[00:00:01] THANK YOU. I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THIS MEETING TO ORDER. [Call to Order] IF YOU COULD PLEASE JOIN US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO JUST TAKE A MOMENT BEFORE WE GO INTO OUR AGENDA. I'M GOING TO BE ASKING EVERYBODY IF WE COULD HAVE A BRIEF MOMENT OF SILENCE. LAST MONTH AT OUR CITY COUNCIL MEETING, CLINTON FORBES, THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR PALM TRAN, WAS HERE TO PRESENT, AND UNFORTUNATELY, HE PASSED AWAY THAT EVENING. SO IT'S IT'S WITH DEEP SADNESS AND HEAVY HEARTS THAT WE WE DO WANT TO DO THIS MOMENT OF SILENCE. HE IS AN ESTEEMED COLLEAGUE. WE MISS HIM A LOCAL CHAMPION, REALLY DOING HIS BEST TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERYBODY, EVERYBODY IN OUR COUNTY HAD ACCESS TO TRANSPORTATION. SO IF YOU GUYS WOULD ALL JUST JOIN ME FOR A MOMENT OF SILENCE, PLEASE. SO THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO REMEMBER HIS CONTRIBUTIONS AND HONOR HIS MEMORY AS AS WE CONTINUE TO PUSH FORWARD WITH TRANSPORTATION AND MOBILITY. WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE ROLL? MAYOR REED HERE. VICE MAYOR WOODS HERE. COUNCIL MEMBER TINSLEY HERE. COUNCIL MEMBER. AMOROSO HERE. COUNCIL MEMBER. MIDDLETON HERE. THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY ADDITIONS, DELETIONS OR MODIFICATIONS THIS EVENING? NO, MA'AM. ALL RIGHT. LOVELY. THANK YOU. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY ANNOUNCEMENTS OR PRESENTATIONS TONIGHT, AND I DON'T HAVE ANY CARDS YET FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA. NONE. OKAY. ALL RIGHT, SO WE'RE MOVING RIGHT ALONG TO THE CITY MANAGER REPORT. [VI. CITY MANAGER REPORT] THANK YOU, MADAM MAYOR. COUNCIL MEMBERS, JUST A COUPLE OF ITEMS TO BRING TO YOUR ATTENTION TODAY. I THOUGHT WAS NOTEWORTHY FOR YOU, FOR YOUR KNOWLEDGE, IN FISCAL YEAR 2223, WE HAVE AN ASSET RECOVERY PROGRAM I'M NOT SURE YOU'RE AWARE OF, BUT JOE CORREA, OUR DEPUTY COMMUNITY SERVICES ADMINISTRATOR, AND HIS STAFF CONDUCTS SELLING MULTIPLE ITEMS OVER THE YEAR. THIS YEAR, 146 SALES OCCURRED FOR $335,000 TO THE CITY. 34 OF THOSE ITEMS WERE FLEET VEHICLES, OF WHICH 229,000 WENT BACK TO OUR RESERVE FUND. SO THAT'S OUR STAFF CONTINUALLY TRYING TO FIND WAYS OF SAVING MONEY. WE HAD 37 OF OUR LEASED VEHICLES THAT TERMINATED THE LEASE. THEY WERE SOLD BY OUR VENDOR, AND THAT RETURNED $744,000 TO THE CITY. WE ALSO COLLECTED AND RECYCLED AND SOLD 44 TONS OF STEEL AND NON-FERROUS METALS TO A SCRAP RECYCLING CENTER, AND WE RECEIVED OVER $10,000 FOR THAT. SO THIS FISCAL YEAR, WE RECEIVED OVER $1 MILLION OF TAKING CARE OF SURPLUS ITEMS, SCRAP METALS AND THOSE THINGS. AND THAT'S ALL DUE TO THE EFFORTS OF OUR FLEET OPERATIONS MANAGER, CHRIS, CHRIS DEHNERT AND ALYSSA ROCHA AND OUR STAFF AT THE FLEET MAINTENANCE OPERATION. SO LIKE I SAID, THIS YEAR THEY'VE RETURNED OVER $1 MILLION TO OUR FLEET MAINTENANCE AND GENERAL FUND. WITH THAT, I'D ALSO LIKE TO CALL TO YOUR ATTENTION THE LOVE SERVING AUTISM. AN ORGANIZATION RECOGNIZED THE TENNIS CENTER AS A PUBLIC TENNIS CENTER OF THE YEAR. SINCE 2018. THESE PROGRAMS, WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO HOST OVER 100 FAMILIES WITH SPECIAL NEEDS THROUGH THIS FACILITY. WE'RE NOW HOSTING PICKLEBALL CLASSES, AND WE ARE THE TRAINING SITE FOR SPECIAL OLYMPICS PICKLEBALL TEAMS. WE ENJOY OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH LOVE SERVING AUTISM, AND LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING THAT RELATIONSHIP AND INCLUSIVENESS OVER THE RACKET SPORTS PROGRAMS. IN ADDITION TO THAT, WE HAVE ALSO FINISHED AND COMPLETED THE ARTISTIC BUS SHELTER ON NORTH MILITARY TRAIL ACROSS FROM PALM BEACH GARDENS HIGH SCHOOL WAS COMPLETED A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO. WE HAVE 17 OF THESE AROUND TOWN AND THREE OTHERS FOR A TOTAL OF 20. [00:05:03] THIS IS AN ONGOING PROGRAM FOR SEVERAL YEARS NOW OF TRYING TO PROVIDE SHADE AND SHELTER FOR THOSE PEOPLE WHO ARE RIDING THE BUS, AND THIS PARTICULAR ONE, IF YOU GO BY MILITARY TRAIL RIGHT AFTER SCHOOL, IT'S REALLY PACKED OVER THERE. AND THEY WERE WITHOUT SHELTER FOR YEARS, SO WE'RE FINALLY ABLE TO GET THEM THAT SHELTER. IN ADDITION TO THAT. WE ARE CURRENTLY HOSTING LIL MO'S TENNIS TOURNAMENT AND IT GOES FROM DECEMBER 1ST THROUGH THE SEVENTH TOMORROW. IT'S THE 17TH ANNUAL EVENT. AGES OF CHILDREN 8 TO 12. THERE ARE OVER 700 PLAYERS PLAYING AT SEVEN DIFFERENT SITES. THEY COME FROM 66 DIFFERENT COUNTRIES, 29 DIFFERENT STATES IN THE USA. THIS TOURNAMENT PROVIDES OUTSTANDING COMPETITION REGIONAL, NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL WHILE ENCOURAGING THE THE PARTICIPANTS TO DEVELOP NEW FRIENDSHIPS, LEARN GOOD SPORTSMANSHIP AND MOST OF ALL, THEY HAVE A LOT OF FUN DOING IT. I KNOW SOME OF YOU ARE OUT THERE, PARTICULARLY AT THE OPENING CEREMONY, WHICH IS VERY SATISFYING TO SEE ALL THOSE YOUNG, ENERGETIC KIDS OUT THERE JUST ALL EXCITED ABOUT PLAYING TENNIS AND WATCHING ALL OF THE DIFFERENT COUNTRIES WALK AROUND IN THE PARADE WITH THEIR FLAG, THEIR COUNTRY'S FLAG. SO THAT'S PRETTY EXCITING. SO THAT'S SOME OF THE THINGS THAT ARE GOING ON AROUND THE CITY, SOME OF THE EVENTS ANYWAY THAT ARE OCCURRING. SO WITH THAT I'LL TURN IT BACK OVER TO YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND YES, THAT WAS THAT WAS ONE OF THE MOST INSPIRING DAYS. IF YOU EVER WANT TO SEE SOMETHING GOOD, GO OUT AND WATCH, YOU KNOW, 600 KIDS WANDERING AROUND PALM BEACH GARDENS. IT WAS WONDERFUL. ALL RIGHT. SO WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ALONG TO THE CONSENT AGENDA. [VII. CONSENT AGENDA] I HAVE NOT HEARD ABOUT ANYTHING BEING PULLED. WE HAVE NOTHING BEING PULLED. SO LET'S GET A MOTION AND A SECOND FOR THE CONSENT AGENDA, PLEASE. I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE. OKAY. SECOND AND BERT. ALL RIGHT. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? ALL RIGHT. THE AYES HAVE IT AND THE MOTION PASSES. MOVING RIGHT ALONG TO OUR PUBLIC HEARINGS. [VIII.a. *ORDINANCE 30, 2023 – (1ST READING) REQUEST FOR VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING, PURSUANT TO A PETITION FOR VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION, EIGHT (8) PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 4.59 ACRES, MORE OR LESS, LOCATED APPROXIMATELY 0.21 MILES SOUTH OF THE INTERSECTION OF PGA BOULEVARD AND ELLISON WILSON ROAD IN PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN AND AS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERETO; DECLARING THAT THE VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION PETITION BEARS THE SIGNATURES OF THE OWNERS OF THE REAL PROPERTY ANNEXED HEREBY; AMENDING ARTICLE II OF THE CITY CHARTER BY REDEFINING THE CORPORATE LIMITS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE PALM BEACH COUNTY CLERK OF COURT, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] TONIGHT, WE ARE HOLDING QUASI JUDICIAL HEARINGS ON THE FOLLOWING CASES. ORDINANCE 30 AT FIRST READING, WHICH IS A REQUEST FOR VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION ORDINANCE 20 2023. SECOND READING AND ADOPTION REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION OF APPROXIMATELY 1,193.58 ACRES. ORDINANCE 21 2023 AT SECOND READING AND ADOPTION REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION OF APPROXIMATELY 20.27 ACRES. ORDINANCE 22 2023 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION OF APPROXIMATELY 31.25 ACRES. ORDINANCE 23 2023 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION OF BOX 32. EXCUSE ME OF APPROXIMATELY 32.92 ACRES. ORDINANCE 24 2023 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION, WHICH IS A REQUEST FOR ANNEXATION FOR APPROXIMATELY 38.71 ACRES. ORDINANCE 26 2023 AT SECOND READING AND ADOPTION, WHICH IS A CITY INITIATED PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT OR PUD REZONING, RESOLUTION 63 2023, WHICH IS A REQUEST FOR MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE IN LEGACY PLACE. RESOLUTION 65 2023, WHICH IS A REQUEST FOR A SITE PLAN AND MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE OF THE APPROVAL OF AVENIR PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT, WHICH IS A PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PCD. AND RESOLUTION 68 2023 AVENIR PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, OR PCD FOR POD 20 REQUESTING APPROVAL FOR MODEL HOMES. THIS MEANS THAT THE CITY COUNCIL IS REQUIRED BY LAW TO BASE ITS DECISION ON THE EVIDENCE CONTAINED IN THE RECORD OF THIS PROCEEDING, WHICH CONSISTS OF THE TESTIMONY OF THE HEARING, THE MATERIALS WHICH ARE IN THE OFFICIAL CITY FILE ON THIS APPLICATION, AND ANY DOCUMENTS PRESENTED DURING THIS HEARING. THE COUNCIL IS ALSO REQUIRED BY LAW TO CROSS EXAMINE. EXCUSE ME. THE COUNCIL IS ALSO REQUIRED BY LAW TO ALLOW CROSS EXAMINATION OF ANY WITNESSES WHO TESTIFY TONIGHT. CROSS EXAMINATION MAY OCCUR AFTER THE STAFF, THE APPLICANT AND OTHER PARTICIPANTS HAVE MADE THEIR PRESENTATIONS AND WILL BE UNTIL THE CONCLUSION OF THE HEARING, IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO RESPOND TO ANY QUESTIONS. EXCUSE ME. WILL BE PERMITTED IN THE ORDER OF THE WITNESSES APPEARANCES. IF YOU GUYS COULD STOP TALKING. IF WE COULD HAVE NO TALKING. AND EVERYONE PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CELL PHONES AS WELL. IT IS NECESSARY THAT ANYONE WHO TESTIFIES AT THE HEARING. SORRY, I'M GOING TO START OVER. CROSS EXAMINATION MAY OCCUR AFTER THE STAFF, THE APPLICANT AND OTHER PARTICIPANTS HAVE MADE THEIR PRESENTATIONS AND WILL BE PERMITTED IN THE ORDER OF THE WITNESSES APPEARANCE. IT IS NECESSARY THAT ANYONE WHO TESTIFIES AT THE HEARING REMAIN UNTIL THE CONCLUSION OF THE HEARING, IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO RESPOND TO ANY QUESTIONS. IF YOU PLAN TO TESTIFY THIS EVENING OR YOU WISH TO OFFER WRITTEN COMMENTS, PLEASE FILL OUT A CARD LOCATED OVER HERE TO MY RIGHT AND GIVE IT TO OUR CITY CLERK OVER HERE ON MY [00:10:02] LEFT. THE CITY CLERK WILL NOW BE SWEARING IN ALL PERSONS WHO INTEND TO OFFER TESTIMONY THIS EVENING ON ANY OF THESE CASES. SO IF YOU HAVE FILLED OUT A COMMENT CARD, YOU WILL NEED TO STAND UP NOW TO BE SWORN IN. THANK YOU. DO YOU SOLEMNLY SWEAR TO TELL THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH, SO HELP YOU GOD? ALL RIGHT. SO WE'RE GOING TO BEGIN WITH ORDINANCE 30 2023. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE ORDINANCE 30 2023 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL, THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING, PURSUANT TO A PETITION FOR VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION, EIGHT PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 4.59 ACRES, MORE OR LESS LOCATED APPROXIMATELY 0.21 MILES SOUTH OF THE INTERSECTION OF PGA BOULEVARD AND ELLISON WILSON ROAD IN PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA. AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN AND AS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERETO. DECLARING THAT THE VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION PETITION BEARS THE SIGNATURES OF THE OWNERS OF THE REAL PROPERTY ANNEXED, HEREBY AMENDING ARTICLE TWO OF THE CITY CHARTER BY REDEFINING THE CORPORATE LIMITS. PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE PALM BEACH COUNTY CLERK OF COURT, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, PROVIDING A CONFLICT CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTY. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. LET'S GO AHEAD AND DECLARE EX PARTY. DOES ANYONE UP HERE HAVE ANY EX PARTY TO DECLARE REGARDING ORDINANCE 30 2023? I DO. ALL RIGHT. GO AHEAD. I SPOKE WITH KATIE RANKIN, JOEY EICHNER AND DAN CATALFAMO. OKAY. ANYONE ELSE DONE FOR ME? NOT FOR ME. ALL RIGHT. I HAVE NONE EITHER. SO WE HAVE BARTON FITTS IS HERE AT OUR PODIUM, OUR PLANNING MANAGER. GOOD EVENING. GOOD EVENING, MADAM MAYOR. MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL, FOR THE RECORD, BARTON FITTS, PLANNING AND ZONING. I HAVE A BRIEF PRESENTATION REGARDING ORDINANCE 30, WHICH IS A VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION PETITION FOR EIGHT PARCELS TOTALING APPROXIMATELY 4.59 ACRES, LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF ELLISON WILSON ROAD, APPROXIMATELY 0.21 MILES SOUTH OF THE INTERSECTION OF PGA BOULEVARD AND ELLISON WILSON DRIVE. THE PARCELS ARE OWNED BY MULTIPLE OWNERS, INCLUDING ARBOR LODGE LLC, DR. RAVI XAVIER, AND THE ARNOLD TRUST HESS TRUST, AND CURRENTLY CONSISTS OF 12 DWELLING UNITS ON THE SOUTH AND VACANT PARCELS ON THE NORTH. NOW BRIEFLY GO OVER EACH OF THE INDIVIDUAL PARCEL GROUPINGS. FIRST, WE HAVE THREE PARCELS IMMEDIATELY SOUTH OF THE RITZ-CARLTON RESIDENCES, OWNED BY ARBOR LODGE, LLC. THESE PARCELS ARE CURRENTLY VACANT AND CONSIST OF APPROXIMATELY 1.79 ACRES. NEXT, WE HAVE ONE PARCEL IMMEDIATELY SOUTH AND WEST OF THE ELLISON WILSON ROAD, EAST OF PROSPERITY HARBOR, NORTH IN THE VILLAGE OF NORTH PALM BEACH, OWNED BY 1125 ELLISON WILSON ROAD LLC, CONSISTING OF 1.11 ACRES, AND IT IS CURRENTLY VACANT AS WELL. NEXT, WE HAVE THE SINGLE PARCEL AT THE END OF THE MELODY LANE, JUST EAST OF THE INTERCOASTAL WATERWAY, OWNED BY THE ARNOLD M HESS TRUST, CONSISTING OF 0.57 ACRES AND THREE DWELLING UNITS. NEXT WE HAVE A SINGLE PARCEL LOCATED AT THE NORTH WEST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF MELODY LANE AND ELLISON WILSON ROAD, CONSISTING OF 0.22 ACRES AND TWO DWELLING UNITS OWNED BY DENISE FORD. AND LAST, WE HAVE TWO PARCELS IMMEDIATELY NORTH OF THE CITY'S FLAG LOT, JUST SOUTH OF MELODY LANE, CONSISTING OF 0.93 ACRES AND SEVEN DWELLING UNITS OWNED BY DR. RAVI XAVIER. THESE PARCELS ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE FLORIDA STATUTES CHAPTER 171 FOR A VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. IT IS WITHIN THE CITY'S FUTURE ANNEXATION AREAS OF INTEREST CITY AND IT MEETS THE CITY'S LEVEL OF SERVICE STANDARDS. WE'LL NOTE THAT THESE PARCELS ARE IN AN EXISTING ENCLAVE, AND THIS VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION REDUCES THE SIZE OF THAT ENCLAVE, AND IT DOES NOT CREATE A NEW ENCLAVE. THIS THE ANNEXATION HAS BEEN DULY NOTICED, BOTH WITH SIGNS ON THE PROPERTY AND MAILERS TO THE TO THE RESIDENTS AS A VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION, THE PETITION WAS SENT TO THE COUNTY AS DIRECTED BY THE COUNTY'S VOLUNTARY ANNEXATION ORDINANCE. THIS PROPERTY IS NOT LOCATED WITHIN THE PALM BEACH COUNTY UNINCORPORATED PROTECTION AREA, AND NO ACTION BY THE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS IS REQUIRED FOR THE ANNEXATION. THIS WILL GO TO THE PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD NEXT WEEK ON DECEMBER 12TH, AND STAFF WILL BRING THEIR RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL AT THE SECOND READING IN JANUARY. STAFF IS RECOMMENDING APPROVAL BASED ON THE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STAFF IS AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU. MARTIN. [00:15:02] JUST LET ME CHECK WITH THE CLERK IF WE RECEIVED ANY COMMENT CARDS REGARDING ORDINANCE 30. NO, MA'AM. ALL RIGHT. WONDERFUL. THANK YOU. SO, SINCE I DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS, I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING. LET'S. A MOTION IS REQUIRED AT THIS TIME. SO COULD I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND. I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 30 2023. ALL RIGHT. MARCY. I'LL SECOND. THANK YOU. DANA. ALL RIGHT. OR DO WE WANT TO BRING IT BACK FOR ANY QUESTIONS OR FURTHER DISCUSSION? ALL RIGHT, MARCY? NO, I THINK IT'S STRAIGHTFORWARD. OKAY. ANY QUESTIONS? ALL RIGHT. A VOTE IS A VOTE WOULD BE NEXT. SO LET'S GO AHEAD. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE, AYE. ANY OPPOSED? ALL RIGHT. AYES HAVE IT. MOTION PASSES. ORDINANCE 30 2023 HAS PASSED. MOVING RIGHT ALONG. [Items VIII.b.- VIII.f.] WE'RE GOING TO MOVE INTO ORDINANCE 20, ORDINANCE 21, ORDINANCE 22, ORDINANCE 23 AND ORDINANCE 24, WHICH WILL BE A COMBINED PRESENTATION THIS EVENING. SINCE THESE ARE ALL QUASI JUDICIAL, WE WILL DO EX PARTE AT THIS TIME. SO DO WE HAVE ANY EX PARTE UP HERE FOR ORDINANCE 2021, 22, 23 OR 24, WHICH IS A COMBINED PRESENTATION? MARCIE. NO. ALL RIGHT. BERT, NO. OUTSIDE OF THE EMAILS THAT HAVE BEEN RECEIVED BY THE CITY. NONE. DANA. NONE FOR ME. ALL RIGHT. CARL ALL RIGHT. ALSO NONE FOR ME. BEFORE I GO INTO ASKING THE CLERK TO READ THE TITLE, WE HAVE FOLKS COMING HERE TONIGHT. SO THIS EVENING, IF YOU'VE FILLED OUT A COMMENT CARD, IF YOU HAVEN'T DONE SO BEFORE, WE DO FOLLOW PARLIAMENTARY PROCEDURE, WHICH IS A METHOD OF MAKING SURE THAT ALL VOICES ARE HEARD, WHETHER IT IS YOURS, ANYONE FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC THAT WISHES TO SPEAK OR OUR COUNCIL OR STAFF OR ANYONE IN ATTENDANCE. SO WE JUST LIKE TO GIVE YOU GUYS A LITTLE BIT OF HOW IT WORKS SO THAT YOU FEEL COMFORTABLE. AND IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE DO LET US KNOW. THIS WILL BE A PUBLIC HEARING AND THERE WILL BE PRESENTATION. THERE WILL BE TESTIMONY, QUESTIONS, ANSWERS, AND DISCUSSION. ABOVE ALL, WE DO ASK PLEASE, FOR MUTUAL RESPECT AND CONSIDERATION BECAUSE THIS MEETING IS IMPORTANT TO ALL OF US. IT'S IMPORTANT TO YOU. IT'S IMPORTANT TO OUR COUNCIL. IT'S IMPORTANT TO OUR STAFF AND THE PEOPLE INVOLVED. AND WE WOULD LIKE IT TO BE CONDUCTED WITH DECORUM BECAUSE OF THAT. SO TO ENSURE THOSE EXPECTATIONS, WE SAY THAT THIS CHAMBER FUNCTIONS MOST EFFECTIVELY AND EFFICIENTLY, EFFICIENTLY BY FOLLOWING RULES OF DECORUM, WHICH IS RESPECTFUL, PROFESSIONAL TONE AT ALL TIMES AND CONDUCT. IF YOU PLAN TO COMMENT PUBLICLY, WE DO ASK YOU TO STATE THAT YOU HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. SO IF YOU HAVE NOT BEEN SWORN IN, THAT OPPORTUNITY WILL BE PROVIDED TO YOU. AGAIN, WE ASK YOU TO STATE YOUR FULL NAME AND ADDRESS FOR THE RECORD, AND WE DO ASK YOU TO MAKE YOUR COMMENTS WITHIN THE ALLOTTED TIME, WHICH IS THREE MINUTES, WHICH IS ABOUT 450 WORDS. SO IF YOU'RE PLANNING TO SPEAK TONIGHT, YOU MAY WANT TO CHECK YOUR NOTES AND MAKE SURE YOU'RE AT ABOUT THAT. YOU WANT TO ADDRESS YOUR COMMENTS TO THE PRESIDING OFFICER, WHICH IS MYSELF, AND NOT TO ANY ONE SINGLE PERSON IN PARTICULAR, WHETHER IT'S A MEMBER OF COUNCIL STAFF OR OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO ARE WITH YOU. WE ASK YOU TO PLEASE BE COURTEOUS AND TO PLEASE BE RESPECTFUL. ALLOW EVERYONE THEIR FULL THREE MINUTES AS NEEDED TO GIVE THEIR COMMENT WITHOUT INTERRUPTION, WITHOUT NOISES, WITHOUT COMMENTS AND GESTURES. WE ALSO ASK YOU TO PLEASE NOT CLAP, CAJOLE OR RIDICULE ANY SPEAKER, WHETHER IT'S A MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC OR COUNCIL OR OUR STAFF. SO AGAIN, WE'RE JUST ASKING FOR COMMON COURTESY. WE PLAN TO GIVE YOU ALL OF THAT, AND WE HOPE TO RECEIVE IT IN RETURN. SO WE'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND HAVE THE CLERK READ THE TITLES. ORDINANCE 20 2223, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT AREA OF UNINCORPORATED REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 1,193.58 ACRES, MORE OR LESS, WHICH INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO THE COMMUNITIES OF CABANA COLONY, CRYSTAL POINT, HIDDEN KEY, FRENCHMAN'S LANDING, PLEASANTRILLIONIDGE, CAPTAINS KEY, MARINER'S COVE AND THE SUB SUBDIVISION. IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171 .0413 FLORIDA STATUTES, SUCH PARCELS BEING GENERALLY LOCATED NORTH OF PGA BOULEVARD, EAST OF ALTERNATE A-1-A, WEST OF LITTLE LAKE WORTH, AND SOUTH OF DONALD ROSS ROAD. AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN AND AS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERETO. AMENDING ARTICLE TWO OF THE CITY CHARTER TO REDEFINE THE CORPORATE LIMITS PURSUANT TO INVOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. CALLING A REFERENDUM ON THE QUESTION OF ANNEXATION FOR THE REGISTERED ELECTORS WITHIN THE PROPERTY PROPOSED FOR ANNEXATION. PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE FLORIDA GOVERNOR'S OFFICE, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTY. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. WE'LL GO AHEAD AND STARTING WITH ORDNANCE 20 AND WE'LL BE DOING EX PARTE. [00:20:01] SO DO WE HAVE ANY EX PARTE FOR ORDNANCE 20 2122 2324. AND I'LL ASK YOU AGAIN WITH EACH TITLE IS READ. ANYONE HAVE ANY EX PARTE FOR THESE? NO. ALL RIGHT. SO WE HAVE MARTIN FITZ AVAILABLE FOR OUR PODIUM PRESENTATION. GOOD EVENING ONCE AGAIN, MADAM MAYOR. MEMBERS OF THE BOARD. FOR THE RECORD, MY NAME IS MARTIN FITZ. PLANNING AND ZONING AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. THIS IS THE SECOND READING FOR THE ANNEXATION ORDINANCES. I WILL HAVE A COMBINED PRESENTATION. THIS WILL BE ESSENTIALLY THE SAME PRESENTATION THAT WE MADE LAST MONTH, BUT FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE PUBLIC WHO MAY NOT HAVE BEEN HERE AT THAT TIME, WILL BE MAKING THE SAME PRESENTATION. AGAIN. THIS IS A REQUEST FOR A CITY INITIATED PETITIONS TO PLACE ANNEXATION REFERENDUMS ON THE BALLOT IN FIVE AREAS, TO ALLOW THE RESIDENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE ON WHETHER OR NOT THEY WOULD LIKE TO ANNEX INTO THE CITY. REFERENDUM. ANNEXATION IS GOVERNED BY CHAPTER 171 OF FLORIDA STATUTES, WHICH PROVIDES ESTABLISHES THE CHARACTER OF THE AREAS PROPOSED TO BE ANNEXED, ESTABLISHES THE PROCESS FOR THE REFERENDUM ANNEXATION, AND ESTABLISHES THE PUBLIC NOTICE REQUIREMENTS FOR ANNEXATION. FLORIDA STATUTE REQUIRES THAT EVERY AREA THAT'S PROPOSED TO BE ANNEXED MUST BE CONTIGUOUS, COMPACT, AND NOT IN ANOTHER MUNICIPALITY AT THE TIME THAT THE ANNEXATION PROCESS BEGINS. FLORIDA STATUTES FURTHER DEFINES CONTIGUOUS AS A SUBSTANTIAL PART OF A BOUNDARY FOR THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED SHARES A BOUNDARY WITH THE ANNEXING MUNICIPALITY TO BE COMPACT. THE AREA IS DEFINED AS A CONCENTRATION OF PROPERTY IN A SINGLE AREA THAT DOES NOT CREATE AN ENCLAVE OR A POCKET OF UNINCORPORATED LAND, OR A FINGER OR SERPENTINE PATTERN. BUT WHAT DOES THAT MEAN? WELL, FLORIDA STATUTES ALSO DEFINES AN ENCLAVE AS AN AREA OF ANY UNINCORPORATED AREA THAT IS ENCLOSED WITHIN AND BOUNDED ON ALL SIDES BY A SINGLE MUNICIPALITY OR AN AREA THAT IS ENCLOSED WITHIN AND BOUNDED BY A SINGLE MUNICIPALITY, AND A NATURAL OR MANMADE OBSTACLE THAT ALLOWS THE PASSAGE OF VEHICULAR TRAFFIC TO THAT UNINCORPORATED AREA ONLY THROUGH THE MUNICIPALITY. HERE I HAVE SOME EXAMPLES OF WHAT AN ENCLAVE ACTUALLY IS. SO ON THE LEFT WE HAVE AN AREA THAT IS COMPLETELY SURROUNDED BY THE MUNICIPALITY, SHOWN IN GREEN. THIS IS AREA FIVE, THE MONET GARDENS AREA. ON THE RIGHT WE HAVE AN AREA THAT EXEMPLIFIES THE SECOND TYPE OF ENCLAVE. THIS IS THE HIDDEN KEY AREA. AS YOU CAN SEE, PALM BEACH GARDENS SIGNIFIED IN GREEN SHIRTS, HAS THE BOUNDARY ON THE WEST AND THE SOUTH, AND ON THE NORTH AND EAST. THE COMMUNITY IS BOUNDED BY WATER, SO THE VEHICULAR TRAFFIC CAN ONLY ACCESS THROUGH THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. FURTHER, THE STATE STATUTES IDENTIFIES ENCLAVES AS A SIGNIFICANT PROBLEM IN THE PLANNING AND GROWTH MANAGEMENT, AS WELL AS PROVIDING SERVICES IN AN EFFICIENT MANNER, AND AS SUCH, FLORIDA STATUTES SPECIFIES SPECIFICALLY DECLARES THAT IT IS THE POLICY OF THE STATE TO ELIMINATE ENCLAVES WHENEVER POSSIBLE. AS SUCH, MULTIPLE ENCLAVES HAVE BEEN INCLUDED WITHIN THE ANNEXATION AREAS IN ORDER TO BE CONSISTENT WITH FLORIDA STATUTES. SECONDLY, WE HAVE I WANTED TO GIVE AN EXAMPLE OF A POCKET OF UNINCORPORATED LAND. A POCKET OF UNINCORPORATED LAND IS ANY AREA THAT IS COMPLETELY ENCLOSED WITHIN AND BORDERED ON ALL SIDES BY TWO OR MORE MUNICIPALITIES, WHICH DIFFERENTIATES IT FROM AN ENCLAVE. HERE WE HAVE AN EXAMPLE WHICH IS THE. IN AREA FOUR. THIS IS THE MLK DAYCARE PROPERTY. AS YOU CAN SEE, IT IS COMPLETELY SURROUNDED, IN THIS CASE BY THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS AND NORTH PALM BEACH, AND FINALLY A FINGER OR SERPENTINE PATTERN. A MUNICIPALITY CANNOT FOLLOW A RIGHT OF WAY OR A NARROW STRIP OF LAND IN ORDER TO ANNEX A PARTICULAR PARCEL. IN ADDITION TO BEING CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT. FLORIDA STATUTES DEFINES THAT OR REQUIRES THAT THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED MUST BE DEVELOPED FOR URBAN PURPOSES. CHAPTER 171 043 PROVIDES SEVERAL WAYS IN WHICH THAT CAN BE DETERMINED, INCLUDING, AS I'VE INDICATED, SUBSECTION A WITH A TOTAL RESIDENT POPULATION EQUAL TO AT LEAST TWO PERSONS FOR EACH ACRE OF LAND. AS I GO THROUGH THE PRESENTATION, I'LL SHOW HOW EACH OF THE AREAS MEETS THIS CRITERIA AS PART OF THE REFERENDUM. ANNEXATION. THE CITY IS REQUIRED TO PREPARE AN ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY. THE STUDY PROVIDES DOCUMENTATION THAT THAT THE AREA MEETS THE CRITERIA SET FORTH BY FLORIDA STATUTES. ADDITIONALLY, IT DOES A REVIEW OF THE CURRENT STATUS OF ALL PUBLIC SERVICES PROVIDED BY THE CITY, SUCH AS POLICE, FIRE, PARKS, AND RECREATION IN THE PROPOSED [00:25:01] AREA, AND IDENTIFY WHAT WOULD BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THOSE SAME LEVEL OF SERVICE FOR THOSE PUBLIC SERVICES IN THE AREA PROPOSED TO BE ANNEXED, AS IS PROVIDED TO THE REST OF THE CITY, WITHOUT REDUCING THAT OVERALL LEVEL OF SERVICE. AND FINALLY, IT MAKES A DETERMINATION AS TO WHETHER OR NOT THE ANNEXATION IS FEASIBLE FOR THE CITY. SO THIS IS AS MENTIONED, THIS IS A WE'RE PROPOSING FIVE DIFFERENT ANNEXATION AREAS SIGNIFIED ON THE MAP SHOWN. AND THESE PROPOSED ANNEXATION AREAS WILL ALLOW THE CITY TO REMOVE GAPS IN THE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY AND ALSO EXTEND THE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY TO LOGICAL NATURAL STOPPING POINTS SUCH AS THE INTERCOASTAL WATERWAY, LITTLE LAKE WORTH, AND ALSO THE NEIGHBORING MUNICIPAL BOUNDARIES. WE HAVE FIVE SEPARATE AREAS, AND CONSISTENT WITH STATE STATUTES, WE HAVE FIVE SEPARATE ORDINANCES AND EACH WILL HAVE FIVE DIFFERENT REFERENDUMS. THIS BASICALLY MEANS THAT THE PEOPLE IN AREA ONE WILL VOTE FOR THEIR REFERENDUM, AND THAT VOTE WILL HAVE NO IMPACT ON ANY OF THE OTHER AREAS, AND VICE VERSA. A LITTLE SUMMARY OF THE DEMOGRAPHICS FOR THE AREA. ALL TOLD, WE HAVE APPROXIMATELY 3500 PARCELS AND JUST UNDER 4000 DWELLING UNITS, WHICH EQUATES TO ABOUT 8300 POTENTIAL RESIDENTS AND A TOTAL OF JUST OVER 1300 ACRES. THE LAND USES ARE PRIMARILY RESIDENTIAL, WITH SINGLE FAMILY AND MULTI-FAMILY, AS WELL AS COMMERCIAL ALONG THE THE US ONE AND ALTERNATE A-1-A CORRIDORS, AS WELL AS LIMITED PUBLIC AND INSTITUTIONAL USES. NOW I'LL GO OVER EACH OF THE FIVE AREAS AND PROVIDE THE RESULTS OF THE ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY. THERE WILL BE A LITTLE BIT OF REPETITION. I APOLOGIZE, BUT I WILL GO MORE IN DEPTH IN AREA ONE TO PROVIDE SOME BACKGROUND, AND THEN WE'LL BE ABLE TO MOVE FASTER THROUGH THE OTHERS. AREA ONE IS SHOWN ON THE MAP OUTLINED IN RED. IT CONSISTS OF JUST UNDER 1200 ACRES WITH 3600 DWELLING UNITS, APPROXIMATELY 7600 RESIDENTS. IT IS PRIMARILY RESIDENTIAL IN NATURE, WITH SINGLE FAMILY AND MULTI-FAMILY AS PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED. THERE IS COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS ALONG US ONE AND ALTERNATE A-1-A. THERE ARE ADDITIONAL INSTITUTIONAL USES, INCLUDING TWO CHURCHES, TWO PARKS, A SCHOOL, AND CONSERVATION LAND OWNED BY PALM BEACH COUNTY. IF YOU'LL NOTICE IN THE MAP, THE THE CITY'S MUNICIPAL AREA IS INDICATED WITH THE GREEN DASHED LINES. AS YOU CAN SEE, THE CITY'S BOUNDARY MAP ALIGNS WITH THE WESTERN BOUNDARY OF THE ANNEXATION AREA, AS WELL AS THE SOUTHERN BOUNDARY, AND ALSO A SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF THE NORTH AND SOUTH, NORTH AND EAST BOUNDARIES AS WELL. THE FUTURE. LAND USE FOR THE AREA IS, AS MENTIONED, PREDOMINANTLY RESIDENTIAL, WITH LOW RESIDENTIAL TWO AND THREE UNITS PER ACRE, AS TYPIFIED BY HIDDEN KEY, CAPTAINS QUAY AND WINDSOR ESTATES, AS WELL AS MEDIUM RESIDENTIAL WITH FIVE UNITS PER ACRE, WHICH IS TYPIFIED BY CABANA COLONY AND PLEASANT RIDGE. THE COMMERCIAL PARCELS ARE, AS MENTIONED, ALONG THE CORRIDORS, AS WELL AS INSTITUTIONAL USES SUCH AS EISENHOWER ELEMENTARY AND INDUSTRIAL FOR SEMINOLE MARINE. THE CURRENT ZONING IS PRIMARILY SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL, SUCH AS CRYSTAL POINT, FRENCHMAN'S LANDING, AND HIDDEN QUAY, AS WELL AS MULTIFAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY. CABANA COLONY AND PLEASANT RIDGE. THE GENERAL COMMERCIAL AND ALSO LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ROUND THINGS OUT THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENT. THIS AREA MEETS THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS FOR ANNEXATION BY BEING CONTIGUOUS ON TWO COMPLETE SIDES. IT'S REASONABLY COMPACT AND IS NOT WITHIN ANOTHER JURISDICTION. IT ALSO MEETS THE CRITERIA FOR SUBSECTION A BY HAVING 6.43 PERSONS PER ACRE AS PART OF THE FEASIBILITY STUDY. WE DID A LEVEL OF SERVICE ANALYSIS FOR THE THE PUBLIC SERVICES PROVIDED BY THE CITY. ONE OF THOSE IS POTABLE WATER. THIS AREA IS WITHIN THE SEACOAST UTILITY AUTHORITY OR SWA SERVICE AREA. CENTRAL WATER IS PROVIDED OR AVAILABLE TO THE AREA THROUGH SEA, COAST OR PRIVATE SYSTEMS. THERE ARE A NUMBER OF COMMUNITIES THAT ARE CURRENTLY SERVICED THROUGH PRIVATE WELLS, AND THESE MAY CONTINUE CONSISTENT WITH THE STANDARDS OF THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. ADDITIONALLY, THIS IS WITHIN THE SEA COAST SERVICE AREA FOR SANITARY SEWER AND AGAIN, THE MAJORITY OF THE AREA HAS SANITARY SEWER EITHER PROVIDED THROUGH SEA COAST OR FROM PRIVATE SYSTEMS. SOME OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD NEIGHBORHOODS ALSO HAVE SEPTIC TANKS, WHICH AGAIN MAY CONTINUE TO HAVE THOSE AS CONSISTENT WITH FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH STANDARDS. I WILL NOTE THAT THERE ARE CENTRAL LINES, BOTH FOR WATER AND SEWER, IN THE VICINITY OF ALL THESE NEIGHBORHOODS, SHOULD THEY CHOOSE TO EXTEND SERVICE IN THE FUTURE. [00:30:08] THE CITY'S PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT HAS ESTABLISHED A LEVEL OF SERVICE STANDARD OF FIVE ACRES PER 1000 RESIDENTS. THE CITY CURRENTLY HAS 569 ACRES OF PARK SPACE, WITH THE PROJECTED POPULATION FOR AREA ONE. FOLLOWING ANNEXATION OF AREA ONE WOULD BE AROUND 66,500 RESIDENTS, WHICH WOULD REQUIRE 332.91 ACRES. THE CITY HAS SUFFICIENT RECREATION SPACE TO MEET THE LEVEL OF SERVICE WITHOUT REQUIRING ANY ADDITIONAL AREAS. NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES IS MORE COMMONLY KNOWN IN OTHER AREAS AS CODE ENFORCEMENT. THE CITY WOULD REQUIRE, DUE TO THE ADDITIONAL AREA, THE CITY WOULD NEED TO ADD ADDITIONAL PERSONNEL, VEHICLES, AND EQUIPMENT WITH AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $400,000. THE POLICE HAS ESTABLISHED A LEVEL OF SERVICE STANDARD BASED ON CALLS FOR SERVICE, AND GENERALLY EQUATES TO TWO OFFICERS PER 1000 RESIDENTS. BASED ON THE PROJECTED POPULATION, THIS WOULD REQUIRE ADDING 18 ADDITIONAL OFFICERS AS WELL AS THE EQUIPMENT AND VEHICLES TO SERVE THOSE OFFICERS. THIS HAS AN ANTICIPATED FIRST YEAR COST OF $3.08 MILLION. HOWEVER, DUE TO THE THE NATURE OF THE UPFRONT COSTS FOR VEHICLES AND EQUIPMENT, THE FOLLOWING YEARS ARE ANTICIPATED TO HAVE A LOWER COST FOR FIRE RESCUE. THE AREAS TO THE WEST OF THE INTERCOASTAL WATERWAY ARE CURRENTLY WITHIN THE PALM BEACH GARDENS FIRE RESCUE SERVICE AREA, AND PALM BEACH GARDENS IS GENERALLY THE FIRST CALL FOR CALLS FOR SERVICE IN THIS AREA. THE CITY ALSO SERVICES THE EAST SIDE OF THE INTERCOASTAL WATERWAY THROUGH AN AUTOMATIC AID AGREEMENT WITH NORTH PALM BEACH AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, AND THIS WILL CONTINUE WOULD CONTINUE AFTER THE ANNEXATION BASED ON THE AUTOMATIC AID AGREEMENTS. NO ADDITIONAL COSTS ARE ANTICIPATED FOR FIRE RESCUE SERVICE. PUBLIC SERVICES PROVIDES FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF THE CITY GENERALLY, SUCH AS THE ROAD AND SIDEWALK MAINTENANCE, STREET SWEEPING, AND STORM AND CANAL MAINTENANCE. THE ANTICIPATED FIRST YEAR COSTS ARE $276,000. I WILL NOTE THAT THE. IT IS ANTICIPATED THAT A TRANSFER OF 17 ACRES ACRES OF CANAL RIGHT AWAY WOULD BE WOULD RESULT FROM THE ANNEXATION, AND THAT THOSE WOULD BE ADDED TO THE CITY'S MAINTENANCE WORK PROGRAM IN FUTURE YEARS. THE CITY PAYS FOR SOLID WASTE PICKUP FOR THE RESIDENTS AS A RESULT OF THE INCREASE IN IN RESIDENCES IN THE AREA. THERE IS AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $537,000. GENERAL GOVERNMENT SERVICES INCLUDES ALL OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE, FINANCE IT CLERK SERVICES. AND THERE IS AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $268,000 FOR AREA ONE. A SUMMARY OF THE. THE ESTIMATED COSTS FOR AREA ONE IS $6.5 MILLION. THE ESTIMATED FIRST YEAR REVENUES, OR REVENUES FOR THE ANNEXATION ARE RESULTING FROM AD VALOREM TAXES, THE FRANCHISE FEES AND COMMUNICATION SERVICES TAX, AND THE GAS TAX, WHICH PRIMARILY PAYS FOR ROAD REPAIRS AND MAINTENANCE. THE TOTAL ANTICIPATED FIRST YEAR REVENUE IS $8.7 MILLION, WHICH RESULTS IN A NET ANTICIPATED BENEFIT FOR AREA ONE OF $2.1 MILLION. AREA TWO CONSISTS OF THE PARCELS THAT ARE SOUTH OF THE PREVIOUS RITZ-CARLTON PROPERTIES THAT ARE ON THE WEST SIDE OF ELLISON WILSON ROAD AND EAST OF THE INTERCOASTAL WATERWAY. CONSISTS OF 20.27 ACRES AND APPROXIMATELY 74 DWELLING UNITS AND 157 RESIDENTS. IT IS DEVELOPED PRIMARILY AS SINGLE FAMILY AND MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL. IT HAS. THE AREAS HAVE A FUTURE LAND USE OF LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL WITH THREE UNITS PER ACRE, NORTH OF THE CITY'S FLAG LOT AND HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL WITH 12 UNITS PER ACRE SOUTH OF THE FLAG LOT. ALL OF THE PARCELS HAVE A ZONING OF MULTIFAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY. HOWEVER, THIS AREA MEETS THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS FOR ANNEXATION BY BEING CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT, AND MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS OF SUBSECTION A BY HAVING 7.74 PERSONS PER ACRE. THIS AREA IS WITHIN THE SEA COAST SERVICE AREA FOR WATER AND SEWER, AND CENTRAL WATER IS PROVIDED OR AVAILABLE FOR ALL ALL PARCELS. THERE IS NO ADDITIONAL PERSONNEL, VEHICLES OR EQUIPMENT ANTICIPATED FOR NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES, PARKS AND RECREATION, POLICE, FIRE, PUBLIC SERVICES OR GENERAL GOVERNMENT. HOWEVER, THERE WILL BE AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $4,000 FOR THE INCREASE IN TRASH PICKUP, WHICH IS AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $4,000. ESTIMATED FIRST YEAR REVENUES ARE $195,000, RESULTING IN AN ANTICIPATED NET BENEFIT OF $191,000. [00:35:03] ANNEXATION. AREA THREE IS MORE COMMONLY KNOWN AS PIRATE COVE. AS YOU CAN. IT IS. AS YOU CAN SEE ON THE MAP, IT IS CONTIGUOUS TO THE CITY'S BOUNDARY ON THE WEST NORTH, AND THE MAJORITY OF THE EAST BOUNDARY CONSISTS OF 31.25 ACRES AND 63 DWELLING UNITS WITH 134 RESIDENTS, AND IT IS DEVELOPED EXCLUSIVELY AS SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL. THE AREA HAS A LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL THREE UNITS PER ACRE. LAND USE AND ZONING. SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL. IT MEETS THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS FOR ANNEXATION BY BEING CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT, AND HAS 4.29 PERSONS PER ACRE. AGAIN, THIS IS WITHIN THE SERVICE AREA FOR SEA COAST UTILITY AUTHORITY AND CENTRAL WATER IS EITHER PROVIDED OR IN PLACE FOR THE EXCUSE ME IS EITHER PROVIDED OR AVAILABLE FOR ALL OF THE PARCELS, AS IS SANITARY SEWER. AGAIN, NO PERSONNEL, VEHICLES OR EQUIPMENT ARE ANTICIPATED FOR NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES, PARKS AND RECREATION. POLICE AND FIRE. PUBLIC SERVICES, HOWEVER, DOES ANTICIPATE A COST OF $12,000 AND AS WELL AS A $9,000 COST FOR THE INCREASE IN SOLID WASTE PICKUP, RESULTING IN AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $21,000 FOR AREA THREE ESTIMATED FIRST YEAR REVENUES OF $316,000, WITH THE NET BENEFIT OF $295,000. AREA FOUR IS CONSISTS OF THE NEIGHBORHOODS OF MONET ACRES, MONET HEIGHTS, THE KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS BUILDING, AND THE DAYCARE. AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE MAP, THE MAJORITY OF THE AREA IS AN EXISTING ENCLAVE, AND THE MLK DAYCARE, AS PREVIOUSLY NOTED, IS A POCKET OF UNINCORPORATED LAND, CONSISTS OF 32.92 ACRES AND 71 DWELLING UNITS WITH 151 RESIDENTS. IT IS DEVELOPED AS SINGLE FAMILY AND MOBILE HOME RESIDENTIAL, A PLACE OF ASSEMBLY AND DAYCARE. USES. IT HAS A LOW RESIDENTIAL ONE AND THREE UNITS PER ACRE FOR MONET HEIGHTS AND THE DAYCARE AND THE HIGH RESIDENTIAL, WITH 12 UNITS PER ACRE FOR MONET ACRES AND THE KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS BUILDING. THE ZONING IS SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL FOR FOR ALL BUT MONET ACRES, AND MONET ACRES HAS A MULTIFAMILY HIGH DENSITY. THIS MEETS THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS FOR BY BEING CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT, AND IT HAS 4.93 PERSONS PER ACRE. THE AREA IS WITHIN THE SEA COAST UTILITY AUTHORITY SERVICE AREA FOR WATER AND SEWER. HOWEVER, MONET ACRES HAS A PRIVATE WATER SYSTEM AND A PRIVATE LIFT STATION IN PLACE. MONET HEIGHTS IS SERVICED BY PRIVATE WELLS AND AND SEPTIC TANKS, AND THOSE MAY CONTINUE WITH THE AS PERMITTED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. WATER MAINS ARE LOCATED ALONG RCA BOULEVARD AND PROSPERITY FARMS, AS ARE SANITARY SEWER. SHOULD THE NEIGHBORS NEIGHBORHOODS WISH TO CONNECT IN THE FUTURE. NO ADDITIONAL PERSONNEL, VEHICLES OR EQUIPMENT ARE REQUIRED FOR PARKS AND RECREATION, NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES, POLICE AND FIRE, OR GENERAL GOVERNMENT. HOWEVER, THERE IS AN ANTICIPATED COST OF $8,000 FOR PUBLIC SERVICES AND $12,000 FOR PUBLIC WASTE OR SOLID WASTE, WHICH RESULTS IN $20,000 FOR ANTICIPATED COSTS. ANTICIPATED REVENUES ARE $101,000, RESULTING IN A NET ANTICIPATED BENEFIT OF $81,000. ANNEXATION AREA FIVE. IT'S THE LAST ONE. THIS IS THE AREA OF MONET GARDENS. THIS IS AN EXISTING ENCLAVE. AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE MAP, IT'S COMPLETELY SURROUNDED BY THE CITY. CONSISTING OF 38.71 ACRES, 113 DWELLING UNITS, 240 RESIDENTS. AND IT IS ALMOST COMPLETELY BUILT OUT AS SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL. IT HAS A LOW RESIDENTIAL, TWO UNITS PER ACRE LAND USE WITH A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ZONING. IT DOES COMPACT AND CONTIGUOUS AND 6.2 PERSONS PER ACRE. AGAIN, THIS AREA IS WITHIN THE SEA COAST SERVICE AREA FOR WATER AND SEWER. HOWEVER, THESE PARCELS ARE ALL SERVICED CURRENTLY BY PRIVATE WELLS AND SEPTIC TANKS, AND THEY MAY CONTINUE TO DO SO AS PERMITTED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. WATER MAINS AND SEWER MAINS ARE LOCATED IN THE VICINITY SHOULD THEY CHOOSE TO CONNECT IN THE FUTURE. NO ADDITIONAL PERSONNEL, VEHICLES OR EQUIPMENT ARE ANTICIPATED FOR PARKS AND RECREATION, NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES, POLICE AND FIRE OR GENERAL GOVERNMENT PUBLIC SERVICES ANTICIPATES $12,000 AND SOLID WASTE WOULD BE $10,000, FOR A TOTAL OF $22,000. ANTICIPATED COSTS, FIRST YEAR REVENUES OF $116,000 AND A NET ANTICIPATED BENEFIT OF $94,000. [00:40:01] NOW A BRIEF SUMMARY. THE EACH OF THE AREAS MEETS THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS BY BEING CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT, AS WELL AS MEETING THE CRITERIA FOR SUBSECTION A BY HAVING RESIDENTIAL DENSITY OF MORE THAN TWO PERSONS PER ACRE. SO WITH THE REFERENDUM PROCESS, AS MENTIONED, THE CITY PREPARED AN ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDIES FOR EACH AREA INDIVIDUALLY SINCE WE DON'T KNOW WHICH AREAS MAY COME IN. SO WE WANTED TO TO DETERMINE EACH ONE SEPARATELY. THE FEASIBILITY STUDY WAS FILED WITH THE PALM BEACH COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON OCTOBER 17TH, MORE THAN 15 DAYS PRIOR TO THE COMMENCING THE THE ANNEXATION PROCEDURES CONSISTENT WITH STATE STATUTES. ADDITIONALLY, MAILERS WERE SENT TO ALL RESIDENTS AND OWNERS IN THE ANNEXATION AREAS ON OCTOBER 19TH, MORE THAN TEN DAYS PRIOR TO THE FIRST HEARING. AGAIN CONSISTENT WITH FLORIDA STATUTES. THIS IS THE SECOND READING OF THE ANNEXATION ORDINANCES. THE REFERENDUMS WILL BE HELD ON MARCH 19TH, 2020 FOR THE REGISTERED VOTERS WITHIN EACH AREA WILL VOTE FOR THEIR AREA ALONE, AND A SIMPLE MAJORITY OF THOSE THAT VOTE FOR THE REFERENDUM WILL DECIDE THE VOTE. FOLLOWING ANNEXATION, THE ANNEXATION WILL BECOME EFFECTIVE ON DECEMBER 1ST, 2024. I WILL NOTE THAT THIS IS DIFFERENT FROM THE FROM WHAT WAS INCLUDED IN THE FIRST PRESENTATION. THE EFFECTIVE DATE WAS CHANGED AT THE REQUEST OF THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS, SO THAT THERE WOULD BE NO IMPACT ON THE GENERAL ELECTION IN NOVEMBER. AFTER THE ANNEXATION, THE CITY WILL ASSIGN A COMPARABLE LAND USE AND ZONING. I WILL NOTE THAT THE COUNTY'S CODES WILL REMAIN IN EFFECT UNTIL THE NEW CODES ARE ASSIGNED THE CITY. CITY STAFF WILL SURVEYED THE ROADS, SIDEWALKS, CANALS AND DRAINAGE TO DETERMINE THE THEIR CURRENT STATE AND WILL INCORPORATE THOSE INTO THE CITY'S WORK PROGRAM AS APPROPRIATE. THE CITY HAS ENGAGED IN NUMEROUS COMMUNITY OUTREACH EFFORTS, INCLUDING A PUBLIC INFORMATION MEETING ON OCTOBER 26TH. WE HAVE HAD MULTIPLE MEETINGS WITH PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATIONS, NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS AND MORE ARE CONTINUING TO BE SCHEDULED. WE'VE HAD MULTIPLE SITE VISITS, AND AS NOTED, WE SENT MAILERS TO THE PROPERTY OWNERS AND RESIDENTS, AS WELL AS ADS IN THE PALM BEACH POST IN COORDINATION WITH PALM BEACH COUNTY. THIS AREA IS NOT WITHIN THE PALM BEACH COUNTY UNINCORPORATED PROTECTION AREA, AND A ACTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IS NOT REQUIRED FOR A REFERENDUM. ANNEXATION, AND THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLICLY NOTICED, BOTH WITH MAILERS AND ADS RUN IN THE PALM BEACH POST. AND THIS CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION. THANK YOU MARTIN. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO COMMENT CARDS FOR JUST THIS ORDINANCE ALONE. ORDINANCE 20. WE HAVE ABOUT TWO HOURS WORTH OF COMMENT CARDS THIS EVENING. EVERYONE WILL BE ALLOTTED THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK. IF YOU FIND THAT WHAT YOU'RE ABOUT TO SAY IS EXACTLY WHAT EVERYBODY ELSE IS SAYING IN. FRONT OF YOU. IT IS OKAY FOR YOU TO SAY I AM REITERATING WHAT THE PERSON IN FRONT OF ME JUST SAID. IF YOU'RE MAKING THE SAME POINTS OVER AND OVER AGAIN FOR THE SAKE OF BREVITY, SO THAT WE CAN MAKE SURE EVERYBODY HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK, FEEL FREE TO JUST SAY THAT YOU REITERATE WHAT THE PERSON IN FRONT OF YOU SAID, AND ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS THAT YOU FEEL ARE APPROPRIATE TO ADD SO THAT EVERYONE HAS THEIR TIME. SO THE FIRST PERSON WE'RE GOING TO BE CALLING UP WILL BE KATHERINE MURRAY. THANK YOU. WOULD YOU MIND COMING UP TO THE PODIUM AND YOU'LL STATE YOUR NAME, YOUR ADDRESS, AND IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS KATHERINE MURRAY. MY ADDRESS IS 11597 LANDING PLACE. AND YES, I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN AND I THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME BEFORE YOU THIS EVENING WITH PRETTY MUCH THE SAME PRESENTATION THAT I HAD LAST MONTH. I STRONGLY FEEL THAT ZONE ONE DOES NOT MEET THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE FLORIDA STATUTE. 171 IN THE FOLLOWING CASES, THE COMPACTNESS IN ZONE ONE IS NOT COMPACT, NOT EVEN CLOSE, AT 1,193.58 ACRES WITH MULTIPLE USES, IT HAS A GREAT DIVERSITY IN LAND USE, ZONING, DENSITY, PUBLIC, PRIVATE, COMMERCIAL, EDUCATIONAL, SPIRITUAL, PARKS, AND SO MANY OTHER USES. THIS IS NOT AND IT CAN'T BE. IT'S JUST A TOO FAR REACH TO SAY THAT ZONE ONE IS A COMPACT AREA. I ALSO THINK THAT ZONE ONE IS NOT AN ENCLAVE. [00:45:04] ESPECIALLY HIDDEN KEY IS DEFINITELY NOT AN ENCLAVE. IN THIS INSTANCE, IT HAS A BREAK IN CONTINUITY WITH A ROADWAY COMING THROUGH THE CENTER, THE ENTRANCE, AND THAT ROADWAY IS NOT COMING THROUGH PALM BEACH GARDENS, BUT IS OWNED BY NORTHERN PALM BEACH COUNTY IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. IT ALSO LACKS CLEAR AND SUBSTANTIAL CONTIGUOUS NESS. I MIGHT ALSO NOTE THAT PALM BEACH COUNTY VOTED OR OR MADE A RESOLUTION THAT THEIR PROPERTIES SHOULD ALSO BE TAKEN OUT OF THIS ANNEXATION PROCESS, AS PALM BEACH GARDENS HAS WISHED FOR A LONG TIME TO ANNEX HIDDEN KEY. OVER THE MANY DECADES I HAVE LIVED IN THE AREA, THE COMMUNITY HAS POLITELY AND STRONGLY DECLINED. THIS EFFORT IS MORE OF A LAND GRAB WORTH MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO PALM BEACH GARDENS, AS PRESENTED IN THE PRESENTATION YOU JUST HAD FROM PLANNING. I BELIEVE IF PALM BEACH GARDENS WISHES TO HEAR OUR VOTE AS A YES OR NO, YOU SHOULD SEPARATE HIDDEN KEY FROM ZONE ONE, ALLOWING A TRUE AND GENUINE REFLECTION OF THE VOTERS DESIRE. THIS PROCESS OF BUNDLING MULTIPLE NEIGHBORHOODS AND USES IS AN OBVIOUS ATTEMPT TO FORCEFULLY OVERRULE THE CITIZENS RIGHTS AND DESIRES. I FRANKLY ANTICIPATE THE MAJORITY OF THOSE IN ZONE ONE WILL OPPOSE THE ANNEXATION. THIS IS YOUR LAST OPPORTUNITY TO SEPARATE HIDDEN KEY, ALLOW US TO PRESENT OUR OWN DESTINY AND GIVE US THE RIGHT TO VOTE YES OR NO. BUT THANK YOU FOR THE INVITATION ANYWAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. MOVING ALONG. OH, SORRY. I'M GOING TO CALL THE NEXT NAME AND THEN THE PERSON WHO WILL BE COMING AFTER THAT SO THAT YOU CAN GET READY TO COME RIGHT UP TO THE PODIUM. SO NEXT WE HAVE DENNIS MEDARIS WILL BE FOLLOWED BY DARLENE JONES. DENNIS. COME ON UP TO THE PODIUM, PLEASE, SIR. NAME? IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN. YOUR ADDRESS. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS DENNIS MEDARIS. ADDRESS IS 13457 WILLIAM MYERS COURT, PALM BEACH GARDENS. AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. SO ON TO DISCUSS A LITTLE SOMETHING OF CONCERN HERE. AND I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S WELL UNDERSTOOD THAT NOTHING IS BEING ALLEGED OR INSINUATED THAT THERE WAS ANY IMPROPER OR MISINFORMATION INTENTIONALLY PROVIDED. OKAY, SO LET ME GET THAT UP FRONT. SO I WANTED THE ITEM I WANT TO ADDRESS IS TAXATION HERE I WAS AT THE OCTOBER 26TH MEETING HERE IN THIS IN THIS HALLWAY HERE IN CITY HALL. AND AT THAT MEETING I MET WITH THE FINANCE FOLKS, AND THEY WERE VERY NICE, VERY HELPFUL AND SO FORTH. AND I WAS VERBALLY AND PHYSICALLY PRESENTED WITH OUR MY TAXES FOR MY PROPERTY IN CRYSTAL POINT. BOTH SPOKE WITH ME, SHOWED ME THE SPREADSHEET PUT TOGETHER BY THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. AND IN THAT SPREADSHEET IT SHOWED THAT MY COUNTY TAXES WERE $6,169, AND THAT MY CITY TAXES WOULD BE $5,982. WHILE I HAVE MY ACTUAL TAX FROM THE COUNTY HERE, AND MY ACTUAL TAXES ARE $5,387, WHICH IS $600 LESS THAN WHAT THE WHAT THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS WOULD BE. AND THESE ARE REAL ESTATE TAXES ONLY, AND THEY DO INCLUDE TRASH. OKAY, SO NONE OF THE OTHER LITTLE MUMBO JUMBO MAKE UP ABOUT TAXATION ON UTILITIES AND SO FORTH. SO ALSO IN YOUR MAILER THAT WAS SENT OUT, YOU SPECIFICALLY SAY, AND IT'S HIGHLIGHTED AND UNDERLINED THAT TAXABLE VALUE BELOW $411,250 WOULD SAVE MONEY. MY TAXABLE VALUE AGAIN ON MY TAX STATEMENT IS $301,992. YET MY TAXES WOULD GO UP UNDER YOUR PRESENTATION OF ANNEXATION OF ZONE ONE. SO WITH THAT INFORMATION IN MIND. YOU KNOW, AND BASED ON MY EXPERIENCE AND SPEAKING WITH FOLKS, AND I ALSO SPOKE WITH FINANCE AS WELL AFTER THAT MEETING AND WAS PROVIDED WITH THE SAME INFORMATION. SO MY BASED ON MY EXPERIENCE, I WOULD URGE EVERYBODY TO TAKE A LOOK AT THEIR THE REAL TAXATION [00:50:07] THAT IS BEING PRESENTED BY THE CITY VERSUS WHAT THE REAL TAXATION IS BY THE COUNTY, AND MAKE UP A DECISION BASED ON THAT. SO CONSIDERING THE INACCURACIES AND JUST THIS BASIC INFORMATION, WHICH SHOULD BE KNOWN BY THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, WE'LL BE VOTING NO ON ANNEXATION. THANK YOU. SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK YOU SIR. NEXT. NEXT WE HAVE DARLENE JONES FOLLOWING DARLENE JONES, WE'LL HAVE ROCCO ODYSSEY. SO GOOD EVENING. THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK. MY NAME IS DARLENE JONES. I LIVE AT 2391 COUNTRY OAKS LANE IN PALM BEACH GARDENS. I HAVE BEEN SWORN SINCE THE LAST MEETING. THERE'S BEEN A IT GENERATED TONS OF CONVERSATION. AS I'M SURE YOU ALL KNOW, THERE'S THREE THINGS THAT WERE SPOKE ABOUT AMONGST PEOPLE, AND I'VE NOT HEARD A SUFFICIENT OR SATISFACTORY ANSWER TO THEM. AND I WOULD LIKE TO POSE THAT THAT WE CAN GET ANSWERS TO THESE QUESTIONS. ONE WAS THE VOTING COUNTS. I KNOW THE GENTLEMAN BEFORE US SAID IT WOULD BE A SIMPLE MAJORITY. THERE HAS BEEN SOME TALK THAT IF A REGISTERED VOTER DOES NOT VOTE YES OR NO, THAT IT'S AUTOMATICALLY CONSIDERED A YES VOTE. NUMBER TWO OWNERS AND RENTERS. I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT IF I OWN A PROPERTY IN PALM BEACH GARDENS AND SAY I LIVE DOWN IN LAKE PARK OR SOME OTHER TOWN, THAT I CAN'T VOTE AS A PROPERTY OWNER, BUT MY RENTER CAN, OR ANY. VOTER REGISTERED PERSON IN THE HOUSEHOLD, WHETHER IT BE ONE, TWO, THREE, FIVE CAN VOTE. AND YET, AS A PROPERTY OWNER, I WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO VOTE. THAT'S TWO. NUMBER THREE. ALSO, I SPOKE WITH THE GENTLEMAN THAT HAS ONE OF THE COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES ON ALTERNATE A-1-A, AND HE INFORMED ME THAT HE WAS TOLD THAT THE COMMERCIAL PROPERTY OWNERS DON'T GET A VOTE. SO I'M HOPING THAT YOU CAN SET THE RECORD STRAIGHT ON THAT. I KNOW THERE'S A LOT OF MISINFORMATION HERE AND THERE, AND THAT'S WHY WE HAVE THESE MEETINGS TO COME TO YOU AND GET ANSWERS. AND HOPEFULLY YOU CAN DO THAT FOR US. JUST FOR THE RECORD, MY HUSBAND AND I ARE VOTING NO. AND EVERYBODY ON MY STREET THAT I'VE TALKED TO IS VOTING NO ALSO, SO I'D LOVE TO GET THE ANSWERS TO THOSE QUESTIONS. THANK YOU. GENERALLY SPEAKING, JUST SO EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS, IN CASE YOU HAVE NEVER COME TO A CITY COUNCIL MEETING AND PROVIDED YOUR THREE MINUTES, WE GO THROUGH EVERYBODY'S THREE MINUTES AND THEN COUNCIL HAS DISCUSSION. SO SO ANY ANY QUESTIONS ASKED ARE NOT RESPONDED TO IMMEDIATELY. WE SAY THANK YOU. AND THEN WE LET EVERYONE ELSE HAVE THEIR VOICE AS WELL. JUST TO GIVE YOU A HEADS UP, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR COMING IN. SO WE HAVE ROCCO AND THEN AFTER THAT WE'LL HAVE NANCY ODYSSEY. SO YES, MY NAME IS ROCCO ODYSSEY. AND GOOD EVENING, MADAM MAYOR. COUNCIL MEMBERS. I LIVE AT 1865 PLEASANT DRIVE, AND I ALSO I WAS SWORN IN, SO WE'RE ALL READY TO GO. I WANTED TO SPEAK UP BECAUSE I LIVE IN PLEASANT RIDGE. AND PLEASANT RIDGE HAS A UNIQUE ABILITY BECAUSE OF ITS LOCATION EAST OF THE INTERCOASTAL. IT WAS ESTABLISHED IN 1955 AS A BLUE COLLAR NEIGHBORHOOD THAT YOU NOW CALL. IT'S A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT, BUT WE'VE BEEN BLUE COLLAR SINCE THE BEGINNING. WE HAVE FIREMEN, PEOPLE, FPL NURSES. ET CETERA. ET CETERA. THE TROUBLE WITH OUR NEIGHBORHOOD IS THAT WE'RE LOW INCOME AS FAR AS OUR MONEY GOES, AND WE CAN'T AFFORD HIGHER TAXES. IT WOULD FORCE A LOT OF PEOPLE OUT. AND YOU TALK ABOUT WORKFORCE. HOUSING USED TO BE CALLED BLUE COLLAR, BUT IT'S WORKFORCE HOUSING. IF YOU FORCE EVERYBODY OUT AND YOU ALWAYS TALK ABOUT WORKFORCE HOUSING, IT'S A CONTRADICTION IN TERMS. SO WE'RE REALLY CONCERNED ABOUT OUR TAXES GOING UP. AND I'VE DONE THE THE ARITHMETIC TOO. AND IT LOOKS LIKE OURS WOULD GO UP. SO WITH THAT SAID, I JUST WANT TO LEAVE YOU WITH A THOUGHT THAT I ALWAYS HEARD FROM MY FATHER, AND HE WOULD ALWAYS SAY, SOMETIMES IT'S BETTER TO LEAVE WELL ENOUGH ALONE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SIR. I BELIEVE I DON'T WANT TO MISPRONOUNCE ANYONE'S NAME. SO YOU'RE UP, AND THEN AFTER THAT, WE'VE GOT NICHOLAS GEISLER. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS NANCY. LADIES, BY WAY OF INTRODUCTION. I AM A I BOUGHT MY PROPERTY IN PLEASANT RIDGE 29 YEARS AGO. SO I'VE BEEN A PROPERTY OWNER IN PLEASANT RIDGE. AND THIS IS, I APOLOGIZE ADDRESS. AND IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN 1865 PLEASANT DRIVE. YES, I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. THANK YOU. OKAY. I PRESENTLY SERVE AS PLEASANT RIDGE PTA PRESIDENT. WE HAVE A VOLUNTARY ASSOCIATION. [00:55:01] SINCE MID SEPTEMBER, I HAVE BEEN FIELDING HUNDREDS OF CALLS, TEXTS, EMAILS FROM NEIGHBORS, NOT JUST IN PLEASANT RIDGE, JUNO TERRACE, JUNO RIDGE, AND PEOPLE THAT I, OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS HAVE BEEN SORT OF AN ACTIVIST. AND SO I KNOW PEOPLE FROM A LOT OF COMMUNITIES, AND SO FAR EVERYONE SEEMS TO BE OPPOSED, ESPECIALLY BECAUSE OF THE ZONE ONE. I TOTALLY AGREE, IT IS NOT A COMPACT AREA. IT'S A VAST AREA OF MANY DIVERSE COMMUNITIES AND USES. ALSO, I WOULD LIKE TO DULY NOTED THAT YOUR PLANNER. NO DISRESPECT, BUT HE HAS SAID THAT PLEASANT RIDGE IS MULTIFAMILY. NO, PLEASANT RIDGE IS EXCLUSIVELY SINGLE FAMILY SINCE 1955. OKAY. SO AND AND AND TO ANSWER SOME OF THE THINGS THAT CAME UP IN THE NEWSPAPER, UNFORTUNATELY I WAS NOT AVAILABLE FOR THE LAST MEETING. SO, YOU KNOW, IN PAST YEARS, YES, THE ANNEXATION WAS DISCUSSED EVEN 20 YEARS AGO, IN 2001, OUR NEIGHBORHOOD WAS LOOKING AT ANNEXATION INTO JUNO BEACH VOLUNTARILY, AND THERE WERE INCENTIVES DISCUSSED AND SUCH. SO, YOU KNOW, SO FAR, I DON'T SEE ANY INCENTIVE, ANY REASON FOR A NEIGHBORHOOD LIKE MY, LIKE PLEASANT RIDGE AND ALL OF THE NEIGHBORHOODS TO THE SOUTH THAT ARE SIMILAR WORKFORCE HOUSING. VOTERS SHOULD DECIDE. ELECTED OFFICIALS, NOT VOTERS, SHOULD DECIDE WHAT TO TAKE AWAY PROPERTY RIGHTS FROM THE PROPERTY OWNER, THE REGISTERED VOTER, YOU KNOW, COULD BE A TENANT. SO WHY DO THEY HAVE A VESTED INTEREST IN MY PROPERTY? YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE MOST FREQUENT THINGS THAT COMES UP, THE VISION OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, YOU'RE A CITY. IT'S NOT THE VISION OF PLEASANT RIDGE OF THE WORKFORCE. AND I KNOW I'M RUNNING OUT OF TIME. I JUST WANT TO SAY THERE IS A GROUNDSWELL, GROUNDSWELL OF OPPOSITION FROM COMMUNITIES IN ZONE ONE, BECAUSE THIS IS A BLATANTLY BAD PROPOSAL. AND IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT MONEY. THIS IS ABOUT QUALITY OF LIFE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. WE HAVE NICHOLAS GEISLER AND NO, THANK YOU. I KNOW WE ALL FEEL THINGS TONIGHT. WE STILL HAVE ALMOST TWO HOURS WORTH OF COMMENT CARDS ON THIS ONE ORDINANCE THAT WE'RE GOING TO CALL PEOPLE UP AFTER NICHOLAS WILL BE MARY HUGHES OR D'ANGELO. AFTER THAT IS TANYA TYSON. IF YOU COULD BE READY TO COME RIGHT UP. YES, SIR. THANK YOU, MADAM MAYOR NICHOLAS GEISLER, ATTORNEY WITH BARTLETT, LOEB, HINES, THOMPSON ANGELOS, 819 SOUTH FEDERAL HIGHWAY, REPRESENTING RESIDENTS OF HIDDEN KEY. AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN BEFORE YOU BEGIN. BEFORE YOU START, YOU STOP THIS CLOCK. PLEASE. IF YOU'RE GOING TO REPRESENT RESIDENTS OF HIDDEN KEY, THEN YOU NEED TO LIST THEM BY NAME. SIR. REPRESENTING THE COMMUNITY OF HIDDEN QUAY. THE ENTIRE YOU. YOU'VE BEEN RETAINED BY EVERY SINGLE SOLITARY RESIDENT. NO, I DON'T I DON'T FEEL THE NEED TO TO BREACH ATTORNEY CLIENT PRIVILEGE AND LET THE COUNCIL KNOW TONIGHT. EVERYONE THAT I REPRESENT THE NAME OF YOUR CLIENT IS NOT BREACHING AN ATTORNEY CLIENT PRIVILEGE. THE FACT THAT YOU'RE REPRESENTING SOMEBODY IS NOT PRIVILEGED INFORMATION. AND YOU ARE ESTABLISHING STANDING OSTENSIBLY FOR THOSE PEOPLE. SO THEY NEED TO BE IDENTIFIED. OTHERWISE YOU MERELY ADD NAMES TO WHATEVER PETITION YOU FILE. WE HAVE FORMALLY REQUESTED THREE TIMES, WITH NO SUCCESS, TO FORMALLY INTERVENE IN TONIGHT'S PROCEEDINGS SO THAT WE COULD PRESENT EVIDENCE, MAKE A PRESENTATION BEYOND THE THREE MINUTES AND THE WITNESSES AND OUR CLIENTS WOULD HAVE WOULD BE ABLE TO GIVE SWORN TESTIMONY, AND WE WOULD BE ABLE TO CROSS-EXAMINE THE WITNESSES THAT ARE HERE PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF THE CITY. WE'VE BEEN DENIED. SO I'M HERE TO GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT, AND I WILL SUBMIT THE SUBMIT EVIDENCE. I WILL SUBMIT THAT EVIDENCE AND IT WILL BE SIGNED BY THE WITNESSES. AND I DON'T FEEL THAT WE NEED TO GO BEYOND THAT. IF YOU FEEL THAT THAT IS NOT SUFFICIENT, YOU CAN DENY MY ABILITY TO GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT. I THINK THAT WOULD BE A DUE PROCESS VIOLATION, AND A COURT WOULD DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT THAT IS VALID OR NOT. I'M NOT DENYING YOUR RIGHT TO GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT. WHAT THE ISSUE IS, IS YOU ARE REPRESENTING. YOU ARE ASSERTING THAT YOU ARE REPRESENTING INDIVIDUALS TO ESTABLISH STANDING, TO FILE A PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERT, YET YOU'RE REFUSING TO NAME THEM. I HAVE DECLARATIONS HERE OF MAGGIE SCHAFMEISTER. I HAVE A DECLARATION. I'LL READ YOU EVERY DECLARATION. [01:00:11] CELESTE CARLTON. JOSEPH D'ANGELO. AND BARRY PERAZZO. ALSO REPRESENT KEN GLUCK AND RICHARD AUGUSTINE. AND I'M HERE REPRESENTING THEIR INTEREST TONIGHT. AND I ALSO HAVE A SWORN AFFIDAVIT FROM AN EXPERT WITNESS, THE FORMER CITY ATTORNEY OF THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE, ROBERT SCHEUER. BUT HE'S NOT A CLIENT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, I APPRECIATE IT. I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ESTABLISHED WHO YOU'RE REPRESENTING. THANK YOU. CAN I CAN I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT MY TIME RESTART? RESTART HIS TIME? ABSOLUTELY. YES, SIR. AND SO AT THE OUTSET OF THIS PROCEEDING, MAYOR, READ READ THE PARAMETERS OF THIS QUASI JUDICIAL PROCEEDING. AND AS PART OF THOSE PARAMETERS THAT THE DECISION TONIGHT OF THE COUNCIL MUST BE BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND THE TERM IN THE LAW IS COMPETENT, SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE. SO THE MAYOR IS ABSOLUTELY CORRECT THAT THAT IS WHAT THE COUNCIL MUST DO TONIGHT. THAT IS THEIR CHARGE. YOUR DUTY TONIGHT GOES BEYOND YOUR TYPICAL LEGISLATIVE DUTY. IT'S NOT APPROPRIATE TO SAY WE VOTE YES ON THIS ANNEXATION BECAUSE WE WANT IT, BECAUSE WE THINK IT'S GOOD FOR THE RESIDENTS. THE COUNCIL MUST LOOK AT THE EVIDENCE, DETERMINE WHERE THE EVIDENCE LIES, WHERE IT FOLLOWS. DOES THE EVIDENCE PROVIDED MEET THE REQUIREMENTS OF FLORIDA LAW? SO THE QUESTION IS, WELL, WHAT IS THAT EVIDENCE? I STOOD BEFORE YOU LAST MONTH AND GAVE A PRESENTATION THAT THE EVIDENCE GIVEN BY THE CITY ITSELF SHOWS THAT THIS IS NOT A COMPACT AREA. IT IS NOT A SINGLE AREA. FOR ALL THE REASONS THAT WERE STATED AFTER ME AND ALL THE REASONS THAT WILL BE STATED AGAIN HERE TONIGHT. AFTER ALL, AFTER AN HOUR OF PUBLIC COMMENT, COUNCIL MEMBER MIDDLETON ASKED THE CITY ATTORNEY, IS THERE ANY VALIDITY TO THIS? WHAT IS IS THIS A COMPACT AREA UNDER THE LAW? THE RESPONSE FROM MR. LOWMAN WAS, I DON'T FEEL THE NEED TO DEBATE THAT TONIGHT. THAT'S SIMPLY NOT GOOD ENOUGH. I HAVE HERE DECLARATIONS FROM SEVERAL RESIDENTS, AND I ALSO HAVE A SWORN AFFIDAVIT FROM THE CITY, FROM THE FORMER CITY ATTORNEY OF FORT PIERCE, AS GIVING HIS EXPERT OPINION THAT THIS IS SIMPLY NOT A COMPACT AREA. THOSE DECLARATIONS ALL SAY FOR THE REASONS THAT HAVE BEEN STATED OVER AND OVER AGAIN, THE SIZE, THE SCOPE, THE LAND USE, THE ZONING DESIGNATIONS, THE DIFFERENT SCHOOL CHOICES, THE DIFFERENT GEOGRAPHIC LOCATIONS. THE HIDDEN KEY IS SEPARATED BY THE INTRACOASTAL WATERWAY. THEY HAVE DIFFERENT PUBLIC SAFETY NEEDS. THEY HAVE DIFFERENT URBAN SERVICES NEEDS THAN THE RESIDENTS DO ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THIS HUGE, HUGE ZONE. FOR THOSE REASONS ALONE, THIS DOES NOT MEET THE FLORIDA FLORIDA STATUTES. ALSO, AS WAS STATED, THE CITY'S ANNEXATION MAP, WHICH YOU'RE RELYING ON TONIGHT, IS INCORRECT. THE CITY DOES NOT OWN THE PROPERTY LEADING INTO THE GATE OF OF HIDDEN KEY. IF YOU VOTE YES TONIGHT, AND IF THE REFERENDUM PASSES, YOU WILL BE CREATING YOUR OWN ENCLAVE, BECAUSE THAT WILL BE THE ONLY PROPERTY LEFT IN ITS OWN POCKET OF UNINCORPORATED PALM BEACH COUNTY. I HAVE THIS EVIDENCE HERE, AND I THINK IF THE COUNCIL AT THE END OF TONIGHT LOOKS AT THE EVIDENCE AND SAYS, WHERE DOES THE EVIDENCE LEAD US? IF YOU'RE DOING YOUR DUTY TONIGHT, YOUR STATUTORILY REQUIRED DUTY NOT TO DO WHAT YOU WANT TO DO, BUT TO VOTE ON WHERE THE EVIDENCE TAKES YOU, YOU HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO SAY THIS ORDINANCE DOES NOT COMPLY WITH FLORIDA LAW, AND WE ARE FORCED TO VOTE NO ON IT. WITH YOUR PERMISSION, MADAM MAYOR, I'D LIKE TO SUBMIT THIS TO THE CITY CLERK. YES, SIR. THANK YOU. MAYOR HUGHES, DEANGELO, TONYA TYSON, AND THEN SHARON. CONNIE WILL BE FOLLOWING THAT. THANK YOU, MA'AM. YOU'LL HAVE YOUR THREE MINUTES IF YOU COULD STATE YOUR NAME AND YOUR ADDRESS. AND IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN. OKAY. GOOD EVENING. I CAN BARELY SEE YOU GUYS. OKAY. MY NAME IS MARY HUGHES OR D'ANGELO, AND I LIVE AT 11830 LAKESHORE PLACE AT HIDDEN KEY, AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. I HAVE A LITTLE DIFFERENT TAKE ON THIS. I HAVE WORKED IN HEALTH CARE FOR OVER. LET'S PAUSE HER TIME FOR ONE MOMENT, PLEASE. YEAH, I'M HAVING TO JUMP UP. NO, NO, WE WANT YOU TO BE COMFORTABLE. JUST ONE MOMENT. I THINK WE HAVE A LOT OF TALL PEOPLE PRESENTING TONIGHT, I APOLOGIZE. ALL RIGHT. SORRY. OKAY. THANK YOU. I'VE BEEN IN HEALTH CARE FOR OVER 50 YEARS. [01:05:01] I'M A REGISTERED NURSE, AND NOW I'M A NURSE PRACTITIONER. I WORKED 25 YEARS AT SAINT MARY'S IN THE EMERGENCY ROOM AND THE TRAUMA CENTER. AND I'VE SEEN SOME OF THE BEST PARTS OF HUMANITY, AND I'VE SEEN SOME OF THE WORST PARTS OF HUMANITY, AND THAT HAS ALLOWED ME TO HAVE A LOT OF MORAL CLARITY. AND I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN RIGHT AND WRONG AND GOOD AND EVIL. AND I'M HERE TO TELL YOU THAT YOUR PLAN IS JUST PLAIN OLD WRONG IN THE FIRST PLACE. WE ONLY FOUND OUT ABOUT THIS PLAN PROBABLY THE END OF SEPTEMBER OR EARLY OCTOBER. WE HEARD IT THROUGH A LEAK FROM CAPTAINS QUAY. WE WERE SHOCKED. I FELT LIKE I WAS DRIVING MY CAR AND T-BONED IN AN INTERSECTION. WE JUST SPINNING AROUND. WE DIDN'T KNOW WHAT TO DO. WE COULDN'T BELIEVE THAT THIS WOULD EVEN BE HAPPENING. IT ALSO FELT LIKE AN ARRANGED MARRIAGE, YOU KNOW? IT JUST WAS. NO FIRST DATE, NO LUNCH, NOT EVEN A CUP OF COFFEE. I DON'T REMEMBER YOU EVER COMING INTO HIDDEN QUAY AND ASKING OUR OPINION, BUT IF MY FEELING WAS IF THAT'S HOW YOU TREAT YOUR POTENTIAL RESIDENTS, WE DON'T WANT THAT. WE'RE VERY HAPPY THE WAY THINGS ARE. IT'S NOT. IT HASN'T BEEN A FRIENDLY OR WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE SO FAR. THEN SOMETIME AROUND THE MID OCTOBER, WE RECEIVED THE FIRST MAILER. I DON'T KNOW IF IT WAS THIS ONE OR THIS ONE, AND INVITING US TO AN INFORMATION SESSION. WE FOUND OUT ABOUT YOUR WEB PAGE, AND WE WENT ON TO THE WEB PAGE TO FIND OUT THAT ZONE ONE WAS THIS BIG GIANT, NOT COMPACT AREA. IT LOOKED MORE LIKE A METASTATIC BLOB WITH TENTACLES REACHING EAST, WEST, NORTH SOUTH, GOING ACROSS, GRABBING UP LAND ACROSS THE INTERCOASTAL, GRABBING LAND ACROSS US ONE AND AND ELLIS AND WILSON. IT IS NOT A COMPACT AREA. THE OTHER REASON THAT THIS IS WRONG IS BECAUSE WE ARE NOT AN ENCLAVE. AS HAS BEEN STATED BEFORE, AND YOUR MAP WAS WRONG ABOUT ABOUT OUR ENTRANCE WAY. WE'VE HEARD FROM MULTIPLE SOURCES THAT THE FIX IS IN. THE REAL PLAN IS FOR MASSIVE REDEVELOPMENT IN THE NORTH COUNTY. WE DON'T WANT THAT. WE DON'T WANT TO BE MIAMI. WE DON'T WANT TO BE FORT LAUDERDALE. WE DON'T EVEN WANT TO BE WEST PALM BEACH. WE'RE VERY HAPPY THE WAY THINGS ARE. ANNEXATION WILL COST US PERSONALLY ABOUT $1,000 MORE EVERY YEAR IN TAXES. IF I HAVE AN EXTRA $1,000, I WOULD LIKE TO DONATE IT TO DOCTORS WITHOUT BORDERS, NOT PALM BEACH GARDENS. I URGE YOU TO VOTE NO, IT'S NOT TOO LATE. YOU CAN DO THE RIGHT THING. VOTE NO TONIGHT. YOU'RE BETTER THAN THIS. AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE HAVE TANYA TYSON, SHARON CAVE, OR. I'M SORRY, I CAN'T READ THE HANDWRITING. IT LOOKS LIKE A K A EITHER U OR V AND E, SO WE'VE GOT TANYA, SHARON AND THEN SONYA. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS TANYA TYSON. MY ADDRESS IS 3106 GROVE ROAD, CABANA COLONY IN PALM BEACH GARDENS. HAVE YOU BEEN SWORN IN? I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. I OPPOSE THIS ANNEXATION OF ORDINANCE 20 2223. I OPPOSED IT 27 YEARS AGO WHEN I BOUGHT MY HOUSE AND IT WAS TRIED BACK THEN. WE HAVE NOTHING TO GAIN IN THIS AREA EXCEPT AN INCREASE IN TAXES. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. I'M SORRY. THANK YOU. WE'RE MOVING ON TO SHARON K YOU ANY OR ANY SONIA GONZALEZ AND THEN HOLLY FINCH. NAME IS SHARON CAVENEY. I LIVE AT 12216 COLONY AVENUE AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. I RECENTLY ATTENDED THE MEETING OVER AT THE MOOSE ON NOVEMBER 15TH, AFTER ALL THE PRESENTERS GAVE ALL THEIR INFORMATION. I KNOW THE LADY IS HERE. SHE PROCEEDED TO TELL US ABOUT THE $30 MILLION IMPROVEMENT TO THE BURNS ROAD REC CENTER AND THE 3.4 MILLION IMPROVEMENT ON THE POOL. AS A RETIREE IN A WORKING CLASS NEIGHBORHOOD, I HAVE NO INTEREST IN JOINING YOUR CITY OR HELPING TO PAY LOANS, MUCH LESS PAY TO USE THE FACILITIES AFTER I'VE INVESTED MONEY INTO IT. I THINK THAT'S MY BIGGEST THING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE HAVE SONIA GONZALEZ. HOLLY FINCH, AND THEN BETTINA GODZIESZE WIELKIE. SO GO AHEAD WITH MS.. GONZALEZ. THANK YOU. I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. MY NAME IS SONIA GONZALEZ. I LIVE AT ONE, TWO, 241 COLONY AVENUE. I MY BIGGEST CONCERN THAT I HAVE IS, IS THE TAXES. I CONTINUE TO HEAR THAT OUR TAXES WILL BE WILL BE SAVING MONEY. [01:10:02] HONESTLY, I DON'T KNOW THE GOVERNMENT COMING INTO YOUR COMMUNITY AND TELLING YOU THAT YOU'RE GOING TO SAVE MONEY. I'M OPPOSED TO THIS. THERE'S PEOPLE HERE THAT ARE NOT HERE THAT ARE ALSO OPPOSED TO THIS. IF THIS PASSES, YOU GUYS WILL JUST FIND OUT MARCH 19TH WHEN THIS DOESN'T PASS. THANK YOU SO MUCH. HOLLY FINCH AND THEN BETTINA GODZISZEWSKI. AND AFTER THAT WILL BE CELESTE COLTON. I APOLOGIZE FOR ANY LAST NAMES. SO WE HAVE HOLLY FINCH. HELLO. MY NAME IS HOLLY FINCH. I LIVE AT 11639 LANDING PLACE IN HIDDEN KEY. I WAS AT THE PREVIOUS MEETING AND I NOTICED YOU SWORN IN. I WAS SWORN IN. THANK YOU. I DID NOTICE THAT YOU HAD MENTIONED AT THIS MEETING THAT YOU DON'T RESPOND TO ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS UNTIL THERE'S COUNCIL DISCUSSION. I NOTICED THAT THAT HAPPENED THE LAST MEETING. THERE WAS A LOT OF PUBLIC COMMENT, A LOT OF CONCERN ABOUT ZONE ONE. EVERYBODY WAS DISMISSED FOR A NICE RECESS, AND THE MEETING WAS CALLED BACK TO ORDER WITH VERY FEW PEOPLE IN THE ROOM. AND THERE WERE A FEW COMMENTS THAT I WANTED TO RESPOND TO BECAUSE WE'RE NOT GETTING A RESPONSE FROM THE CITY COUNCIL OR THE CITY PRETTY MUCH WHEN OUR STEERING COMMITTEE HAS MET WITH THE COUNCIL OR WITH YOUR STAFF. I UNDERSTAND IT TO BE VERY DISMISSIVE. WE'RE DOING THIS ANYWAY, AND THAT DOES SEEM TO BE THE WAY IT APPEARS THIS EVENING. AND AT THE LAST MEETING, ONE OF THE COUNCIL MEMBERS SAID THEY LOVE PALM BEACH GARDENS. WHY ON EARTH WOULD WE NOT WANT TO JOIN THIS LOVELY CITY? AND I DON'T BELIEVE ANYBODY HAS SAID, YOUR CITY IS NOT LOVELY. YOUR FACILITIES ARE BEAUTIFUL. IT'S VERY NICE. BUT IF WE HAD WANTED TO LIVE IN PALM BEACH GARDENS, WE WOULD HAVE MOVED THERE AND PAID FOR THOSE FACILITIES AND THE USE OF THOSE FACILITIES. SO NOBODY'S DISPARAGING YOUR TOWN. IT'S JUST WE DON'T LIKE BEING SUCKED INTO IT INVOLUNTARILY BECAUSE OF THE UNFAIR WAY THAT ZONE ONE HAS BEEN DRAWN THROUGH. NORTH PALM BEACH COUNTY IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT, WHICH WE KNOW IS NORTH PALM BEACH COUNTY IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT, BECAUSE WE PAY TAXES TO THAT DISTRICT TO MAINTAIN OUR GATE AND ROADWAY INTO OUR COMMUNITY. IT'S NOT THAT WE THINK THAT'S NOT PALM BEACH GARDENS. WE KNOW FOR A FACT THAT IT IS. AND I BELIEVE THE ATTORNEY THAT YES, I'VE ALSO SIGNED AN AFFIDAVIT AND CONTRIBUTED FINANCIALLY TO THE LEGAL FUND TO POINT OUT THAT THAT IS NOT PALM BEACH GARDENS. I CAN DRIVE AROUND SINGER ISLAND BY MACARTHUR PARK, WHICH IS THE VILLAGE OF NORTH PALM BEACH, INTO MY COMMUNITY AND NEVER TOUCH PALM BEACH GARDENS IF I CHOOSE TO. AND THE OTHER THING THAT WAS VERY DISHEARTENING ABOUT THE COUNCIL COMMENTS WAS THAT THE CITY MANAGER OR THE CITY ATTORNEY DID SAY THEY HAD NO NEED TO ADDRESS THE PUBLIC COMMENTS. AND THAT IS SORT OF THE ATTITUDE AND WHERE EVERYBODY IS A LITTLE HURT ON OUR SIDE, IS THAT FROM THE VERY BEGINNING, WHEN WE FOUND OUT ABOUT ALL OF THIS IN OCTOBER, LATE SEPTEMBER, WE WEREN'T TOLD ABOUT IT. IT WAS SOME LEAK THAT GOT OUT THERE. AND WHEN WE DID COME FORWARD TO SAY, HEY, WHAT'S HAPPENING? THIS IS NEW TO US, WE WANT TO DISCUSS IT. OUR STEERING COMMITTEE WAS PRETTY MUCH DISMISSED, AND WE'RE ONLY A COMMUNITY OF 70 HOMES. SO WE TALK TO EACH OTHER AND WE KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON. AND WE HAVE MOST, I WANT TO SAY ALL, BUT MAYBE 1 OR 2 HAVE SIGNED THESE AFFIDAVITS THAT WE ARE GOING TO FIGHT THIS ZONE. ONE. IT'S NOT THE YES OR NO VOTE THAT YOU PRETENDED TO BE IN THE MAILER SAYING, OH, YOU DON'T LIKE IT? THEN JUST VOTE YES OR NO. IT DOESN'T MATTER IF IT'S YES OR NO. THE WAY THE ZONE WAS WRITTEN, THE PROCESS THAT WAS THAT WAS PUT TOGETHER, THE WAY THIS WAS DONE WAS VERY, VERY WRONG IN THAT IT DID NOT INVITE ANYBODY WHO'S GOING TO BE AFFECTED TO BE PART OF IT, OR EVEN ASK IF WE WANTED TO BE PART OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. IT WAS JUST DONE TO US. THAT'S HOW IT FEELS, AND THAT'S WHY THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE HERE THIS MONTH, A LOT OF PEOPLE HERE LAST MONTH. THERE'S SIGNS ALL OVER OUR NEIGHBORHOOD. PEOPLE ARE PEOPLE ARE REALLY GETTING INTO COMMUNITY ACTIVISM BECAUSE WE FEEL THIS HAS PUSHED UPON US. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. PLEASE. WE WE STILL WANT TO GET THROUGH EVERYONE'S COMMENT CARD. WE HAVE BETTINA AND THEN CELESTE COLTON AND THEN MARGO SAYLOR. HI, MY NAME IS BETTINA GODZISZEWSKI. I LIVE AT 1921 KATHY LANE IN NORTH PALM BEACH, FLORIDA AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT I AGREE WITH AND REITERATE EVERY SINGLE THING THAT HAS BEEN SAID UP HERE BY EVERY OTHER RESIDENT THAT HAS STOOD UP BEHIND THIS MICROPHONE, AND I OPPOSE ANNEXATION. THANK YOU MA'AM. CELESTE COLTON, MARGO SAYLOR, AND THEN MICHAEL HALL. MY NAME IS CELESTE CARLTON. I LIVE AT 11660 LANDING PLACE IN HIDDEN KEY, AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. I JUST STAND HERE IN OPPOSITION TO THE ANNEXATION OF HIDDEN KEY BY THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. I FAIL TO SEE WHAT PALM BEACH GARDENS ADDS TO OUR COMMUNITY THAT WE DON'T ALREADY HAVE. SO I BELIEVE THAT THERE IS NO NEED TO FIX SOMETHING THAT ISN'T BROKEN. WE DO NOT NEED ANOTHER LAYER OF GOVERNMENT. THANK YOU MA'AM. WE'LL MOVE ON TO MARGO, SAILOR MICHAEL, AND THEN WILLIAM LIPINSKI. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS MARGO SAILOR. I LIVE AT 3411 FLORIDA BOULEVARD, WHICH IS IN CABANA COLONY. AND YES, I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. MY HUSBAND AND I BOUGHT OUR PROPERTY IN 1996, PRIMARILY BECAUSE IT WAS AN UNINCORPORATED PALM BEACH COUNTY. [01:15:05] WE HAPPEN TO LIKE OUR CURBLESS SIDEWALKS, OUR THROWBACK TO 70 HOMES. I DON'T THINK ADDING ANOTHER LAYER OF GOVERNMENT IS GOING TO BENEFIT ANY OF US, AND WE ARE STRONGLY OPPOSED AND WE WILL VOTE NO. THANK YOU, MA'AM MICHAEL HOLLY. AND THEN WE HAVE WILLIAM LIPINSKI AND THEN LORAINE WOLFORD. WOLFORD. GOOD EVENING, MAYOR. MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL, MICHAEL HALL. I'VE BEEN SWORN IN AT 12892 INSHORE DRIVE, WHICH IS ON THE MAYHEW AREA. I'M GOING TO BE OPPOSING THIS ANNEXATION. FIRST OF ALL, I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING EVERYBODY SAID ABOUT THIS AREA. ONE. I MEAN, YOU CAN JUST LOOK AT IT AND SAY, THAT'S NOT RIGHT. ROADS. WE HAVE PRIVATE ROADS. WE I'M HEARING WE EITHER KEEP OUR PRIVATE ROADS OR WE HAVE TO TURN THEM OVER TO YOU. IF WE TURN THEM OVER TO YOU, THERE IS EVIDENTLY SOME EASEMENTS THAT ARE NOW GOING TO CUT INTO OUR AREAS. WE HAVE HEARD NOTHING ABOUT ROADS. THIS WHOLE AREA. ONE IS ALSO IN TERMS OF DIVERSE. SOME HAVE PRIVATE ROADS, SOME DO NOT. SOME HAVE SEWERS, SOME WANT SEWERS, SOME HAVE SEWERS THAT DON'T WANT SEWERS, SOME HAVE WATER. I MEAN, THERE'S ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT THINGS. SOME OF THE ROADS ARE EASY TO GET DOWN TO IN TERMS OF PIPES. SOME ROADS ARE LIKE, NO, MR. BISHOP, BISHOP, HE AIN'T COMING OVER OUR WAY. SO NO SERVICE ON WATER, SEWER, NO SERVICE ON ON DRAINS, ROADS, DRAINAGE. I DON'T LIVE IN CABANA COLONY, BUT I HAVE A LOT OF FRIENDS THERE. I HAVE SOME BACKGROUND IN WATER MANAGEMENT. THAT CANAL IS A MESS. THAT IS A VERY, VERY EXPENSIVE PROJECT. IT'S GOING TO TAKE A VERY, VERY LONG TIME. I'M HEARING THAT THERE'S SOME PROMISES THAT THIS COUNCIL IS MAKING TO A COLONY PEOPLE ABOUT. WE'RE GOING TO CLEAN THAT UP. IT'S A 2 MILLION AT LEAST PROJECT. YOU'VE GOT $200,000 IN YOUR BUDGET. NOW, HOW ARE YOU GOING TO PAY FOR THAT WITHOUT STRETCHING IT OUT 10 OR 15 YEARS? HOW ARE YOU GOING TO RAISE TAXES? OKAY. NEXT PUBLIC SAFETY. OUR AREA WE LOVE THE SHERIFF. HE HAS A GREAT JOB. I DON'T WANT TO PAY FOR THE COPS. AND IF IF YOU DON'T KNOW, WE PAY FULL COUNTY MILLAGE. I WASN'T SURE ABOUT THIS BECAUSE I'VE ALWAYS LIVED UNINCORPORATED. WE'RE GOING TO PAY THE FULL COUNTY OPERATING MILLAGE, WHICH COUNTS THE ENTIRE SHERIFF'S BUDGET. AND THEN YOUR ADDITIONAL MILLAGE IS TACKED ON TOP OF THAT TO PAY FOR YOUR COPS. I DON'T WANT TO DO THAT. I'M FINE WITH THE SHERIFF. ONLY YOU'RE NOT GIVING ME ANYTHING. FIRE RESCUE. IT'S FINE. WE'VE GOT COUNTY. YOU'VE GOT THAT AGREEMENT. FIRST RESPONDERS, GREAT CODE ENFORCEMENT. WE DON'T NEED CODE ENFORCEMENT BEING STRICTER THAN IT IS. OR IF YOU'RE SAYING I'M HEARING THE CODE IS NOT GOING TO CHANGE. WE DON'T NEED STRICTER ENFORCEMENT. THIS IS A MARINE COMMUNITY. OUR WHOLE AREA. THERE'S BOATS. HAVE YOU EVER TRIED. DO YOU KNOW HOW MUCH IT COST TO STORE A BOAT AT PGA, MARINA OR ANYBODY ELSE? IT'S IMPOSSIBLE. NO ONE CAN AFFORD A STORE, A BOAT OR AN RV IN A PLACE. WHERE ARE YOU GOING TO DO IT? OKAY. TRASH COLLECTION. YOU'RE SAYING WE'RE GOING TO SAVE THAT $282 OR $281? IT'S NOT SAVING. YOU'RE PUTTING THAT IN THE VILLAGE. AND THAT'S THE POINT I WANT TO MAKE ON. THE NEXT POINT IS THAT YOU'RE MOVING FIXED ASSESSMENTS LIKE SOLID WASTE COLLECTION INTO YOUR MILLAGE. A PROPERTY A PROPERTY OWNER DOESN'T WANT OUR TAXABLE VALUES GOING UP ON ANYTHING. WE DON'T WANT ANYTHING GOING INTO THE MILLAGE BECAUSE OUR TAXABLE VALUES ARE GOING TO GOING UP. WE'D RATHER PAY THE FIXED FEE THAT ISN'T RELATED TO THE PROPERTY VALUES, THE FPL, THIS OTHER STUFF. THOSE ARE JUST FIXED THINGS THAT YOU PUT INTO THE MODEL. IT'S A GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT. I'M SORRY THAT MODEL IS WRONG. THANK YOU, SIR WILLIAM LIPINSKI, LORRAINE WOOLFORD, PLEASE. OH I'M SORRY, THAT WAS MR. LIPINSKI, LORAINE WOLFORD AND BARRY PARISIO. HOW YOU DOING? MY NAME IS WILLIAM LIPINSKI. I LIVE AT 2634 LONE PINE ROAD IN MAINE, TWO STATES, AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. AND I'VE BEEN A RESIDENT OF PALM BEACH GARDENS SINCE 1980, 43 YEARS. I LIKE IT EXACTLY HOW IT IS. I DON'T WANT TO SEE ANY CHANGE. I'VE BEEN WITH THE COUNTY FOR 36 YEARS AND I'M STILL WORKING ON COUNTY PROJECTS, AND I FEEL IT'S NOTHING BUT GOVERNMENT OVERREACH. WE HAVE ENOUGH BUILDING AND PEOPLE DOWN HERE NOW, FROM WHAT I'VE SEEN IN THE LAST 43 YEARS, AND I DON'T WANT CITY SERVICES, I'M HAPPY WITH PALM BEACH GARDENS, WITH THE POLICE DEPARTMENT HERE, THE SHERIFFS, THEY PARK RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET BY THE CHURCH ALL THE TIME WAITING FOR CALLS. SO THEY'RE NEARBY ALL THE TIME. I TALK TO THEM AND I'M CONTENT. I'M CONTENT BEING. IN UNINCORPORATED PALM BEACH COUNTY. I DON'T NEED THE CITY. I DON'T NEED YOUR SERVICES. I'M HAPPY THE WAY I AM. I STILL WORK 20 HOURS A WEEK ONLY, BUT I RETIRED FROM THE COUNTY BACK IN 2017 AND I'M STILL ON COUNTY PROJECTS, SO I KIND OF KNOW A LITTLE BIT WHAT GOES ON A LOT DEEP [01:20:03] INSIDE, AND I'D LIKE TO LEAVE EVERYTHING THE WAY IT IS, AND THAT'S ALL I HAVE TO SAY. AND I GOT DAUGHTERS AND EVERYTHING THAT ARE REGISTERED VOTERS TOO, IN THE AREA, AND I KNOW THEY'RE GOING TO BE VOTING NO, THANK YOU, SIR. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO LORRAINE WOLFORD AND THEN BARRY P R A IZZO AND THEN PATRICIA HUMPHRIES. GUYS. WHOEVER'S ON DECK, CAN YOU JUST FORM A LINE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE HALLWAY? AND WHEN THE WHEN THE PERSON AT THE PODIUM LEAVES, THE NEXT PERSON CAN STEP UP. JUST MAKE IT A LITTLE BIT QUICKER. SO WHOEVER IS NEXT IS FORM A LINE BEHIND THAT PERSON WHEN SHE CALLS YOUR NAME, JUST STEP UP. THANKS. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS LORRAINE WOFFORD, 2692 LONE PINE ROAD, WEST PALM BEACH. I JUST REITERATE REITERATE WHAT EVERYONE ELSE SAYS AND I'M VOTING NO FOR THE ANNEXATION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU MA'AM. ALL RIGHT. BARRY PR FOLLOWED BY PATRICIA HUMPHRIES, WHICH WILL BE FOLLOWED BY CHUCK JONES. I APPRECIATE THAT. BERRY PROVIDES A11758 LAKE SHORE PLACE. I WAS SWORN IN AND. EXCUSE ME, CAN YOU PLEASE SPEAK INTO THE MICROPHONE? OH, OKAY. THANK YOU. IS THAT BETTER? OKAY. WE LIKE. I'M SORRY. SIR, WE'RE GOING TO ASK YOU TO SAY YOUR NAME, YOUR ADDRESS, AND IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN NOW THAT IT'S BEEN RECORDED. OH, OKAY. THANK YOU. I'M BARRY PRICE OF A11758 LAKESHORE PLACE, AND I WAS SWORN IN. MY GOOD. GREAT. OKAY. WE ENJOY BEING IN HIDDEN KEY. WE LIKE A VILLAGE. WE DON'T LIKE CITIES. JUST. WE'RE JUST UPSET THAT THIS IS OCCURRING. I NOTICED IN YOUR PAPERWORK. FIRST OF ALL, I THINK YOU MENTIONED EARLIER THAT YOU ANSWER QUESTIONS AT THE END AFTERWARDS. IS THAT CORRECT? YEAH. SO I'M LOOKING AT YOUR DOCUMENT HERE AND YOU HAVE IN HERE CAPTAIN'S KEY. NOW CAPTAIN'S KEY FROM WHAT I HAVE BEEN TOLD IS JOINED JUNO BEACH. SO HOW COME THAT'S STILL IN HERE? ANYBODY KNOW YOU HAVE YOUR THREE MINUTES TO SAY WHATEVER YOU WANT? WE'LL HAVE OUR TIME AT COUNCIL AFTER. AFTER WE'VE HEARD FROM ALL THE RESIDENTS. OKAY. SO, YEAH, THIS IS THIS IS US BEING POLITE. WE LISTEN FIRST AND WE SPEAK AFTER. ALL RIGHT. YES, MA'AM. PATRICIA HUMPHREYS. HI, MY NAME IS PATRICIA HUMPHREYS, AND I LIVE AT 2275 NORTH WALTON DRIVE. I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN, AND WE BEEN LIVING IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS, AND WE ARE VERY MUCH HAPPY WITH THE COUNTY. WE ARE OPPOSED TO BEING INCLUDED INTO THE PALM BEACH GARDENS. EVERYTHING IN THE COUNTY IS IS GOOD FOR US. THANK YOU. THANK YOU MA'AM. ALL RIGHT. WE HAVE CHUCK JONES, FOLLOWED BY. JOSEPH DEANGELO, FOLLOWED BY MELISSA WEIGAND. GOOD EVENING. CHUCK JONES TWO TWO, SEVEN FIVE NORTH WALTON DRIVE. I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN AND I HAVE A FEW THINGS HERE. FIRST OF ALL, WE NEVER GOT. THERE WAS NEVER A SURVEY OR NOTHING. THERE WAS JUST BOOM, WE'RE DOING THIS. I DON'T LIKE IT. I'VE BEEN A RESIDENT THERE 38 YEARS AND I NOTICED A FEW THINGS. IF THIS IF YOU GUYS PASS THIS TONIGHT, WHICH I KNOW WHEN YOU WHEN YOU COME, USUALLY YOU GUYS ALREADY KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING. NOBODY IN HERE IS GOING TO CHANGE IT, BUT YOU'RE HAVING THAT DURING AN OFF ELECTION. IF YOU HAD THAT DURING THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION, YOU'D PROBABLY GET THERE WOULD BE A LOT MORE TURNOUT. SO SOMEHOW I FEEL THAT THAT WAS PLANNED. UH. WHAT ELSE I GOT? UM, I'M VERY HAPPY WITH THE ROADS. ROADS, THE SERVICE WE'VE GOTTEN OVER THE YEARS FROM THE COUNTY WE USED TO FLOOD OVER THERE ON ON THE STREETS ON THE EAST SIDE OF PROSPERITY WAS ALL CAUSED BY THE MALL, PALM BEACH GARDENS. AND I WAS IN HERE FIGHTING ABOUT THAT OVER PROBABLY 20, 25 YEARS AGO. CAROL MARCUS, OUR COUNTY COMMISSIONER AT THE TIME, SHE TOOK GREAT CARE OF US. SO I WAS VERY HAPPY WITH THE COUNTY ON THAT ONE. UM. FIVE WHAT ELSE I GOT? OH, I WAS ALREADY SAID, I'M SORRY, BUT THE BUSINESSES CAN'T VOTE, THE RENTERS CAN'T VOTE OR. EXCUSE ME, I GOT THAT PART. LET ME START OVER THERE. THE RENTERS CAN VOTE. THE THE PROPERTY. PROPERTY. THANK YOU. THE PROPERTY OWNERS CAN'T VOTE. A LOT OF THEM IF THEY DON'T LIVE THERE. AND THE BUSINESS BUSINESS OWNERS THAT I HAVE, THE BUSINESSES THEY CAN'T VOTE JUST DOESN'T SEEM FAIR. [01:25:07] I FEEL LIKE POLITICS IS AT PLAY THE WAY THAT YOU GUYS ARE TRYING TO TAKE LAND THAT I'VE ALWAYS KNOWN FOR YEARS. YOU KNOW, IT WAS JUNO ON THE OTHER. ON THE WEST SIDE OR EAST SIDE OF THE INTERCOASTAL IS JUNO, AND ON THE OTHER SIDE OF PGA IS NORTH PALM BEACH. NOW, YOU WANT THAT PALM BEACH GARDENS? I DON'T UNDERSTAND IT. BOY. ANYTHING PRESSING ON YOUR LEG? THAT'S PROBABLY PRETTY MUCH IT, BUT WE PLAN TO VOTE. NO, I HAVEN'T SPOKEN TO NOBODY THAT WANTS THIS IN OUR IN OUR AREA. YOU KNOW, I JUST I DON'T I DON'T SEE WHY WE GOT TO DO THIS. IT'S JUST IT'S GOING TO COST US MORE. YOU GUYS SAY IT'S NOT. IT IS. YOU KNOW, AND CODE ENFORCEMENT, THE THE THE COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT, THEY JUST THEY IF I CALL ABOUT A NEIGHBOR OR SOMETHING, THEY WOULD COME AROUND AND THEY WOULD CITE THE NEIGHBOR AND THEY'D DO A BLOCK OR TWO AND THEY'D GO AWAY. THE CITY, THEY'RE PROACTIVE. YOU RIDE AROUND JUST LOOKING TO LOOKING FOR VIOLATIONS. THANK YOU SIR. SO THANK YOU SO MUCH. APPRECIATE IT. WE'RE GOING TO GO ON TO JOSEPH D'ANGELO, PLEASE. AND THEN MELISSA WIEGAND. I'M NOT A PUBLIC SPEAKER. BUT ONE THING I FOUND OUT FROM THIS MEETING SO FAR, AND I DON'T GO TO VERY MANY MEETINGS. I'M SORRY, SIR, IF YOU COULD, PLEASE. I'M SORRY TO INTERRUPT YOU. YOU'LL NEED TO STATE YOUR NAME, YOUR ADDRESS, AND IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN. JOSEPH D'ANGELO. I LIVE AT 11830 LAKESHORE PLACE IN KEY. AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. AS I WAS SAYING, THIS SEEMS LIKE ONE OF THE MOST NEGATIVE CONCLAVES OF PEOPLE THAT I'VE EVER SEEN. NOBODY WANTS THIS. I MEAN, YOU DON'T NEED TO BE A ROCKET SCIENTIST TO SEE THAT THESE PEOPLE OUT HERE LOVE IT THE WAY IT IS. I MEAN, HOPEFULLY YOU'LL SEE THE LIGHT, AS RONALD REAGAN ONCE SAID, THE SENTENCE YOU SHOULD NEVER BELIEVE IN IS WE ARE HERE FROM THE GOVERNMENT AND WE'RE HERE TO HELP YOU. BY GOLLY, YOU'RE NOT HERE TO HELP US. WE DON'T NEED YOUR HELP. WE DON'T WANT YOUR HELP. WE ARE VERY HAPPY IN HIDDEN KEY TO BE THE WAY WE ARE. WE ARE NEIGHBORS. WE ARE VILLAGERS. WE ENJOY EACH OTHER'S COMPANY. I HAVE BEEN THERE FOR HALF A CENTURY, AND I'VE HAD NO COMPLAINTS FROM ANYBODY OR MYSELF THAT THE GARBAGE DISPOSAL WAS BAD, OR THAT THE ROADS WERE BAD, OR THAT THE POLICE FORCE DIDN'T RESPOND, OR THAT THE FIRE DEPARTMENT DIDN'T HELP US. WE'VE BEEN WITH NORTHERN COUNTY AND BEEN VERY HAPPY WITH THEM. YOU GAVE US A MAP. THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO BE AN HONEST APPRAISAL OF THE GATES. THEY'RE NOT YOUR GATE. THEY'RE OUR GATE. WE'VE BEEN PAYING FOR THAT GATE. THE ROADWAY INTO HIDDEN KEY IS NOT YOUR ROADWAY. IT'S OUR ROADWAY. WE'VE BEEN PAYING THEM EVERY YEAR FOR IT. YOU MAY LOOK THE OTHER WAY AND SAY WE'RE FULL OF PRUNES, BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS, WE'VE BEEN PAYING FOR THOSE THINGS. THEY'RE OURS. YOU CAN'T TAKE IT AWAY FROM US, AND THEREFORE WE'RE NOT AN ENCLAVE. IF YOU HAVE ANY DOUBTS ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT WE'RE FOR IT OR AGAINST IT, I INVITE YOU ALL TO COME TO HIDDEN KEY AND SEE HOW MANY SIGNS FOR NO ANNEXATION THERE ARE. IT'S ON EVERY HOUSE IN THE SWALE LINE. NO ANNEXATION. WHAT ELSE DO YOU NEED? I DON'T KNOW. GOD BLESS YOU. THANK YOU. SIR, WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO MELISSA. I DON'T WANT TO HAVE TO GAVEL, BUT WE'RE GOING TO HAVE PEOPLE WHO SPEAK IN FAVOR, PEOPLE WHO SPEAK AGAINST. AND IF I HAVE TO GAVEL EVERY TIME WE'LL BE HERE AND IT WILL PUSH BACK THE TIME. SO IF WE COULD JUST HAVE EVERYONE DO OUR THREE MINUTES, IF I HAVE A PRESENTATION ON A ZIP DRIVE I NEED LOADED, I'M GOING TO HAVE TO HAVE YOU TALK TO THE CLERK. SO WE'LL GO ON TO DON OKERSON. OK E R S O N, PLEASE. DON OKERSON NOT HERE. NOT SPEAKING. I HAVE THE NAME ON. THIS IS DON OK. E R S O N LAST CHANCE. ALL RIGHT. ARE YOU SPEAKING, MA'AM? I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY I'M NOT ABLE TO PRESENT A ZIP DRIVE. YOU'LL HAVE TO TALK TO OUR CLERK ABOUT THAT. BUT IN THE MEANTIME, I WOULD LOVE TO ALLOW OTHER FOLKS SOME TIME TO HAVE SOME TESTIMONY, IF THAT'S OKAY. WELL, I MEAN, I CAN READ WHAT I HAVE PREPARED, BUT I WOULD I'D MUCH RATHER HAVE THE VISUAL PRESENTATION THAT I SPENT TIME PUTTING TOGETHER. [01:30:08] IS THERE A PROBLEM WITH IT? I MEAN, I CAN I CAN LET THE ZIP DRIVE BE LOADED. JUST ONE MOMENT. WE DON'T USE USBS AT THE CITY AS A MATTER OF OUR IT POLICY FOR SECURITY REASONS. OF COURSE, IF YOU'D LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND PRESENT, YOU MAY. AND IF NOT, YOU'RE WELCOME TO TO SPEAK WITH SOMEONE ELSE. BUT I DO WANT TO GO AHEAD AND ALLOW EVERYONE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TONIGHT. MY NAME IS MELISSA WIEGAND. I'M AT 2059 PLEASANT DRIVE. AGAIN, JUST LIKE THE ATTORNEY HAD MENTIONED, YOU GUYS ARE IN STRICT VIOLATION OF THE FLORIDA STATUTE. I'M SO SORRY TO INTERRUPT YOU AGAIN. I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. THANK YOU. PER THE FLORIDA STATE STATUTE, 171 MUNICIPAL ANNEXATION CONTRACT ACT, YOU ARE IN TOTAL VIOLATION OF THAT. AND AS WAS MENTIONED EARLIER, CAPTAINS KEY HAS NOW VOLUNTARILY GONE INTO JUNO BEACH. SO THE EIGHT LOTS THAT WERE SOLD BETWEEN 1679 AND 1815, PLEASANT DRIVE THAT WERE ANNEXED INTO THE TOWN OF BEACH, TOWN OF JUNO BEACH, CLEARLY CREATE A FINGER THAT SERPENTINES THE NORTHEAST SECTION OF AREA ONE. ADDITIONALLY, THE PLEASANT RIDGE IS NOT COTERMINOUS WITH ANY PORTION OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS UNLESS THE CITY CREATES A CORRIDOR BY ANNEXING PLATTED LAND TO INCLUDE FIVE PROPERTY ASSOCIATIONS, STARTING WITH WATERWAY VISTA AND ENDING WITH SHELL SUB ON NORTH PALM CIRCLE. THEN PALM BEACH GARDENS HAS TO ANNEX JUNO PARK, OWNED BY PALM BEACH COUNTY, TO GET TO THE PROPERTIES CONTAINED WITHIN PLEASANT RIDGE ON THE WEST SIDE OF ALISON WILSON ROAD. IN CHAPTER 171 .043, THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED, A MUNICIPAL GOVERNING BODY MAY PROPOSE TO ANNEX AN AREA ONLY IF IT MEETS THE GENERAL STANDARDS OF SUBSECTION ONE AND THE REQUIREMENTS OF EITHER SUBSECTION TWO OR SUBSECTION THREE. THE TOTAL AREA TO BE ANNEXED, SUBSECTION ONE MUST BE CONTIGUOUS TO THE MUNICIPALITY'S BOUNDARIES AT THE TIME OF THE ANNEXATION, PROCEEDING HAS BEGUN AND REASONABLY COMPACT. NO PART OF THE MUNICIPALITY SHALL BE WITHIN THE BOUNDARY OF ANOTHER INCORPORATED MUNICIPALITY. AS MENTIONED, JUNO BEACH OWNS EIGHT PARCELS OF LAND ON OUR STREET. THE PARCELS AT 1647 AND 1657 PLEASANT DRIVE ARE OWNED BY LIFESPACE COMMUNITIES, THE PARENT COMPANY OF THE WATERFORD, AND THESE LOTS HAVE PLANS TO BE ANNEXED INTO THE TOWN OF JUNO BEACH IN THE FUTURE. SO AT A MACRO LEVEL, WE YOU HAVE TO SERPENTINE BETWEEN THOSE PROPERTIES THAT THE LIFE SPACE OWNS, WHICH IS THE WATERFORD. THEN IT GOES TO UNINCORPORATED PALM BEACH COUNTY, BACK INTO JUNO BEACH, THEN AT SERPENTINES, AGAIN INTO UNINCORPORATED PALM BEACH COUNTY. ALSO, THE THE COUNTY MENTIONED THAT THEY WANT TO RETAIN OWNERSHIP OF THE PARK, AND THEN THAT CREATES A POCKET TO PREVENT ACCESS TO THE WESTERN SIDE OF PLEASANT DRIVE. ADDITIONALLY, CAPTAIN SKI, LIKE I MENTIONED, HAS BEEN VOLUNTARILY, VOLUNTARILY ANNEXED IN. SO NOW AREA ONE HAS EVEN MORE ADDITIONAL FINGERS AND SERPENTINES INTO THE AREA. THIS JUST REDUCED PALM BEACH COUNTY'S TAX $2.1 MILLION TAX SURPLUS BUDGET BY OVER $128,000, SO MAYOR REED AND HER COMPTROLLER WILL HAVE TO GO RECALCULATE THEIR PROJECTIONS WITH LESS THAN 20% 28% OF REGISTERED VOTERS LIVING ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE INTERCOASTAL. THE RESIDENTS OF PLEASANT RIDGE, HIDDEN KEY AND 15 OTHER PLATTED SUBDIVISIONS HAVE OUR VOTERS RIGHTS INTERFERED WITH. DILUTED BY THE BY THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, SETTING UP A SPECIAL ZONE AREA ONE, WHERE THE RESIDENTS ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE INTERCOASTAL CAN DETERMINE THE FATE OF OUR PARCELS AND DWELLINGS BASED ON AN UNFAIR STATISTICAL ADVANTAGE CONTROLLING OVER 72% OF REGISTERED VOTERS. IN CASE YOU ARE NOT AWARE, LIKE I SAID, CAPTAINS KEYS BEEN ANNEXED. IT SEEMS TO ME THAT IT'S COMPLETELY SURREAL TO ME THAT OVERREACHING ZONE ZONE SET UP BY THE CITY, WHICH CLEARLY VIOLATES FLORIDA STATUTE 171, CAN EXIST WITHOUT ANY TYPE OF STAY OF ESTOPPEL FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY ATTORNEY. THANK YOU. YOUR TIME IS ENDED AND WE DO HAVE QUITE A FEW CARDS LEFT. I WANT TO GIVE EVERYONE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK. NEXT WE HAVE DON OAKERSON, DAVID BRADY AND THEN LYNN BRADY. IF YOU GUYS COULD COME ON UP AND IF YOU COULD BE READY TO COME ON UP. THAT WAY WE CAN MAKE SURE EVERYONE HAS TIME TO SPEAK. DAN DON OAKERSON, DAVID BRADY, PLEASE COME UP AND SPEAK, SIR. YOU'LL HAVE THREE MINUTES IF YOU COULD STATE YOUR NAME, YOUR ADDRESS, AND IF YOU. DAVID BRADY, 2106 PLEASANT DRIVE. SO WE DON'T HAVE DON OKERSON. ALL RIGHT THERE. HE'S NOT THERE. OKAY. DON'T NO WORRIES. WE'LL WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS. I APPRECIATE YOU COMING UP, MR. BRADY. IF YOU COULD STATE YOUR NAME AND YOUR ADDRESS AND IF YOU'VE BEEN SWORN IN. DAVID BRADY, 2106 PLEASANT DRIVE, NORTH PALM. AND I'VE BEEN SWORN IN. I USED TO BE IN THE. I'M RETIRED NOW. LIKE MOST OF THE PEOPLE HERE, I'M LIVING ON A FIXED INCOME. TOPIC OF CONVERSATION. FIRST OF ALL, I'D LIKE TO THANK YOU. BECAUSE OF WHAT YOU'VE ATTEMPTED TO DO HERE, I'VE GOT TO KNOW MY NEIGHBORS, ACTUALLY, YOU KNOW, [01:35:01] AND WHEN CABANA COLONY, THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT SAID THAT THE REASON THEY STRAIGHTENED OUT CABANA, CABANA COLONY, OR PART OF THE REASON THEY GAVE WAS BECAUSE THE NEIGHBORHOOD STARTED TALKING TO EACH OTHER AND THEY STRAIGHTENED OUT THEIR PROBLEMS. THE THE QUESTION THAT KEEPS COMING UP TO ME IN THE CONVERSATION IS, WHY IS THE CITY DOING THIS? WHAT'S REALLY WHAT ARE THEY AFTER? WELL, THERE'S THE END GAME HERE, AND THE THE END GAME IS MONEY AND CONTROL OF THE PROPERTY. AND THE REAL ESTATE BUSINESS IS CALLED ROLLING THE NEIGHBORHOOD OVER OR ROLLING THE PROPERTY OVER. HOW DO I KNOW THAT? I USED TO DO IT. I WAS IN THE DEVELOPMENT BUSINESS. I WAS A CONTRACTOR. I USED TO, BUT THE DIFFERENCE WAS I DIDN'T DO IT FORCEFULLY. I BOUGHT THE PROPERTY, I FIXED IT UP. I GOT RID OF THE TENANTS THAT WEREN'T COOPERATING, MADE IT BETTER. YOU CAN'T DO THAT UNTIL YOU GET CONTROL. MY EXPERIENCE. I'VE LIVED THIS ALREADY. 40 YEARS AGO, I HAD PROPERTY IN LAKE PARK, AND THE TOWN OF LAKE PARK DECIDED THAT THEY WERE GOING TO ROLL THE NEIGHBORHOOD OVER SOUTH KELLEY AND NORTH. EXCUSE ME, NORTH KELLEY AND DRIVE, WHICH IS A WAREHOUSE DISTRICT AND ALL THEIR INFINITE WISDOM. THEY DECIDED THAT THEY WANTED TO MAKE AN ART DECO DISTRICT, AND THEY WANTED ALL THE MOM AND POP BUSINESSES OUT OF THERE, AND THEY WANTED ART GALLERIES, AND THEY WANTED ANTIQUE STORES AND EVERYTHING IN THERE. SO THEY TRIED TO ROLL IT OVER. THEY USED THE CODE ENFORCEMENT TO DO IT. THEY HARASSED IT. EVERYBODY, THE AS TENANTS, AS PROPERTY OWNERS, WE SUFFERED BECAUSE THEY WEREN'T THEY WEREN'T RENEWING OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE. THEY WERE HARASSING. TO GET WHAT THEY WANTED. YOU'RE GOING TO DO THE SAME THING TO GET WHAT YOU WANT, BECAUSE WE'RE ALL SITTING ON A POT OF GOLD, AND THE POT OF GOLD IS BECAUSE WE'RE ALL, WE'VE BEEN HERE SO MANY YEARS, AND WE'RE PAYING TAXES DOWN HERE, AND WE'RE UNDERNEATH THE 3% CAP. YOU NEED TO ROLL THE NEIGHBORHOOD OVER. YOU NEED TO GET EVERYBODY TO SELL AT A HIGHER LEVEL SO YOU CAN QUADRUPLE THE TAXES. THANK YOU SIR. WE HAVE TOTALLY IMMORAL. TOTALLY IMMORAL. I'M SORRY SIR. I THINK WE HAVE YOUR WIFE. NEXT. LYNN BRADY. AND THEN AFTER THAT WILL BE DAVID MENTON. LET'S KEEP IT RESPECTFUL, PLEASE. MY NAME IS LYNN BRADY. I LIVE AT 2106 PLEASANT DRIVE AND I AM SWORN IN AND I WOULD LIKE TO GIVE MY THREE MINUTES TO MELISSA WIG WEIGAND TO FINISH HER PRESENTATION. I'M GOING TO CHECK WITH MY ATTORNEY. NO, WE DON'T TRANSFER TIME. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES, MA'AM, FOR YOUR OPINION. WELL, THEN I'D LIKE TO SAY THAT I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING THAT EVERYBODY HAS ALREADY SAID. PLUS, I ALSO FEEL THEIR ANGER AND THEIR FRUSTRATION. THANK YOU. OKAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE HAVE DAVID MENTON KEVIN F YOU ARE A LOT I THINK IT SAYS AND THEN CHARLES HOLLINGS. SO MR. MENTON. NOW GOING ALONG TO KEVIN FIRLOTTE. NO. OKAY. ARE YOU COMING TO THE PODIUM, SIR? PARDON ME. CHARLES HOLLINGS. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU SIR. AFTER YOU. IF YOU DON'T MIND ME. JUST SAYING. WE'LL HAVE SCOTT LAMBERTSON IF YOU COULD BE READY TO COME ON UP. THANK YOU. CHARLES HOLLINGS, 1679 PLEASANT DRIVE. I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. GOOD EVENING. COUNCIL. IT'S GREAT TO BE WITH YOU AGAIN. FOLLOWING LAST MONTH'S MEETING, AT LEAST ONE MEMBER OF THIS COUNCIL COMMISSIONER MADE THE COMMENT THAT THESE ANNEXATIONS ARE NOT A SURPRISE TO ANYBODY. WELL, WHY SHOULDN'T THEY BE? BECAUSE YOU DISCUSSED ANNEXATION IN 1989. GIVE ME A BREAK. IT'S RATHER CAVALIER ATTITUDE. AND THIS WHOLE THING SMACKS OF IMPERIALISM. DO YOU REALLY THINK NORTH PALM BEACH AND JUNO BEACH THINK OF YOU AS A GOOD NEIGHBOR RIGHT NOW? PROBABLY NOT. FOLLOWING PUBLIC COMMENTS AT THE MEETING LAST MONTH, MAYOR REED COMMENTED THAT ONLY 25 OR 26 PEOPLE SPOKE TO OPPOSE THE ANNEXATION OUT OF APPROXIMATELY 8500 AFFECTED RESIDENTS, AS IF IT WERE INSIGNIFICANT. WELL, MAYBE YOU DID THE WRONG MATH, MADAM MAYOR, BECAUSE 19 OUT OF 20 SPEAKERS OPPOSED THE ANNEXATION. THAT'S A 95% REJECTION RATE. AND SHAKESPEARE MIGHT HAVE REFERRED TO THIS AS FORESHADOWING. [01:40:06] LET ME SEE IF I CAN EXPLAIN IT TO YOU THIS WAY. HOW WOULD YOU REACT, MAYOR REED, IF I TOLD YOU I HAD TO MOVE OUT OF MY HOUSE EARLIER TODAY? I'M MOVING IN WITH YOU TONIGHT. I'M STAYING FOR THE REST OF MY LIFE. YOU PROBABLY REALLY WOULDN'T BE RECEPTIVE TO THAT IDEA. AND THAT'S WHAT PALM BEACH GARDENS HAS DONE TO US. YOU DIDN'T TELL US YOU WERE COMING. YOU DIDN'T ASK US IF WE WANTED YOU TO COME. AND NOW THAT WE'VE TOLD YOU NO, YOU REFUSE TO LEAVE. IN THIS ERA OF THE METOO MOVEMENT, NO MEANS NO N O NO. THAT'S THE BEST WAY I CAN EXPLAIN IT TO YOU AT THIS POINT. MY NEIGHBORS AND I, WE JUST FEEL VIOLATED. AND NOW THAT YOU KNOW THIS, YOU HAVE ONLY ONE RESPONSIBLE COURSE OF ACTION TO TAKE. THAT IS TO VOTE NO ON THE REFERENDUM FOR ANNEXATION TONIGHT. BECAUSE IF YOU DON'T, IT MEANS ONLY ONE THING. YOU DON'T CARE ABOUT US. THANK YOU FOR LISTENING. BUT PLEASE BE AWARE THAT WE'RE NOT GOING AWAY BECAUSE WE NEVER GO AWAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. SIR, WE HAVE SCOTT LAMBERSON. AFTER MR. LAMBERSON, WE HAVE TONY PANDO, AND THEN KATHLEEN MCBRIDE. SCOTT LAMBERSON, 2433. HOPE LANE, RESIDENT OF 35 YEARS, AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. KUDOS TO THE GENTLEMAN HERE. I YOU KNOW, I'M AMAZED I'VE BEEN IN CONSTRUCTION. I KNOW SOME OF YOU GUYS, AND I JUST CAN'T BELIEVE THAT YOU ARE DOING THIS WITHOUT ASKING ANYBODY. AND I REALIZE IT'S FOR TAXES. THE SAME THING. I WAS HERE AT ANOTHER MEETING AND THE FINANCE GIRL SAID, OH, WE KNOW WHAT YOUR TAXES ARE. YOU'RE GOING TO SAVE $300. NO, THEY QUOTED 3500. I'M WAY LOWER THAN THAT. AND SO IT WAS, OH, GO TALK TO HIM. GO TALK TO HIM. IT WAS A BUNCH OF BS AND I'M SORRY. MY MAIN CONCERN, AND I DON'T THINK THAT EVERYBODY REALIZES THAT, ESPECIALLY THE PEOPLE IN CABANA COLONY IS THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. IF YOU OWN A BOAT, IF YOU OWN A MOTORCYCLE, OR IF YOU'RE WORKING ON YOUR CAR, OR MAYBE YOUR GRAPH IS NEEDS A LITTLE BIT OF CUTTING, THEY'RE COMING AND THEY'RE KNOCKING ON THE DOOR AND THEY'RE GOING TO WRITE YOU UP. YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO GET RID OF THE BOAT. YOU MAY HAVE A FAMILY THAT HAS A LOT OF KIDS. THEY MAY HAVE SOME DOGS. OH, YOU'RE UNDER CONTROL NOW. WE DON'T WANT THAT. I'VE BEEN HERE FOR 35 YEARS. GRANTED, I'VE BEEN IN THE SPORTS PROGRAM. I'VE RAISED FOUR KIDS HERE. THEY'VE GONE TO SCHOOL HERE. YOU KNOW, WE LOVE IT, BUT WE DON'T WANT THIS STUFF. AND LIKE EVERYBODY HERE SAID. AND POWER TO THE WOMEN FOR BRINGING IT UP. YOU DON'T ASK. YOU JUST DO IT. AND IT'S IT'S REALLY TOTALLY UNFAIR. I, I JUST DON'T UNDERSTAND IT. I SEE MARTIN TALKING ABOUT SPENDING MONEY, SPENDING MONEY, SPENDING MONEY. WELL, HOW ARE YOU GOING TO RECOUP THAT MONEY? HOW ARE YOU GOING TO GET ALL THAT PAY FOR ALL THAT STUFF THAT MARTIN WAS TALKING ABOUT? YOU GOT TO RAISE THE TAXES, PERIOD, AM I WRONG? SO I WOULD LIKE JUST TO SAY ONE MORE THING. I WOULD REQUEST THE BOARD TO GET A LETTER OUT ON EXACTLY WHAT THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DOES AND WHAT THEIR POWER IS, AND HOW THEY CAN AFFECT A HOMEOWNER. I THINK EVERYBODY SHOULD REALIZE THIS, AND I THINK YOU SHOULD PUT IT IN WRITING. YOU MAY HAVE IT ON YOUR WEBSITE, I DON'T KNOW, I DIDN'T CHECK INTO IT, BUT THE ONLY THING IS FAIR, EVERYBODY KNOWS IS TAXES ARE GOING UP. BUT HOW IS THAT GOING TO AFFECT LIFE AS A RETIRED PERSON WITH CODE ENFORCEMENT? IT'S NOT FAIR. YOU GUYS AREN'T AFFECTED. YOU GOT TO VOTE, RIGHT? THAT'S YOU JUST HAVE TO. YOU CAN'T BE LIKE THE REST OF THE THE GOVERNMENT HERE. YOU GOT TO THINK OF WHAT ALL THESE PEOPLE ARE SAYING AND PLEADING TO YOU GUYS ABOUT. AND YOU KNOW, EVERYBODY HERE IS. RIGHT. SO THAT'S ALL I GOT TO SAY ABOUT THAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE HAVE TONY PANDO, FOLLOWED BY KATHLEEN MCBRIDE, FOLLOWED BY MICHELLE NAULT. TONY. PANDO. GOING ONCE, GOING TWICE. OKAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE HAVE KATHLEEN MCBRIDE. MY NAME IS KATHLEEN MCBRIDE AND I'M SHORT AND I LIVE AT 3762 FLORIDA BOULEVARD IN CABANA COLONY. AND YES, I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. SO A FEW THINGS, REALLY TAKING NOTES FROM SOME OF THE OTHER THAT I JUST WANT TO REITERATE. FIRST OF ALL, I MEAN, SILENCE IS NOT APPROVAL. SO THE COMMENT THAT AND THE REASON I'M HERE TONIGHT IS BECAUSE OF THE COMMENT THAT WAS MADE ABOUT JUST SO FEW PEOPLE SPEAKING LAST TIME. [01:45:03] WELL, NOW YOU GET TO HEAR FROM MORE OF US AND EVERYTHING BECAUSE OF THAT COMMENT AND EVERYTHING. BUT AT THE SAME TIME, LIKE YOU SAID, EVERYBODY WAS SAYING NO, YOU NEED TO LISTEN TO THE NO'S. THE PEOPLE WHO ARE SHOWING UP ARE TALKING FOR A LOT OF US, AND I'M TALKING FOR A LOT OF MY NEIGHBORS AS WELL. THERE'S NO IN FAVORS OF SIGNS IN MY NEIGHBORHOOD. AND AND I LIVE ON THE MAIN ROAD, BUT I DRIVE THROUGH ALL THE OTHER BACK ROADS. I RUN BACK THERE AND EVERYTHING ELSE. OUR NEIGHBORHOOD IS FINE. I MOVED TO THAT NEIGHBORHOOD. I'VE ONLY BEEN THERE FOR A COUPLE OF YEARS NOW. I LOVE THAT NEIGHBORHOOD. ONE OF THE REASONS I BOUGHT IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD, BECAUSE IT WAS NOT IN A CITY. I MOVED FROM SOME PLACE WHERE I WAS OUTSIDE OF THE CITY AND ONLY IN COUNTY CONTROL, AND I DO NOT WANT THE CITY TYPE STUFF THAT YOU'VE BEEN HEARING MORE ABOUT AROUND HERE. AS FAR AS I AM WANTING AN ABSOLUTE ANSWER TO THIS THING OF IF SOMEBODY DOESN'T VOTE, IF A HOUSEHOLD DOESN'T VOTE, THAT IT GETS COUNTED AS A YES. THAT BEST NOT BE THE CASE. I'M I'M HOPING THAT WHOEVER COMES TO VOTE THAT DAY, THE MAJORITY IS THE WHO WINS, IN WHICH CASE THIS IS NOT GOING TO END UP PASSING BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW OF ANYBODY WHO'S IN FAVOR OF IT. LET'S SEE, WHAT ELSE DO I HAVE TO SAY HERE? WE ARE NOT COMPACT. I MEAN, I THIS LOOKS LIKE GERRYMANDERING OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT TO ME. WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE LINES OF THE SECTION ONE THAT YOU ALL ARE TALKING ABOUT, THERE'S A COUPLE OF PROGRAMS THAT CABANA COLONY HAS, ITS PAL PROGRAM AND THE FOOD DISTRIBUTION. THOSE WILL GO AWAY. ANYBODY WHO THINKS THEY WON'T, YOU'RE WRONG. THOSE ARE SUPPORTED BY THE COUNTY AND BY THE COUNTY POLICE. IF THE COUNTY POLICE AREN'T SUPPORTING US LIKE THEY HAVE BEEN, THEY'RE GOING TO BE GOING TO THE OTHER AREAS WHERE THESE PROGRAMS DO EXIST. BUT THE PEOPLE WHO'VE BEEN SERVED BY THEM IN OUR AREA ARE NOT GOING TO BE BEING SERVED ANYMORE. AND THAT'S A FACT. AND I JUST DON'T SEE ANY ADVANTAGE TO US. AS FAR AS Y'ALL COMING IN. WE JUST GOT ALL THE ENTIRE NEIGHBORHOOD REPAVED. THAT WAS COUNTY. WHAT ARE YOU ALL GOING TO DO? WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO IMPROVE? YOU'RE GOING TO BE PUTTING ALL CODE ENFORCEMENT ON US AND STUFF LIKE THAT. AND I DON'T WANT IT AND NEITHER DO MY NEIGHBORS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE HAVE MICHELLE NAULTY, FOLLOWED BY DANIEL HAJEK, FOLLOWED BY BARBARA GERTH. DO WE HAVE, MICHELLE? NOT HERE. NO. OKAY. DANIEL HAJEK, FOLLOWED BY BARBARA. I THINK IT'S. MR. SAHAK. THANK YOU. MY NAME IS DANIEL HAJEK. I'M HERE FROM 1230081833410. I'D LIKE TO. HAVE YOU BEEN SWORN IN? YES, I HAVE. THANK YOU. I'D LIKE TO JUST START OFF AND SAY I'M A HUGE SUPPORTER OF PALM BEACH GARDENS AND THE STATE OF FLORIDA. THANK YOU FOR ALL BEING HERE TODAY AND ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK IN FRONT OF YOU. I'D LIKE TO OFFER A SUGGESTION. AS A COMMERCIAL SENSE, COMMERCIAL PROPERTY OWNERS ARE NOT ALLOWED TO VOTE. CAN THERE BE A CLAUSE THAT SAYS IF ANNEXATION IS VOTED FOR, WHATEVER HAPPENS THERE JUST TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS, MAY ALL THE BUNDLE OF RIGHTS THAT COMMERCIAL PROPERTY OWNERS HAVE IN THE COUNTY PRIOR TO ANNEXATION PLEASE BE GRANDFATHERED IN. THIS FOR FOR ALL COMMERCIAL PROPERTY OWNED PRIOR TO ANNEXATION. I HOPE THAT WE CAN ADD THIS SAFE HARBOR TO BALANCE THE PRESERVATION OF THE BUNDLE OF RIGHTS AND ANNEXATION. I BELIEVE THAT THIS IS A FAIR WAY TO PRESERVE THE RIGHTS, PROTECT THE COMMERCIAL OWNERS AND. JUST TO HAVE A FAIR RESOLUTION ON THAT. SO AS A COMMERCIAL PROPERTY OWNER NOT BEING ABLE TO VOTE. I APPRECIATE YOU GUYS HEARING THAT REQUEST. THANK YOU KINDLY. THANK YOU SIR. WE HAVE BARBARA AND THEN SARAH WILLIAMSON, IF YOU COULD, IF IF YOUR NAME IS CALLED, IF YOU COULD STAND UP AND GET INTO THE ROW LIKE THE VICE MAYOR ASKED, THAT WOULD BE SUPER HELPFUL SO THAT WE IF WE MISS ANYONE OR ANYONE LEFT, WE'LL BE ABLE TO MOVE FORWARD. AND THEN AFTER THAT WE HAVE J. WILLIAMS. THANK YOU. HELLO. MY NAME IS BARBARA GERTH, 2578 VENICE DRIVE. I'VE BEEN A RESIDENT. I'M SWORN IN. YES. THANK YOU. I'VE BEEN A RESIDENT OF THAT HOME AND IN THAT AREA FOR 45 YEARS. I'M A THIRD GENERATION NATIVE FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY. NEVER LEFT. STAYED IN THE NORTH END OF PALM BEACH COUNTY BY CHOICE. AND THAT IS BECAUSE EVERYWHERE THAT WE HAVE BEEN IS BEEN IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA BY CHOICE. WE CHOSE TO STAY IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA SO THAT WE WOULD NOT HAVE DOUBLE TAXATION, AND I PREFER THAT IT STAY THAT WAY. I DO NOT WANT TO BE ANNEXED. AND I DO HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE BOARD. SITTING HERE IS I AM ON A DEAD END STREET THAT IS MYSELF AND. 1/25 STREET IS COMPLETELY SURROUNDED BY FRENCHMAN'S PRESERVE. THERE IS NO WAY PALM BEACH GARDENS TOUCHES ANY OF OUR PROPERTY OR THROUGH THE PRESERVE. AND THERE NO IN OR OUT, THROUGH PALM BEACH GARDENS OR ANY OTHER MUNICIPALITY. [01:50:02] SO I'D LIKE TO KNOW HOW I AM INCLUDED IN AREA ONE, BECAUSE THERE IS NO WAY THAT YOU CAN BE A PART OF THAT AREA. BECAUSE. OF THE PRESERVE AS FAR AS ANY TYPE OF COST BENEFIT. I KNOW PEOPLE HAVE TALKED ABOUT THE TAXES. I'M OPPOSED TO INCREASING TAXES AS WELL, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT THAT IT WAS BROUGHT UP THROUGH THE ANALYSIS THAT PALM BEACH GARDENS IS GOING TO MAKE A PROFIT EVERY YEAR OFF OF THIS, AND THAT WILL BE THROUGH OUR TAX DOLLARS, AND I DON'T FEEL LIKE WE NEED IT. WE HAVE GREAT SERVICES THROUGH THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE, THROUGH ALL OF THE COUNTY SERVICES. THERE'S NOTHING PALM BEACH GARDENS CAN OFFER THAT WE DON'T ALREADY HAVE, AND WE DON'T NEED ANY MORE ADDITIONAL GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT. SO NO MATTER WHICH WAY YOU SLICE IT, WE WILL SEE. AN INCREASE IN TAXES IN THE CITY OF PALM BEACH. GARDENS WILL BENEFIT FROM IT. NOT NECESSARILY ANY INCREASED SERVICES FOR ANY OF THE RESIDENTS IN ANY OF THE AREAS. THIS IS A LAND GRAB FOR TAX REVENUE AND FOR PROFIT, AND I AM COMPLETELY OPPOSED IT. AND ALL OF MY NEIGHBORS ARE AS WELL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU MA'AM. WE HAVE SARAH WILLIAMSON. AS JAY WILLIAMS HERE FOR AFTER MISS WILLIAMSON. AND THEN BOB ACTUALLY WASN'T SWORN IN. ALL RIGHT, WE'LL GET YOU SWORN IN. THANK YOU FOR LETTING US KNOW. YOU WANT ME TO STEP TO THE SIDE? SHE'LL TAKE CARE OF YOU RIGHT WHERE YOU'RE AT. DO YOU SOLEMNLY SWEAR TO TELL THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH, SO HELP YOU GOD? THANK YOU. MY NAME IS SARAH WILLIAMSON. I LIVE AT 11855 ALLISON WILSON ROAD. UNFORTUNATELY, LAST TIME I DID GO IN THE WRONG GROUPING AND I FELT LIKE I REALLY HAD YOUR ATTENTION. I ACTUALLY GOT A PHONE CALL FROM ONE OF YOUR ASSISTANTS AND SPOKE TO THEM, AND I UNDERSTAND THAT YOU GUYS ACTUALLY DO CARE AND YOU ARE LISTENING BECAUSE I DID FEEL THE CONNECTION FROM EACH OF YOU, NOT THE CITY OF ATTORNEY OR MANAGER. I KNOW THAT THEY'RE NOT TOTALLY PAYING ATTENTION, BUT YOU GUYS CLEARLY ARE CONNECTING. AND I SEE YOUR CIVIL SERVANTS, AND I KNOW THAT YOU PROBABLY ALL ENDED UP IN THOSE SEATS BECAUSE YOU SAW SOMETHING THAT YOU WANTED TO DO FOR YOUR COMMUNITY, AND YOU WANTED TO MAKE IT BETTER. I THINK THAT'S AMAZING. AND I THINK IT'S GREAT THAT YOU'VE DONE THAT. BUT I THINK IN LISTENING, I THINK YOU NEED TO ALSO HEAR A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE, I MEAN, MY WHOLE NEIGHBORHOOD, I'M REPRESENTING ABOUT 25 PEOPLE WHO ARE LIKE, YES, SARAH, GO TALK TO THEM AND LET THEM KNOW HOW WE FEEL THAT ARE BUSY WITH THEIR FAMILIES AND CAN'T COME. AND ALL THESE PEOPLE PROBABLY ARE REPRESENTING OTHERS AS WELL. I THINK YOU HAVE A HUGE COMMUNITY. WHO IS BEING REALLY CLEAR. AND I'VE TOLD YOU BEFORE THAT I DON'T THINK THE VIBE OF THE EXPONENTIAL GROWTH THAT YOU GUYS HAVE SUITS OUR COMMUNITY. I SEE AVENIR, I THINK YOU GUYS ARE GOING TO GET TONS OF MONEY IN TAX REVENUE FROM THAT NEIGHBORHOOD. I THINK YOU SHOULD FOCUS ON THAT. I THINK YOU SHOULD LOOK AT ALL THE DEVELOPMENT THAT YOU'RE DOING AND NOT LOOK TO A COMMUNITY THAT ALREADY EXISTS AND IS DOING WELL AS YOUR NEW VENUE FOR GETTING TAX REVENUE. YOU KNOW, I COMMEND YOU ON WHAT YOU'VE ATTEMPTED TO DO. I DID SPEAK TO TONS OF PEOPLE. EVERYONE WAS VERY NICE SO FAR. THE ONLY BENEFIT THAT WAS TOLD TO ME WAS THAT I WOULD GET REDUCED ADMISSION TO COMMUNITY CENTER ACTIVITIES. I'M SORRY, I DIDN'T MEAN TO LAUGH. IT'S NOT FOR ME. I'M NOT INTERESTED IN THAT. I AM A BOAT OWNER. OCCASIONALLY MY BOAT IS STORED IN MY YARD. I WAS TOLD THAT I COULD BE GRANDFATHERED IN AS A BOAT OWNER. OCCASIONALLY I GET ANOTHER BOAT AND I SELL MY OLD ONE. WHEN I GET THAT BOAT, THAT BOAT WON'T BE GRANDFATHERED IN. THAT WILL BE NOT ALLOWED ACCORDING TO THE FUTURE PRESENTATION OF HOW THE CODE WILL BE ENACTED IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD. FOR ALL THE BOAT OWNERS, I THINK THAT SHOULD BOTHER YOU A LITTLE BIT PERSONALLY. I THINK THAT YOUR TOWN, YOUR CITY IS WONDERFUL. I DON'T MIND WHAT YOU'RE DOING WITH IT, EXCEPT FOR THE MARINA THAT I'M GOING TO HAVE TO LOOK AT. BUT PERSONALLY, I REALLY HOPE THAT YOU'RE CONSIDERING WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING. I KNOW THAT YOU'RE HERE. I'VE SEEN EACH ONE OF YOU REALLY LOOK ME IN THE EYE. LOOK ALL THESE PEOPLE IN THE EYE. THESE ARE GOING TO BE PEOPLE THAT ARE GOING TO BE VOTING AGAINST YOU IN THE NEXT ELECTION. SO PLEASE LISTEN. THANK YOU. THAT'S TRUE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'VE GOT DO WE HAVE JAY WILLIAMS HERE? AFTER JAY WE HAVE BOB MINKOWITZ AND THEN DONNA OKERSON COME BACK. NO. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. SO WE'VE GOT JAY WILLIAMS AND THEN BOB MINKOWITZ. I'M JAY WILLIAMS, 1881 KATHY LANE, NORTH PALM BEACH, FLORIDA. [01:55:02] I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. THANK YOU. I REITERATE EVERYTHING THAT I'VE HEARD. YOU GUYS KNOW WHERE WE STAND. WE WOULDN'T BE HERE. WE KNOW WHERE YOU GUYS STAND OR YOU ALL PROBABLY WOULDN'T BE HERE EITHER. I JUST WOULD LIKE TO PLEAD A CASE THAT, YOU KNOW, THERE'S PEOPLE OF ALL AGES HERE. IT'S GOING TO WRECK A LOT OF FAMILIES. WE JUST MOVED HERE NOT TOO LONG AGO. COULD PUSH US OUT. YOU'VE GOT PEOPLE WHO'VE BEEN PAYING TAXES FOR 30, 40 YEARS. IT COULD PUSH THEM OUT. DON'T HAVE AN ELITIST MINDSET. WE SEE WHAT'S GOING ON ALL OVER THE PLACE. BIG GOVERNMENT IS NOT THE ANSWER. YOU GUYS DON'T WANT IT. WE DON'T WANT IT. YOU KNOW, DONORS ARE NOT A GREAT THING. THEY USUALLY DON'T TELL YOU THE RIGHT THING. DON'T DO WHAT THE DONORS WANT. THIS IS NOT A GOOD MOVE. THIS IS NOT SOMETHING YOU'LL LOOK BACK AND BE PROUD OF. YEAH. DON'T DO IT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE HAVE BOB MINKOWITZ. OKAY. GOOD EVENING. I'M BOB MANKIEWICZ, 1843, CATHY LANE. I WAS SWORN IN. I RECEIVED A BROCHURE, AS MOST EVERYBODY HERE HAS, WHERE IT SAYS IS REGULARLY PALM BEACH GARDENS, REGULARLY APPROACHED BY PROPERTY OWNERS REQUESTING ANNEXATION. NO FURTHER REFERENCE ON A WEBSITE, YOU CITE THAT THERE WAS 25 PEOPLE THAT REQUESTED ANNEXATION. I JUST DO A REAL QUICK, REAL QUICK, INFORMAL SURVEY. HOW MANY PEOPLE HERE ARE OPPOSED TO THE ANNEXATION? I'M SORRY SIR. OKAY. ANYBODY IN FAVOR? OKAY, SO YOU CITE THAT THERE WERE 25 PEOPLE IN FAVOR? I THINK BASED ON JUST A QUICK INFORMAL SURVEY, PEOPLE YOU CAN ACTUALLY SEE SHOW YOU SOMETHING TO THE CONTRARY. MAYBE IF THERE'S LIKE 25 OR MORE PEOPLE, WE GOT TOGETHER AND SAID, WE WANT A CASINO. I WONDER IF YOU ALL WOULD DO THE SAME LEVEL OF RESEARCH AND PLANNING AND DO ALL THAT. SO THAT'S MAYBE IN THE FUTURE. THE OTHER THING THAT WAS KIND OF REALLY UPSETTING, VERY, VERY DISINGENUOUS, IS IN THE ANNEXATION PLAN, WHICH YOU'VE ALREADY PUT TOGETHER, YOU SHOW THAT THERE'S A FUTURE DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR OUR FOR ANNEXING OUR PROPERTY. TO MY KNOWLEDGE, NOT ONE OF US HAS HAD ANY INPUT INTO YOUR FUTURE DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF OUR AREA. THAT'S REALLY SAD. OKAY, NOT A GOOD THING. THAT'S MY TIME. WHAT ELSE? WE GOT ANOTHER THING THAT WAS NOT INCLUDED AT ALL. WHAT ABOUT THE COST TO US? IF BY CHANCE, GOD FORBID, WE DO GET ANNEXED, WHAT ABOUT THE COST TO US? I GOT TO CHANGE ADDRESSES ON INSURANCE, ON MORTGAGE, ON 100 OR MORE CONTACTS. I GOT TO TELL EVERYBODY I KNOW, EVERYBODY I EVER MET. MY NEW ADDRESS IS PALM BEACH GARDENS. THAT'S COST TO ME. IT COST A WHOLE BUNCH OF OTHER PEOPLE. IS THERE ANY. DOES ANYBODY CARE ABOUT THAT? NOT APPARENTLY. WHAT ELSE I GOT? I DIDN'T THINK I WAS GOING TO GET IT DONE THIS QUICK. WHAT ELSE THEY GET COST RENTAL PROPERTY. WELL, THERE'S JUST A BUNCH OF OTHER TAX REQUESTS. I'M ONE OF THE VERY, VERY MANY PEOPLE THAT WILL BE PAYING MORE IN TAXES. AND AGAIN, I WAS KIND OF SURPRISED THAT PEOPLE THAT DID DO THE ANALYSIS FOUND OUT THAT THERE'S A LOT OF NUMBERS THAT ARE WRONG. ALSO, I DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S ANY COST THAT GETS PASSED ON TO THE COUNTY. IF BY CHANCE WE DO GET ANNEXED, WE PAY YOU TAXES, DOES THAT MEAN THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE LESS COST TO THE COUNTY? ARE THEY ACTUALLY GOING TO REDUCE THEIR SHERIFF'S NUMBER? I DON'T THINK SO. OKAY. SO GOVERNMENT IS JUST GOING TO GET BIGGER. PALM BEACH GARDENS IS GOING TO GET BIGGER. THE COUNTY IS GOING TO STAY THE SAME. THAT'S NOT A GOOD THING. THAT'S NOT A GOOD THING. YOU ALL CAN VOTE RIGHT NOW TONIGHT TO JUST KILL THIS. YOU CAN DO IT. OKAY. YOU GOT A WHOLE BUNCH OF PEOPLE THAT ARE SAYING NO TO THIS. YOU'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD WITH IT. FINE. WE'RE GOING TO PUT UP OUR SIGNS. WE'RE GOING TO GO DOOR TO DOOR AND WE'RE GOING TO DEFEAT THIS. OKAY. WHY DON'T YOU JUST SAVE ALL THE TIME AND MONEY AND THE HASSLE, OKAY? IT'S NOT THAT HARD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SIR. THAT IS THE END OF OUR CARDS FOR ORDINANCE 20. SO I DON'T HAVE ANY FURTHER CARDS. MAX, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE BEFORE WE CLOSE THE HEARING? YES, MADAM MAYOR, AS I DID LAST TIME, WE'RE GOING TO INCORPORATE THE ENTIRETY OF THE STAFF REPORT, WHICH IS IN THE AGENDA PACKAGE AND INCLUDES THE ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR ORDINANCE 2023 INTO THE RECORD. AND THERE ARE A COUPLE OF THINGS THAT I SHOULD PROBABLY ADDRESS TO ANSWER SOME QUESTIONS, BECAUSE I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE ARE CLEAR ON A FEW THINGS. A COUPLE OF PEOPLE ASKED ABOUT THE VOTING. SO I WANT TO BE CRYSTAL CLEAR ON THAT, BECAUSE I THINK THAT'S A PENULTIMATE QUESTION THAT SHOULD WEIGH HEAVILY ON EVERYONE'S MIND. FAILING TO VOTE IS NOT A YES VOTE. ABSOLUTELY NOT. STATE LAW IS CLEAR. AND PLEASE UNDERSTAND THAT THIS PROCESS FOR A REFERENDUM ANNEXATION IS SET FORTH IN STATE STATUTE. IT'S NOT THE CITY'S POLICIES, IT'S STATE LAW. IT'S CHAPTER 171 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES. AND IT IS TO PASS THE FOR THE REFERENDUM PASS, YOU HAVE TO HAVE ONE MORE VOTE THAN 50% OF THE PEOPLE THAT VOTE. [02:00:09] THAT'S THE WAY IT WORKS. NOT VOTING IS NOT A YES VOTE. NOT VOTING IS NOT A NO VOTE. IT'S A NO VOTE. YOU DIDN'T VOTE. SO IF THERE ARE 5000 PEOPLE IN THE AREA AND FIVE 4000 PEOPLE VOTE, IT'S 50. IT'S 2001 VOTES WOULD WOULD BE A POSITIVE 2001 AGAINST WOULD BE NEGATIVE. THE 1000 PEOPLE THAT DON'T VOTE THEIR VOTE JUST ISN'T. IT'S A NON VOTE. YOU DIDN'T VOTE. SO IT DOESN'T MEAN ANYTHING. IT'S NOT COUNTED. THAT'S NOT THE WAY IT WORKS. AS IT RELATES TO OWNERSHIP OF PROPERTY. ANNEXATION DOES NOT CHANGE OWNERSHIP. NOT AT ALL. ALL IT DOES IS REDRAW A BOUNDARY LINE INSTEAD OF NO LONGER BEING INSTEAD OF BEING IN THE UNINCORPORATED COUNTY. THE PROPERTIES WOULD THEN BE IN THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. IT DOESN'T CHANGE OWNERSHIP. YOUR LAND USE AND ZONING DON'T CHANGE UNTIL THE CITY ADOPTS A NEW LAND USE AND ZONING. IT IS. THAT IS WHAT IT IS. YOUR USES THAT ARE EXISTING AND ARE LEGAL USES IN THE COUNTY RIGHT NOW REMAIN LEGAL USES. THEY'RE GRANDFATHERED AS IT RELATES TO THE THE QUESTION FROM THE GENTLEMAN THAT HAD A COMMERCIAL PROPERTY, THEIR USES ARE IF IT'S A LEGALLY PERMITTED USE UNDER THE CURRENT COUNTY ZONING, IT WOULD REMAIN A LEGALLY PERMITTED USE. IT WAS GRANDFATHERED EVEN IF THE CITY CHANGES THE ZONING, AND IT WOULD SO THAT IT WOULD THEN BECOME WHAT THEY CALL A LEGAL NONCONFORMITY. YOU GET TO CONTINUE THAT USE. YOUR PROPERTIES DO NOT GET REASSESSED MERELY BECAUSE YOU'RE ANNEXED INTO THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. YOUR VALUATION OF YOUR PROPERTY IS THE VALUATION OF YOUR PROPERTY. IT DOESN'T AUTOMATICALLY GET REASSESSED AND GO UP. THERE'S THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY AND THEN THE TAX RATE. THOSE ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS. CAPTAIN'S KEY. FOR THE RECORD, HAS NOT VOLUNTARILY ANNEXED INTO THE TOWN OF JUNO BEACH YET THAT HAS NOT OCCURRED. THEY THEY HAVE TO PASS AN ORDINANCE AND THEY HAVEN'T THEY HAVE NOT PASSED THAT ORDINANCE YET. AND IF IT DOES PASS, THEN THAT WILL BE DEALT WITH BY THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS. THERE WERE COMMENTS MADE ABOUT THE TIMING OF THIS ELECTION. IT WAS I THINK SOMEBODY SAID THAT IT WAS. BUT IT WAS THAT IT WAS. IT WAS DONE ON PURPOSE ON AN OFF ELECTION. YOU'RE RIGHT. IT WAS BY THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS BECAUSE SHE HAS GOT SO MUCH GOING ON. THERE WAS NO WAY YOU WERE GOING TO GET A MUNICIPAL REFERENDUM ON THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION, FOR OBVIOUS REASONS. I THINK YOU COULD ALL UNDERSTAND. SO THIS IS A PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY. IT'S NOT AN OFF ELECTION. THIS IS A PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY, PREFERENTIAL PRIMARY ELECTION THAT IS HAPPENING. SO THERE'S USUALLY A VERY HIGH VOTER TURNOUT. AND THAT'S ONE OF THE REASONS THAT THAT ELECTION DATE WAS CHOSEN. AND AS IT RELATES TO THE EXPERT, WE'VE ACCEPTED. JUST FOR THE RECORD, MR. NICKLAUS, IS IT GEISLER? GIESELER. I JUST WANT TO PRONOUNCE IT PROPERLY. WE'VE ACCEPTED THAT INTO THE INTO THE INTO THE CITY'S FILE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE ON BEHALF OF THE CLIENTS THAT HE LISTED. BUT FOR THE RECORD, THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS AN EXPERT LEGAL WITNESS. THE PROFFERED, THAT IS, EXPERT TESTIMONY ON THE LAW. THAT'S THE JUDGE. THAT'S THE COURT. THERE'S NO EXPERT WITNESS TESTIMONY AS IT RELATES TO A LEGAL ISSUE. YOU CAN RENDER A LEGAL OPINION, BUT IT'S NOT EXPERT TESTIMONY. IT WAS PROFFERED AS EXPERT TESTIMONY AND IT'S NOT EXPERT TESTIMONY. SO IT SHOULD BE CONSIDERED IN THAT VEIN. IT IS AN OPINION. AS IT RELATES TO THE COMPACTNESS. COMPACTNESS, AS DEFINED UNDER THE FLORIDA STATUTES DOESN'T MEAN SMALL. IT MEANS THAT YOU CANNOT ANNEX IN SUCH A FASHION AS TO CREATE ENCLAVES, POCKETS, OR SERPENTINE PATTERNS. IF YES I KNOW OR FINGERS AND YOU YOU CAN'T ANNEX TO CREATE THEM AND IT DOES NOT THIS ZONE. THIS AREA DOES NOT CREATE FINGERS. HIDDEN KEY IS AN ENCLAVE BASED UPON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY AND THE RECORD AND THAT WE HAVE IT IS YOU HAVE TO PASS THROUGH THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS TO GET INTO HIDDEN KEY. THE ENTRANCE INTO HIDDEN KEY IS OWNED BY NORTH PALM BEACH IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. AGAIN, OWNERSHIP DOES NOT AFFECT ANNEXATION. IT DOES NOT AFFECT BOUNDARIES. YOUR PROPERTY WON'T CHANGE OWNERSHIP BECAUSE IT'S ANNEXED IF IT IS. THE PROPERTIES ARE CONTIGUOUS. IT IS COMPACT. IT DOES SATISFY THE REQUIREMENTS AS SET FORTH IN THE FLORIDA STATUTES, BASED UPON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY IN THE RECORD. ADDITIONALLY, THE PEOPLE WILL GET TO VOTE. THIS ORDINANCE PASSES, IT WILL GO TO A REFERENDUM, AND YOU WILL GET TO VOTE. EVERY SINGLE SOLITARY PERSON WITHIN THAT REGISTERED VOTER IN THAT DISTRICT WILL GET TO VOTE. THE PROPERTY OWNERS THAT ARE UPSET ABOUT THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE RENTERS AND THEY DON'T LIVE AT THE PROPERTY, AND SO THEY DON'T GET TO VOTE BECAUSE THERE'S NOT A REGISTERED VOTER. WE DIDN'T MAKE THAT RULE. THAT'S THE FLORIDA STATUTES. [02:05:02] THAT'S THE FLORIDA LEGISLATURE THAT ESTABLISHED THAT PROCESS AND RULE, NOT US. SO I CAN UNDERSTAND BEING DISSATISFIED WITH THAT, BUT THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE CITY. THIS PROCESS AND THE MANNER IN WHICH THIS IS CONDUCTED AND HAS BEEN CONDUCTED BY THE CITY, IS SET FORTH IN THE FLORIDA STATUTES, AND WE HAVE FOLLOWED THAT TO THE LETTER. I HAVE NOTHING ELSE. MAMA. SOUNDS LIKE YOU ALREADY. THANK YOU. MAX. I'M SORRY. YOU WILL BE DISMISSED AND REMOVED IF YOU SPEAK OUT OF TURN. PLEASE. WE. WE'RE ALL BEING RESPECTFUL. WE WERE RESPECTFUL OF EVERY SINGLE PERSON THAT SPOKE. WE DIDN'T SPEAK OVER YOU. WE DIDN'T CLAP, CAJOLE OR DO ANYTHING. AND WE ASK THE SAME IN RETURN. THANK YOU. SO WE NEED TO GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THIS HEARING. IT'S I'M GOING TO I'M GOING TO KEEP RUNNING MY MEETING. AND IF YOU GUYS ARE GOING TO KEEP SPEAKING OUT OF TURN, I DON'T WANT TO HAVE SOMEONE REMOVED TONIGHT. I REALLY DON'T I WANT THIS TO BE DUE DISCOURSE. WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE? MAYOR, I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 2023, AS PRESENTED ON ITS SECOND AND FINAL READING. BASED ON THE FINDINGS AND THE FACT OF CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, THAT ALL REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 171 .042 FLORIDA STATUTES HAVE BEEN FULLY SATISFIED AND COMPLIED WITH, AND THAT THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED FULLY COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH AT SECTION ONE. 71.043 FLORIDA STATUTES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, CARL. MAY I GET A SECOND? I'LL MAKE A SECOND. ALL RIGHT, LET'S BRING IT BACK FOR DISCUSSION. OUR CITY COUNCIL WILL NOW HAVE DISCUSSION ABOUT WHAT WAS PRESENTED TO YOU. SO IF YOU'LL ALLOW US THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TO EACH OTHER AND ASK SOME QUESTIONS. SO DO I HAVE ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO GO FIRST IN DISCUSSION? I'LL GO. FIRST ON PALM BEACH GARDENS IS IN BIG GOVERNMENT BECAUSE I THINK IT IT GOES THE PATH OF ITS COUNCIL. I WAS A COP HERE FOR 30 YEARS BETWEEN JUPITER AND PALM BEACH GARDENS. I DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO BE GOVERNMENT AT ALL. THE DISCUSSION OF ANNEXATION THAT BEFORE THEY EVEN THE WHEELS WERE EVEN IN MOTION WAS WAS REALLY SOLELY TO SQUARE OFF OUR BOUNDARIES. YOU KNOW, PALM BEACH GARDENS IS A LARGE CITY AND WE'VE GOT WE'VE GOT HOLES ALL OVER IT, YOU KNOW, LIKE LAKE OKEECHOBEE IS IN THE MIDDLE OF OUR CITY, AND IT'S A IT THEY'RE MAKING A RUN AT IT TO SEE WHO WANTS TO COME INTO THE CITY. I HEAR A LOT OF STUFF THAT ONE OF THE HARDEST THINGS FOR ME TO DO IS SIT UP HERE AND LISTEN TO PEOPLE THAT ARE SAYING THINGS THAT AREN'T TRUE. IF YOU HAVE A BOAT, I DON'T CARE. IF YOU CHANGE A BOAT 20 TIMES A WEEK, YOU'RE GRANDFATHERED INTO IT AND THAT'S THE END OF IT. THE CITY COUNCIL SEES FIT. I MYSELF HAS MADE SURE THAT WITH OUR CODE ENFORCEMENT THAT IF THERE'S NO IF THERE'S NO SMOKE, DON'T MAKE FIRE. SO I TAKE A LITTLE PERSONAL OFFENSE THAT OUR CODE ENFORCEMENT IS GOING TO COME IN AND BE. YOU KNOW, PARENTING YOU GUYS ON WHAT YOU HAVE IN YOUR YARD. NONE OF US ARE LIKE THAT. I LIVE RIGHT AT HOOD AND MILITARY TRAIL, RAISED MY FAMILY HERE, AND I'VE BEEN IN CABANA COLONY HUNDREDS OF TIMES OVER THE YEARS ON AND OFF AS A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. SO YOU GUYS ARE MY NEIGHBORS. THIS ISN'T US AGAINST YOU. BY NO MEANS. IF YOU DON'T WANT IT, DON'T VOTE FOR IT. YOU KNOW, IT DOESN'T COME DOWN TO THE MONEY. YOU GUYS THINK THAT PALM BEACH GARDENS REALLY NEEDS AN EXTRA $2 MILLION WHEN THE CANAL IN CABANA COLONY. TOTALLY UNTRUTHFUL. THE CITY HAS PLENTY OF PLENTY OF TIME AND MONEY TO FIX THAT CANAL IN A TIMELY FASHION, JUST LIKE WE DO THE OTHER 200 CANALS WE HAVE. IT GOES INTO A MAINTENANCE PROGRAM AND IT GETS MAINTAINED. I'M NOT MAKING THAT UP. THE CANAL WILL BE RESOLVED AND FIXED IF YOU'RE ON WELL WATER, STAY ON IT. WE DON'T CARE. IF YOU WANT CITY WATER, APPROACH US. YOU KNOW WE'RE HERE TO HELP YOU. AND IF IF YOU HAVE A YOUNGER SINGLE PARENT MOTHER, IT MAYBE MAKES A DIFFERENCE TO HER IF SHE CAN GET SOME OF THE THE COMMUNITY DISCOUNTS WITH OUR OUR CLUBS AND OUR DAYCARE AND OUR OUR POOL AND OUR STUFF BECAUSE IT'S NOT FIRST COME, FIRST SERVE IN PALM BEACH GARDENS. IF YOU LIVE IN PALM BEACH GARDENS, YOU'RE AT THE TOP OF THE FOOD CHAIN WHEN IT COMES TO USING OUR RECREATION PICKLEBALL OR TENNIS OR OR WHATEVER ELSE IT IS. SO I'M AN ADVOCATE FOR PALM BEACH GARDENS, BUT I'M ALSO AN ADVOCATE FOR YOU ALL AS WELL. I HEAR WHAT YOU'RE SAYING, AND I KNOW THERE'S PROBABLY 6000 VOTERS IN AREA ONE, AND I WANT EVERYBODY TO SAY THEIR PIECE. AND IF THE CITY WANTS TO MAKE A RUN AT IT AND IT GETS VOTED DOWN, I'M GOING TO BE OKAY WITH THAT. YOU KNOW, I MEAN, THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE OUT THERE THAT LIKE TO BE IN PALM BEACH GARDENS. I CAN'T SAY 50 PEOPLE APPROACHES ME. I SHOP AT HOOD AND THE HOOD ROAD PUBLIX. AND OVER THE YEARS, LONG BEFORE THIS CONVERSATION CAME UP, PEOPLE DID APPROACH ME IN CABANA COLONY. IT WASN'T EVEN ON MY RADAR. HEY, WHEN'S CABANA COLONY GOING TO GET ANNEXED? [02:10:02] NOT THAT I'M USING THAT AS AMMUNITION, BUT YOU KNOW, I HAVE BEEN APPROACHED FOR IT, BUT AGAIN, NOT BY THIS MANY PEOPLE. I RESPECT YOUR PASSION AND I APPRECIATE EVERY ONE OF YOU AND WHAT YOU'VE HAD TO SAY AND DELIVER TO US. AND OUR EYES ARE WIDE OPEN. OUR EARS ARE WIDE OPEN. I HAVE ADDRESSED CABANA COLONY AND ASKED. I WENT TO THE LAST TWO MEETINGS ON ANNEXATION AT THE. MOOSE LODGE, MOSTLY ON RCA. I APPROACHED THE PEOPLE AT CABANA COLONY AND ASKED THEM IF THEY WOULD LIKE US TO COME IN AND OR MYSELF. PERSONALLY, I CAN'T SPEAK FOR MY OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS AND SIT IN WITH ANOTHER MEETING AND START TO FORENSICALLY CLARIFY SOME THINGS AS WE GET CLOSER TO MARCH, AND THEN MAYBE SOME PEOPLE, THE MAJORITY OF THE PEOPLE IN CABANA COLONY, I'M NOT GOING TO LOOK AT YOUR TAXES. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'RE GOING TO GO UP OR DOWN, BUT THERE WILL BE A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT PROBABLY THE TAXES MIGHT GO DOWN. SO I DON'T I DON'T WANT THINGS, THINGS TO BE MADE UP. IF YOU DON'T KNOW, MAYBE YOU SHOULD REALLY ASK. I DON'T KNOW IF YOUR TAXES WILL GO UP OR DOWN. SOME PEOPLE WILL BENEFIT, MAYBE SOME PEOPLE WON'T. SO, YOU KNOW, I APPRECIATE YOU GUYS. YOU GUYS ARE MY NEIGHBORS. I LIVE AND WORK HERE. SO I JUST, YOU KNOW, I WANT TO LET THE TOTALITY OF THE NUMBERS THAT PEOPLE IN ZONE ONE VOTE BECAUSE IT'S UP TO 6000 PEOPLE. AND IF YOU GUYS SPEAK FOR A PERCENTAGE OF THEM. PROBABLY WON'T COME IN, BUT WE ALSO DON'T WANT TO BE A CHECKERBOARD CITY EITHER. IT MAKES COMMON SENSE TO TRY AND SQUARE OFF OUR BOUNDARIES. AND AND I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME. AND LAST TIME YOU ALL RAN OUT BEFORE WE HAD A CHANCE TO DO COUNCIL COMMENT. SO SOME OF THE THINGS WE DIDN'T YOU DIDN'T HEAR, WE I THINK YOU DID. ANYWAY, MAYBE SOME OF THE THINGS THAT WE ADDRESSED, SOME OF YOU ALL LEFT. SO AGAIN I APPRECIATE IT. AND THAT'S WHAT I HAVE TO SAY ABOUT IT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. CARL NEXT. DANA. SORRY. YEAH, A LOT OF WHAT CARL SAID. I CONCUR WITH HIM. YOU KNOW, WE HEAR YOU. I APPRECIATE EVERYBODY WHO'S HERE. I KNOW MANY OF YOU HAVE BEEN HERE FOR THE SECOND TIME. I KNOW PEOPLE HAVE SENT EMAILS OUT AND YOU'RE PASSIONATE ABOUT IT. YOU'RE PASSIONATE ABOUT WHERE YOU WORK, WHERE YOU LIVE. AND AND I'VE BEEN HERE FOR MANY, MANY YEARS. AND, YOU KNOW, MY JOB TONIGHT IS TO VOTE, TO GIVE YOU THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE ON HOW YOU WANT TO MOVE FORWARD. AND, YOU KNOW, THE FLORIDA STATUTE IS CLEAR ON ON WHAT, WHAT THE DEFINITION OF THINGS WERE. AND I DID ASK MAX AT THE LAST MEETING, AND HE ANSWERED TONIGHT AGAIN ABOUT THE THE COMPACTNESS OF AREA ONE. AND, YOU KNOW, I DON'T KNOW IF THAT ANSWERED EVERYBODY'S QUESTION. HE ANSWERED MY QUESTION. BUT I AM, YOU KNOW, VOTING BASED ON THE FLORIDA STATUTES TO GIVE ALL OF YOU THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE AT THE ELECTION, WHETHER YOU WANT THIS OR NOT. SO THAT'S NOT MY VOTE, AND THAT'S GOING TO BE YOUR VOTE. SO AND I HEAR YOU, I'M LISTENING TO YOU. AND YOU KNOW, I DON'T KNOW, I'LL LET MY OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS COLLEAGUES TALK AS WELL. SO ALL RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. GO AHEAD BERT. YEAH. I JUST KIND OF LOOK AT THIS AS WHAT CAN WE OFFER TO THE AREAS THAT THEY DON'T HAVE NOW. AND OBVIOUSLY A LOT OF YOU DON'T WANT IT, AND I GET IT, BUT WE'RE TRYING TO REPRESENT ALL OF DISTRICT ONE ON THIS VOTE THAT'S COMING IN. SO I LOOK AT LEVELS OF SERVICE, I LOOK AT PUBLIC SAFETY, I LOOK AT THE COUNTY ISSUES THAT ARE GOING ON NOW. OUR DISTRICT ONE, COMMISSIONER MARINO MARIA MARINO, HAS ASKED FOR A LOT OF INFORMATION ON THE COUNTY BUDGET BECAUSE THEY DON'T EVEN KNOW WHERE SOME OF THEIR MONEY'S GOING FOR ROADS AND AND FACILITIES AND OTHER STUFF AND COUNTY PROJECTS BEING HALF COMPLETED IN THE SOUTHERN END OF THE COUNTY, BUT NOT MUCH ACTION ON THE NORTHERN END OF THE COUNTY WHERE WE LIVE. AND WE COULD USE ADDITIONAL PROJECTS AND SUPPORT. SO THAT WORRIES ME AS WELL. LEGAL AND STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS, ACCORDING TO EVERYBODY ON OUR SIDE, ON THE ATTORNEY SIDE HAS BEEN MET. SO WHAT WE'RE DOING IS LEGAL AND YOU GUYS COME OUT AND VOTE IN MARCH AND SUPPORT IT OR NOT, WE'RE PUTTING THE BALLOT OUT THERE. WE WOULD HOPE THAT PEOPLE WOULD SUPPORT IT. BUT IF YOU DON'T, WE UNDERSTAND IT. BUT WE'RE TRYING TO OFFER ADDITIONAL SERVICES. I KNOW WE TALKED ABOUT RECREATION AND WE LAUGH ABOUT THAT, BUT I'VE BEEN IN RECREATION IN THIS CITY FOR ALL MY LIFE, AND I SUPPORTED IT FOR 30 YEARS WITH MY KIDS. AND THOSE PROGRAMS ARE FULL. IF YOU'RE A NON RESIDENT, A LOT OF TIMES YOU'RE NOT GETTING IN AND THAT'S HARMFUL TO ME, TO OUR SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES THAT ARE NOT IN THE CITY, THAT CAN'T USE OUR FACILITIES OR GET INTO OUR SPORTS PROGRAMS, HAVE THEIR KIDS PLAY, WATCH YOUR GRANDKIDS PLAY. THOSE ARE THINGS THAT AFFECT ME THAT I WANT TO GET PEOPLE INTO OUR CITY, HAVE ACCESS TO OUR PROGRAMS, AND NOT WORRY ABOUT STUFF LIKE THAT. WE'RE A GROWING CITY. WE'RE GROWING PARKS, GROWING RECREATION, BUT WE'RE GOING TO GET FULL IN SOME OF THOSE PROGRAMS GOING FORWARD. [02:15:05] AND NON RESIDENTS ARE GETTING LEFT OUT, AND I DON'T SEE TOO MANY COUNTY PROGRAMS IN THE NORTH END SUPPORTING YOUR KIDS OR GRANDKIDS TO THE LEVEL THAT WE DO HERE IN OUR CITY. SO I'LL PUT IT ON THE BALLOT. I'LL DEFINITELY VOTE TO APPROVE IT TONIGHT, AND IT'S UP TO YOU IN MARCH. AND IF IT IF IT GOES THE WRONG WAY AND YOU DON'T WANT TO COME TO THE CITY, I TOTALLY UNDERSTAND. AND WE'LL MOVE ON AND TRY TO SERVICE THE EXISTING RESIDENTS OF OUR CITY THE BEST WAY WE CAN. IN REGARDS TO TAXES. THERE IS NO SPECIAL ASSESSMENT BEING ADDED ON TO YOUR TAXES BY THE CITY. I DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU'RE GETTING THAT STUFF FROM. OUR MILLAGE RATES BEEN LOWER THE LAST TWO YEARS I'VE BEEN ON THE BUDGET OVERSIGHT BOARD. I WATCHED THIS BUDGET PROBABLY BETTER THAN ANYBODY IN THE CITY, AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU THAT WHAT WE DO WITH OUR MONEY, WE DO IT WELL. WE PUT RESERVES IN, WE LOWER OUR MILLAGE RATE, WE LOWER OUR TAXES TO OUR RESIDENTS. AND YOU CAN TALK TO ANY OF OUR CITY RESIDENTS THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS AND THEIR TAXES ARE LOWER, NOT HIGHER. SO WE'RE TRYING TO DO EVERYTHING WE CAN WITH WHAT WE HAVE TO WORK WITH. AND I THINK WE DO IT PRETTY WELL. BUT AGAIN, THE VOTE IS UP TO YOU IN MARCH AND I WELCOME YOUR DECISION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU MERCY. THANK YOU. I DON'T HAVE A LOT LEFT TO SAY. FOR BREVITY. I'M GOING TO JUST SAY I AGREE WITH MY COLLEAGUES. THEY'VE SAID IT VERY WELL. I DO APPRECIATE EACH AND EVERY ONE OF YOU AND ALL OF YOUR COMMENTS, AND I APPRECIATE THE TIME AND EFFORT THAT IT TOOK FOR YOU GUYS TO COME HERE AND SHARE YOUR YOUR COMMENTS. YOU KNOW, HAVING THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE IS THE MOST DEMOCRATIC AND TRANSPARENT WAY TO VOICE YOUR OPINION. AND ALL WE WANT TO DO IS GIVE YOU THAT OPPORTUNITY. BUT WE WANT TO GIVE NOT JUST YOU. WE WANT TO GIVE ALL 8000 PEOPLE THAT SAME OPPORTUNITY. WHILE WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOU COMING HERE AND SHARING THAT, LIKE SOME OF YOU SAID, OTHERS DON'T HAVE THAT OPPORTUNITY, BUT THEY'LL BE ABLE TO HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE. RECENTLY, LAKE CLARKE SHORES WENT TO THE COUNTY AND ASKED THE COUNTY TO ANNEX. PORTIONS OR ENCLAVE AREAS NEAR THEM TO ANNEX IT INTO THEIR CITY, AND THE COUNTY RECOMMENDED THAT THEY DO WHAT WE ARE ACTUALLY TRYING TO DO HERE, WHICH IS DO A REFERENDUM, THE COUNTY SAID. WE'RE NOT GOING TO APPROVE JUST PUTTING THIS AREA INTO YOUR CITY. WE WANT YOU TO GO OUT TO THE PEOPLE AND ASK THEM TO THE QUESTION. SO THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO. YOU KNOW, WE RELY ON OUR EXPERTS, WE RELY ON OUR CONSULTANTS. AND THEY'VE ALL SAID THAT WE MEET THE FLORIDA STATUTE 171 STANDARDS. I BELIEVE THEY PROVED THAT TONIGHT. THEY REITERATED IT IN THEIR PRESENTATION LAST TIME AND THIS TIME. AND WE'VE WE'VE ALWAYS HAD THE GOAL TO SQUARE OUT OUR BOUNDARIES. LIKE CARL ELOQUENTLY SAID TONIGHT, IN THE LAST DECADE, I'VE PERSONALLY HAD MANY PEOPLE THAT HAVE ASKED US TO ANNEX. WE HAVE ANNEXED SOME OF THE AREAS THAT THAT HAVE COME AND ASKED US TO BE PART OF OUR CITY, BUT THERE'S A LOT OF OTHERS THAT HAVE ASKED US OVER THE LAST DECADE THAT WE'VE NOT APPROACHED, AND THIS IS THE VEHICLE IN WHICH WE CAN GO ABOUT ASKING, DOES EVERYBODY WANT TO BE IN HERE OR NOT? THIS IS THE ONLY VEHICLE THAT WE FEEL IS THE RIGHT ONE TO TO USE TO GET EVERYONE'S OPINION. SO WE ARE ASKING THIS IS OUR WAY OF ASKING AND THAT'S WHY I'M IN FAVOR OF THAT. I DO WANT TO JUST SAY, I KNOW MAX ANSWERED ALL OF MY QUESTIONS, WHICH I HAD A WHOLE A WHOLE BUNCH OF THEM. SO HE WENT THROUGH AND ANSWERED ALL OF THEM WITHOUT ME EVEN ASKING. BUT THE EASEMENT ROADS WILL REMAIN. EASEMENT ROADS. CORRECT, MAX? THE AGAIN THE STATUS OF RIGHTS AWAY. THE STATUS OF OWNERSHIP OF PROPERTY IN ITS CURRENT LEGAL CONFIGURATION DOES NOT CHANGE BY ANNEXATION. ANNEXATION MOVES A LINE ON A MAP. THAT'S IT. CORRECT. AND IT JUST CHANGES. IT COULD POTENTIALLY CHANGE JUST THE MUNICIPALITY UNINCORPORATED TO THE MUNICIPALITY. THAT'S IT. THAT IS CORRECT. THANK YOU. I APPRECIATE THE ANSWER. SO THANK YOU AND I APPRECIATE IT. THANKS FOR MY TIME. YEAH. MADAM MAYOR, I FORGOT ONE COMMENT ON HERE. THE LADY WHO LIVES ON VENICE DRIVE WITH THE FRENCHMAN'S RESERVE AROUND HER. CAN SHE GET WITH STAFF OR STAFF? GET WITH HER TO ADDRESS HER QUESTION ABOUT HER LOCATION WHERE SHE IS. I DON'T KNOW IF SHE LEFT OR NOT OR. OH, SHE'S OVER HERE. OKAY, WE'LL GET WITH YOU. THANK YOU. LET'S GO AHEAD AND BRING IT TO VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE, AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. MOVING ON TO ORDINANCE 21. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE RECORD. READ THE TITLE. YEAH. LET'S TAKE A FIVE MINUTE RECESS. IF YOU COULD BE QUIET AS YOU EXIT, WE WOULD SINCERELY APPRECIATE IT. THAT GUY WAS MISLEADING. HE'S MISLEADING. I'M JUST TELLING YOU, HE CALLED ME OUT ON A $2 MILLION NUMBER. [02:20:03] HE'S MISLEADING THAT BY SAYING. TALKED TO. ALL RIGHT, LET'S REOPEN OUR CITY COUNCIL MEETING FOR DECEMBER 6TH, 2023. WE ARE AT ORDINANCE 21, 2023. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE. ORDINANCE 21 2023 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT AREA OF UNINCORPORATED REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 20.27 ACRES, MORE OR LESS COMMONLY KNOWN AS THE ELLISON WILSON PARCELS IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171 .0413 FLORIDA STATUTES, SUCH PARCELS BEING GENERALLY LOCATED SOUTH OF PGA BOULEVARD, EAST OF THE INTRACOASTAL WATERWAY AND WEST OF ELLISON WILSON ROAD. AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN AND AS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERETO. AMENDING ARTICLE TWO OF THE CITY CHARTER TO REDEFINE THE CORPORATE LIMITS PURSUANT TO INVOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. CALLING A REFERENDUM ON THE QUESTION OF ANNEXATION FOR THE REGISTERED ELECTORS WITHIN THE PROPERTY PROPOSED FOR ANNEXATION. PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE FLORIDA GOVERNOR'S OFFICE, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE FOR THE PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTI. WE ARE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. WE ALREADY DECLARED EX PARTE UNDER ORDINANCE 20, AND I DO HAVE COMMENT CARDS ON THIS ITEM. I'LL BE CALLING OUT YOUR NAME IF YOU WOULD MIND, PLEASE. COMING TO THE PODIUM, STATE YOUR NAME, YOUR ADDRESS, AND IF YOU HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. WE HAVE TJ NICHOLS. -21. YES, SIR. SORRY. YEAH. ORDINANCE 21 2023 TJ NICHOLS. AND NEXT WE HAVE F O T I S OR L. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT IS. AND THE LAST NAME IS M E R I S S SOMETHING. MASAYOSHI F O T I S PERHAPS OR PHOTO. NO. ALL RIGHT. AND THEN WE HAVE LINDA. JANE. JANIE. NO. PATRICIA GOFF. GOFF. ALL RIGHT. COME ON UP. MS.. GOFF. IF YOU COULD COME UP TO THE PODIUM PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME YOUR ADDRESS. AND IF YOU HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. THANK YOU MA'AM. I'M PATRICIA GOUGH, 1901 WHEELER ROAD, AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. I THINK PROBABLY MY ADDRESS IS MORE EFFICIENT WITH THE THE ORDINANCE 20 BECAUSE IT WAS MISS, MISS MISS LABEL SO FAR AS MY UNDERSTANDING. SO ANYWAY. BUT WHAT I WANTED TO SAY IS THAT WAS CONCERNED WITH THE POLICE AND THE FIRE AND SO FORTH. WOULD THERE BE EXTRA? AND BECAUSE I KNOW LIVING IN THE COUNTY, I'VE BEEN THERE SINCE 1970 AND BACK 40 YEARS AGO, THERE WAS A SHOOTING IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT, AND I HAD POLICE FROM JUNO BEACH, NORTH PALM BEACH, PALM BEACH GARDENS, LAKE PARK AND THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT. I WAS VERY WELL REPRESENTED EVEN THOUGH I WAS NOT INVOLVED, JUST A NEIGHBOR IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. SO I FEEL LIKE WE HAVE ADEQUATE PROTECTION THERE. WE HAVE THE FIRE TRUCK WHENEVER WE NEED IT ON THE STREET. I'M BLESSED. I'VE NOT EVER HAD TO CALL THEM, BUT I FEEL LIKE WE AS UNINCORPORATED, WE HAVE THOSE PROTECTIONS, AND I JUST WAS WONDERING HOW WE WOULD BE BENEFITING FROM BEING ANNEXED INTO PALM BEACH GARDENS. WOULD WE HAVE A FIRE STATION IN OUR AREA CLOSER TO MY HOME THAN WHAT I HAVE NOW? WOULD WE HAVE A MAYBE A POLICE SUBSTATION? SINCE YOUR POLICE DEPARTMENT IS WAY OVER HERE ON MILITARY TRAIL? YOU KNOW, WOULD I HAVE ONE OVER THERE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE INTERCOASTAL AND THINGS LIKE THAT? THAT WAS MY QUESTION. WOULD I HAVE. AND SO THAT'S THAT WAS MAINLY WHAT I HAVE, THE TAXES. OF COURSE, EVERYBODY'S WORRIED ABOUT OUR TAXES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SPEAKING. THOSE ARE MY ONLY COMMENT CARDS. JUST CHECKING WITH OUR CITY ATTORNEY. IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE WE HAVE TO ADD BEFORE WE CLOSE THE HEARING? YES, MADAM MAYOR, AS BEFORE, AT THIS TIME, WHEN THE CITY WOULD LIKE TO ENTER INTO THE ENTIRETY OF THE STAFF REPORT, WHICH IS IN THE AGENDA PACKAGE, INTO THE RECORD, THAT INCLUDES THE ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR ORDINANCE 21, 2023. THANK YOU SO MUCH, MAX. I'M GOING TO CLOSE THE HEARING. IT'S TIMELY TO HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO GO FORWARD, PLEASE. I'LL MAKE A MOTION OF ORDINANCE 21 2223 AS PRESENTED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING. BASED ON THE FINDINGS AND FACT CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, THAT ALL THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 171.042 FLORIDA STATUTES HAVE BEEN FULLY SATISFIED AND COMPLIED WITH, AND THAT THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED FULLY COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH AT SECTION ONE. 71.043 FLORIDA STATUTES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, CARL, FOR YOUR MOTION. MAY I GET A SECOND TO APPROVE? I'LL MAKE A SECOND. THANK YOU. DANA, LET'S BRING IT BACK FOR DISCUSSION. I'LL START, I THINK I THINK BERT WAS BEATING YOU TO IT TONIGHT. BUT YOU DID. YOU DID MAKE THE MOTION. I WANTED TO ADDRESS YOU. YEAH. EVERYBODY'S JUMPING TO ANSWER. [02:25:01] OKAY, GO FOR IT. THE COP IN THE ROOM. WELL, FIRST OFF, WHATEVER HAPPENS IN YOUR COMMUNITY IS PROBABLY GOING TO BE A GREEN FIRE TRUCK BECAUSE THEY RESPOND TO ANY COUNTY POCKET. GREEN BEAN GARDENS. GREEN BEAN GARDENS. YES. AND THEY'RE ALREADY RESPONDING TO CABANA COLONY AND ALL THE OTHER AREAS THAT THAT THESE PEOPLE DON'T WANT TO BE ANNEXED. THEY'RE PROBABLY GOING TO SEE A GREEN FIRE TRUCK IN THERE IN A IN A PALM BEACH GARDENS FIREFIGHTER, YOUR VISIBILITY OF LAW ENFORCEMENT. I CAN'T SAY IT WOULD TRIPLE, BUT YOU WILL INSTANTLY SEE A CHANGE IN A BLACK AND WHITE POLICE CAR IN YOUR COMMUNITY. PROBABLY. THAT WOULD BE UP TO THE CITY MANAGER TOO TO DETERMINE HOW QUICKLY, BUT I'M SURE INSTANTLY YOU WOULD ALMOST SEE BLACK AND WHITES IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD. LIKE I SAID, I'VE BEEN AROUND HERE A LONG TIME AND. I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY SHERIFFS GO IN CABANA COLONY OR NOT, BUT WE HAVE A LOT OF COPS, SO YOU WILL. THE I CAN TELL YOU THIS, THE IN THE MOMENT THAT YOU NEEDED LAW ENFORCEMENT, WE WOULD PROBABLY BE THERE IN SECONDS AS OPPOSED TO MINUTES. SO YOU WOULD BENEFIT PUBLIC SERVICE WISE, I WOULD SAY HUGELY. SO THANK YOU FOR SAYING THAT, MA'AM. I APPRECIATE THAT. ALL RIGHT. I CALL CARL'S RIGHT. I THINK AS PART OF THE ORIGINAL ORDINANCE NUMBER 20, WE TALKED ABOUT ADDITIONAL LAW ENFORCEMENT, MAYBE 18 OR 19 OFFICERS, YOU KNOW, ADDITION TO WHAT WE HAVE NOW, KIND OF PATROLLING THAT EXPANDED AREA. SO I THINK YOU'LL SEE A PRETTY NICE PRESENCE OF POLICE FIRE ALREADY SERVICES NOW. SO I THINK THE AND THE LEVELS OF SERVICE THAT ARE OFFERED BY JUST GENERAL STAFF FROM THE CITY WILL BE GREATLY ENHANCED FROM WHAT YOU HAVE NOW. NO, NO GUESSING ON PROJECTS AS WELL. THE STAFF WILL STAY ON TOP OF IT AND THERE'S A LOT TO BE OFFERED TO THAT AREA. THANK YOU. RON, THE POLICE CHIEF AND FIRE CHIEF ARE WAITING RIGHT OUTSIDE THAT DOOR TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTIONS AND GIVE YOU INFORMATION. AND THAT'S HOW WE. IF ONLY EVERYONE WOULD JUST ASK THE QUESTIONS AND WE CAN ANSWER THEM, THAT WOULD BE THE WAY TO GO. THANK YOU. YEAH. DO YOU WANT TO GO AHEAD, MARCY? GO AHEAD. I ALSO WANT TO NOT JUST ADD TO THAT WE HAVE MUTUAL AID AS WELL, JUST LIKE EVERY OTHER CITY. THAT'S ONE OF THE THINGS THAT THAT WE HAVE. SO. SO NOT TO WORRY ABOUT THAT, BUT I THINK I WANTED TO ALSO CLARIFY WHICH I SHOULD HAVE SAID AT THE LAST ONE, BUT AT THE LAST ORDINANCE. BUT AS FAR AS THE TAXES, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I MEANT TO SAY BUT DIDN'T, AND I'M ALWAYS DEFENDING MY STAFF, BUT IN THEIR DEFENSE, I THINK THEY TALK ABOUT WHAT THE WHAT THE TAXES WOULD BE ESTIMATED. BUT WHAT THEY I THINK WERE REFERRING TO IS THE FACT THAT WE DON'T HAVE AN EXTRA GARBAGE TAX. OUR COMMUNICATION TAX IS HALF OF WHAT ANY OTHER COMMUNICATION TAX IN THE COUNTY. WE HAVE THE I WANT TO SAY IT'S THE SECOND LOWEST, BUT IT COULD BE THE LOWEST TAXABLE RATE IN THE ENTIRE COUNTY. AND I THINK THAT IT WAS A CUMULATIVE EFFECT OF TAXES, NOT JUST MILLAGE. AND I THINK IN THEIR DEFENSE, THAT'S WHAT THEY WERE REFERRING TO WHEN THEY MEANT WITH SOME OF THE RESIDENTS. AND I WANTED TO CLARIFY THAT. THANK YOU. WHAT YOU'RE SAYING IS THE TAXES ON THEIR PROPERTY VERSUS ALL THE OTHER THINGS THAT THEY WOULD SAVE MONEY ON, AND ALL THE OTHER THINGS THAT WE DON'T HAVE AND ALL THE OTHER THINGS LIKE MSTU, GARBAGE TAX, ALL OF THOSE THINGS THAT ARE ADDED WHEN YOU ARE AN UNINCORPORATED RESIDENT. YEAH, THERE'S WE DO NOT HAVE THAT. THERE'S ALWAYS A FOCUS ON THE AD VALOREM TAX, BUT THE ANCILLARY TAXES THAT THE CITY SAVES ARE WHAT YOU NEED TO FOCUS ON AS WELL, BECAUSE THAT'S THAT'S WHERE THE SAVINGS ARE COMING DOWN ON THE AREAS THAT ARE UNDER 411 OR WHATEVER THE NUMBER IS. SO BUT I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT, THEY GLOSS OVER THAT AND JUST SEE THE TOP LINE NUMBER, THAT CUMULATIVE EFFECT THAT WE NEED TO LOOK AT. IT DOES TAKE PROCESSING. AND THAT'S PROPER BUDGETING AS WELL, IS TO KNOW WHAT ALL OF THE DIFFERENT TAXES YOU PAY ON IN YOUR HOME. ON YOUR HOME IS MORE THAN JUST PROPERTY TAX. RIGHT. OKAY. LET'S I THINK WE'RE GOOD. LET'S TAKE IT TO VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU FOR COMING TONIGHT. WE'RE MOVING ON TO ORDINANCE 22. THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE ORDINANCE 22 2023, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT AREA OF UNINCORPORATED REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 31.25 ACRES, MORE OR LESS COMMONLY KNOWN AS PIRATE'S COVE, IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171 .0413 FLORIDA STATUTES, SUCH PARCELS BEING GENERALLY LOCATED SOUTH OF PGA BOULEVARD, WEST OF THE INTERCOASTAL WATERWAY AND NORTH OF CANAL ROAD. AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN AND AS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERETO. AMENDING ARTICLE TWO OF THE CITY CHARTER TO REDEFINE THE CORPORATE LIMITS PURSUANT TO INVOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. CALLING A REFERENDUM ON THE QUESTION OF ANNEXATION FOR THE REGISTERED ELECTORS WITHIN THE PROPERTY PROPOSED FOR ANNEXATION. [02:30:06] PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE FLORIDA GOVERNOR'S OFFICE, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. WE'VE ALREADY DONE OUR PART. UNDER ORDINANCE 20 IS WHEN WE DECLARED, I DO HAVE ONE COMMENT CARD ON THIS ITEM FOR ORDINANCE 22, 2023 AND THAT IS FOR SHARON PROVO. SHARON IN THE ROOM. ALL RIGHT, SO SEEING NO ONE SHOWING UP FOR THE COMMENT CARD, IF I COULD ASK OUR CITY ATTORNEY IF THERE'S ANYTHING ELSE WE HAVE TO DO BEFORE WE CLOSE THE HEARING. YES, MADAM MAYOR, AS WITH THE OTHER ORDINANCES AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WOULD LIKE TO ENTER INTO THE ENTIRETY OF THE STAFF REPORT, WHICH IS IN THE AGENDA PACKAGE AND INCLUDES THE ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR ORDINANCE 22, 2023. INTO THE RECORD. GREAT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. MAX, I'M GOING TO CLOSE THE HEARING. A MOTION OR A SECOND TO APPROVE, PLEASE. MOTION. AND SECOND TO APPROVE, PLEASE. I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 22 2023, AS PRESENTED ON THE SECOND AND FINAL READING. BASED ON THE FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, THAT THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 171 .042 FLORIDA STATUTES HAVE BEEN FULLY SATISFIED AND COMPLIED WITH, AND THAT THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED FULLY COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH AT SECTION ONE. 71.043 FLORIDA STATUTES. THANK YOU. CARL SECOND. I'LL MAKE A SECOND. THANKS, DANA. ALL RIGHT. ANY DISCUSSION FOR ORDINANCE 22 2023? I HOPE NOT. ALL RIGHT. MOVING. LET'S TAKE IT TO VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. LET'S MOVE ON TO ORDINANCE 2322. SORRY. ORDINANCE 23, 2023. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE. ORDINANCE 23 2023, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT AREA OF UNINCORPORATED REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 32.92 ACRES, MORE OR LESS COMMONLY KNOWN AS MONET ACRES, IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171 .0413 FLORIDA STATUTES, SUCH PARCELS BEING GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF PROSPERITY FARMS ROAD AND RCA BOULEVARD, IS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN AND AS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERE, TO AMENDING ARTICLE TWO OF THE CITY CHARTER TO REDEFINE THE CORPORATE LIMITS PURSUANT TO INVOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. CALLING A REFERENDUM ON THE QUESTION OF ANNEXATION FOR THE REGISTERED ELECTORS WITHIN THE PROPERTY PROPOSED FOR ANNEXATION. PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE FLORIDA GOVERNOR'S OFFICE, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. WE'VE DONE EX PARTE DECLARE UNDER ORDINANCE 20. I DO NOT HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS ON THIS ITEM. MAX, IS THERE ANYTHING WE HAVE TO DO BEFORE WE CLOSE THE HEARING? YES, MADAM MAYOR, AS IN THE OTHER ORDINANCES AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WOULD LIKE TO ENTER INTO THE INTO THE ENTIRETY OF THE STAFF REPORT, WHICH IS IN THE AGENDA PACKAGE AND INCLUDES THE ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY IN FOR ORDINANCE 23, 2023. INTO THE RECORD. THANK YOU SO MUCH. LET'S GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 23 2023? MAYOR, I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 23 2023 AS PRESENTED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING. BASED ON THE FINDINGS AND FACT AND CONCLUSION OF LAW, THAT ALL REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 171.042 FLORIDA STATUTES HAVE BEEN FULLY SATISFIED AND COMPLIED WITH, AND THAT THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED FULLY COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH AT SECTION 171.043 FLORIDA STATUTES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, VICE MAYOR. DO I HAVE A SECOND? I'LL MAKE A SECOND. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. DANIEL. ANY DISCUSSION? LET'S BRING IT TO VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. LET'S MOVE ALONG TO ORDINANCE 24, 2023. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE ORDINANCE 24 2023 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL, THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ANNEXING A CONTIGUOUS AND COMPACT AREA OF UNINCORPORATED REAL PROPERTY COMPRISING A TOTAL OF 38.71 ACRES, MORE OR LESS COMMONLY KNOWN AS MONET GARDENS, IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171 .0413 FLORIDA STATUTES, SUCH PARCELS BEING GENERALLY LOCATED NORTH OF RCA BOULEVARD, SOUTH OF FAIRCHILD AVENUE, AND EAST OF FAIRCHILD GARDENS AVENUE AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, AND IS DEPICTED ON THE MAP ATTACHED HERE TO AMENDING ARTICLE TWO OF THE CITY CHARTER TO REDEFINE THE CORPORATE LIMITS PURSUANT TO THE INVOLUNTARY ANNEXATION. CALLING A REFERENDUM ON THE QUESTION OF ANNEXATION FOR THE REGISTERED ELECTORS WITHIN THE PROPERTY PROPOSED FOR ANNEXATION. PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE, THE FLORIDA GOVERNOR'S OFFICE, AND PALM BEACH COUNTY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I APPRECIATE THAT WE'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. WE HAVE DECLARED EX PARTE UNDER ORDINANCE 20. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS ON THIS ITEM. LET'S CHECK WITH OUR CITY ATTORNEY. IS THERE ANYTHING WE NEED TO DO BEFORE WE CLOSE THIS HEARING? YES, MADAM MAYOR, AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WOULD LIKE TO ENTER THE ENTIRETY OF THE STAFF REPORT, WHICH IS IN THE AGENDA PACKAGE. [02:35:02] IT INCLUDES THE ANNEXATION FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR ORDINANCE 24, 2023. INTO THE RECORD. THANK YOU. MAX, LET'S GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 24 2023? MAYOR, I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 24 2023 AS PRESENTED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING. BASED ON THE FINDINGS AND THE FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW THAT ALL REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 171.042 FLORIDA STATUTES HAVE BEEN FULLY SATISFIED AND COMPLIED WITH, AND THAT THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA TO BE ANNEXED FULLY COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH AT SECTION 1710.043 FLORIDA STATUTES. THANK YOU. CARL. MAY I GET A SECOND? I'LL MAKE A SECOND. ALL RIGHT. GREAT. AND LET'S SEE ANY I DON'T HEAR ANY DISCUSSION. SO ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. LET'S MOVE ALONG TO ORDINANCE 25 2023. IF THE CLERK. OH, SORRY, I APOLOGIZE. WE'VE MOVED ON TO NON QUASI JUDICIAL. SO ORDINANCE 25 2023 AN ORDINANCE 26 2023 WILL BE A COMBINED PRESENTATION. THE CITY CLERK WILL READ THE TITLES SEPARATELY AND EACH ORDINANCE WILL BE VOTED ON SEPARATELY SINCE ORDINANCE 26. MADAM MAYOR, I'M SORRY, WE'RE ON TO ORDINANCE FIVE FIVE. I LOST MY MIND. ONE MOMENT. YEAH. THERE'S A PAGE OUT OF ORDER FOR YOU. MISSING. TAKE OUT ALL THE BAD STUFF. IT'S MISSING OUT OF HER BACK. IT'S NOT MISSING ON THE AGENDA. THANK YOU, THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. I LOVE MY COUNCIL TEAM. EVERYONE'S GOT ME COVERED HERE. ALL RIGHT, LET'S MOVE ALONG TO ORDINANCE FIVE 2023 AT SECOND READING AT THE CLERK CAN PLEASE READ THE TITLE. [VIII.g. ORDINANCE 5, 2023 – (2ND READING AND ADOPTION) CITY-INITIATED LAND DEVELOPMENT TEXT AMENDMENT. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 78 - LAND DEVELOPMENT AT ARTICLE III. - DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCEDURES BY REPEALING DIVISION 4. - CITYWIDE IMPACT FEES AND MOBILITY FEES, AND READOPTING SAME, AS REVISED, IN ORDER TO REVISE THE CITY’S IMPACT FEE SCHEDULE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MOST RECENT LOCALIZED DATA FOR PARKS AND RECREATION, FIRE PROTECTION/EMS, POLICE PROTECTION, AND PUBLIC FACILITIES; PROVIDING FOR AND DECLARING THE EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES THAT NECESSITATE THE ADOPTION OF THE UPDATED IMPACT FEES AT THE FULLY CALCULATED RATE AS OF THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS ORDINANCE; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] ORDINANCE FIVE 2023. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 78, LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE. ARTICLE THREE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCEDURES BY REPEALING DIVISION FOUR CITYWIDE IMPACT FEES AND MOBILITY FEES AND RE ADOPTING SAME AS REVISED IN ORDER TO REVISE THE CITY'S IMPACT FEE SCHEDULE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MOST RECENT LOCALIZED DATA FOR PARKS AND RECREATION, FIRE PROTECTION, MS POLICE PROTECTION, AND PUBLIC FACILITIES PROVIDING FOR AND DECLARING THE EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES THAT NECESSITATE THE ADOPTION OF THE UPDATED IMPACT FEES TO FULLY CALCULATED RATE AS OF THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS ORDINANCE, PROVIDING A CONFLICT CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. HAS ANYTHING CHANGED SINCE FIRST READING? MADAM MAYOR, THERE HAVE BEEN NO CHANGES SINCE FIRST READING. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. DO COUNCIL DO WE NEED ANOTHER PRESENTATION REGARDING ORDINANCE FIVE? NOPE. NO. ALL RIGHT. IF I MAY, I'D JUST LIKE TO STATE A FEW POINTS JUST TO HAVE THEM ON THE RECORD. YES, PLEASE. SO JUST TO RECAP THIS, THIS ORDINANCE, ORDINANCE FIVE, IT UPDATED THE PARK, POLICE, FIRE AND PUBLIC BUILDINGS IMPACT FEES ON THE MOST RECENT LOCALIZED DATA. OUR CONSULTANT HAS PREPARED A TECHNICAL REPORT THAT DEMONSTRATED NEED AS OF OCTOBER 20TH, 2023. WE HELD TWO PUBLIC WORKSHOPS ON EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES TO SATISFY THOSE REQUIREMENTS, AND STAFF AND OUR CONSULTANT RECOMMEND EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES. AND UPON ADOPTION, THE FEES WILL BECOME EFFECTIVE APRIL 1ST AND WE'RE AVAILABLE TO MAKE A PRESENTATION OR ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. AND WE DO APPRECIATE THE CONSULTANT SHOWING UP AGAIN THIS EVENING. THANK YOU, SIR, FOR BEING HERE AFTER A LITTLE WHILE OF A WAIT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. SO THAT CLARIFIES EVERYTHING AGAIN. ANYONE HAVE A QUESTIONS REQUIRE ANY PART OF THE PRESENTATION. OR WE DO HAVE OUR CONSULTANT HERE IF YOU WANT TO ASK ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE IMPACT FEES. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHTY. FAIR ENOUGH. LET'S GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE FIVE 2023, PLEASE, MADAM MAYOR, I'LL MOVE. ORDINANCE FIVE 2023, SECOND READING AND ADOPTION. I'LL SECOND. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. SEEING NO FURTHER DISCUSSION, LET'S BRING IT TO OUR VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES FIVE ZERO. THANK YOU SO MUCH AGAIN FOR COMING. WE REALLY APPRECIATE IT. OKAY. NOW WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO ORDINANCE 25 AND ORDINANCE 26, WHICH WILL BE A COMBINED PRESENTATION. [Items VIII.h & VIII.i.] THE CITY CLERK WILL READ THE TITLES SEPARATELY, AND EACH ORDINANCE WILL BE VOTED ON SEPARATELY SINCE ORDINANCE 2623. 2023 IS QUASI JUDICIAL. WE WILL DECLARE EX PARTE COMMUNICATION. AT THIS TIME. THE CLERK WILL READ THE TITLES SEPARATELY FOR EACH, AND THERE WILL BE A VOTE FOR EACH ORDINANCE ON SECOND READING. SO LET'S GO AHEAD AND DO EX PARTE. DO WE HAVE ANY EX PARTE FOR ORDINANCE 25? NONE FOR MERCY. BURT. NONE. NO. DANA. CARL. OKAY. SAME FOR MYSELF. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE ORDINANCE 25 2023 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ADOPTING A SMALL SCALE AMENDMENT TO THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FUTURE LAND USE MAP IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MANDATE SET FORTH IN CHAPTER 163 FLORIDA STATUTES PURSUANT TO APPLICATION NUMBER CPS 20 308-0001. [02:40:03] IN ORDER TO CHANGE THE LAND USE DESIGNATION OF 29.59 ACRES, MORE OR LESS KNOWN AS THE SHOPPES AT INDIAN TRAILS FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY. COMMERCIAL LOW WITH UNDERLYING RURAL RESIDENTIAL. ONE UNIT PER FIVE ACRES RR FIVE TO PALM BEACH GARDENS COMMERCIAL C THE SUBJECT PROPERTY BEING LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD AND COCONUT BOULEVARD, PROVIDING FOR COMPLIANCE WITH ALL REQUIREMENTS OF CHAPTER 163 FLORIDA STATUTES PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY, D.O., PROVIDING THAT THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP AT THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS BE AMENDED ACCORDINGLY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. HAS ANYTHING CHANGED SINCE FIRST READING? NO, MADAM MAYOR, THERE'S NO CHANGES SINCE FIRST READING. OKAY. WONDERFUL. THANK YOU SO MUCH. COUNCIL. WOULD YOU GUYS LIKE A PRESENTATION FOR ORDINANCE 25 OR 26 AT SECOND READING? NO. THANK YOU, THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. WE DO HAVE OUR PLANNER HERE, BUT THAT'S FINE. WE'RE ALL SET TO GO. SO I DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS ON THIS. AND SO I WILL CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 25? MADAM MAYOR, I'LL MOVE ORDINANCE 25 2023 ON SECOND READING AND ADOPTION. THANK YOU SIR. THANK YOU. MARCIE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE, AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. LET'S GO ON TO ORDINANCE 26. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE ORDINANCE 26 2023, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, ASSIGNING A CITY ZONING DESIGNATION TO CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, SUCH PROPERTY BEING COMPRISED OF 29.59 ACRES IN SIZE, MORE OR LESS KNOWN AS THE SHOPPES OF INDIAN TRAILS, AND LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD AND COCONUT BOULEVARD, PROVIDING THAT THESE PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY, WHICH ARE MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, SHALL BE REZONED FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY. MULTIPLE USE PLAN DEVELOPMENT MBPD TO PALM BEACH GARDENS PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT PUD OVERLAY WITH AN UNDERLYING ZONING DESIGNATION OF GENERAL COMMERCIAL CG ONE, PROVIDING THAT THE ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS BE AMENDED ACCORDINGLY, PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTI. I'M GOING TO OPEN THE HEARING. WE'VE DONE EX PARTE FOR ORDINANCE 25 REGARDING ORDINANCE 26 2023. WE'VE ALREADY HAD OUR PRESENTATION. IT WAS COMBINED, SO WE DIDN'T WANT ONE FOR 25. I'M ASSUMING NOT ONE FOR 26. IS THAT OKAY? ALL RIGHT. WE HAVE NO COMMENT CARDS, SO I'LL CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I PLEASE GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 26 2023? MADAM MAYOR, I'LL MOVE ORDINANCE 26 2023 FOR SECOND READING AND ADOPTION. I'LL SECOND. ALL RIGHT. GREAT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. ALL IN FAVOR? ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES FIVE ZERO. THANK YOU GUYS SO MUCH. MOVING ON TO ORDINANCE 27. ORDINANCE 27 2023, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 78 LAND DEVELOPMENT AT SECTION 78 TO 21 [VIII.j. ORDINANCE 27, 2023 – (2ND READING AND ADOPTION) A LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS (LDR) TEXT AMENDMENT. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 78 - LAND DEVELOPMENT AT SECTION 78-221. - PGA BOULEVARD CORRIDOR OVERLAY. BY REPEALING SUBSECTION (d)(1)b.1.(iii) AND READOPTING SAME, AS REVISED, TO PERMIT “HEALTH, PHYSICAL FITNESS, WEIGHT REDUCTION, AND SPA” AS A MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE IN THE PGA BOULEVARD CORRIDOR OVERLAY; PROVIDING EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 78 - LAND DEVELOPMENT SHALL REMAIN IN FULL FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] PGA BOULEVARD CORRIDOR OVERLAY BY REPEALING SUBSECTION D ONE, B13 AND RE ADAPTING SAME AS REVISED TO PERMIT HEALTH, PHYSICAL FITNESS, WEIGHT REDUCTION, AND SPAS AS A MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE IN THE PGA BOULEVARD CORRIDOR OVERLAY, PROVIDING EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 78 LAND DEVELOPMENT SHALL REMAIN IN FULL FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED, PROVIDING A CONFLICT CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'M GOING TO OPEN THE HEARING. THIS NEXT ITEM, RESOLUTION 63 2023 IS ACTUALLY A COMPANION ITEM TO ORDINANCE 27 2023. SO IS ALSO QUASI JUDICIAL. SO LET'S GO AHEAD AND DECLARE EX PARTE. NOW I'LL START OVER HERE MARCIE 27 AND 63. DO YOU HAVE ANY EX PARTE DONE? ALL RIGHT DANA, NO CARL. ALL RIGHT. I DO NOT HAVE ANY EX PARTE FOR RESOLUTION 63 2023 OR ORDINANCE 27 2023. HAS ANYTHING CHANGED SINCE FIRST READING? NO, MA'AM. ALL RIGHT. DO WE NEED ANY FURTHER PRESENTATION FROM CUTLER AND HEARING FROM NICOLE? THANK YOU. FROM OUR PLANNER, OLIVIA. NO OFFENSE. ALL RIGHT. GREAT. WE DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS OR ANYONE WISHING TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM. LET'S GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I PLEASE GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 27 2023? I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 27 2023 SECOND READING AND ADOPTION. THANK YOU. DANA. I'LL SECOND. ALL RIGHT. MARCY, ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. MOVING ON TO COMPANION RESOLUTION 60 THREE, 2023. [VIII.k. *RESOLUTION 63, 2023 – REQUEST FOR A MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE IN LEGACY PLACE. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING A MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW A HEALTH, PHYSICAL FITNESS, WEIGHT REDUCTION, AND SPA USE WITHIN THE LEGACY PLACE PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT (PCD), LOCATED SOUTHWEST OF THE INTERSECTION OF PGA BOULEVARD AND FAIRCHILD GARDENS AVENUE, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN; PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE RESOLUTION 63 2023, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING A MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW A HEALTH, PHYSICAL FITNESS, WEIGHT REDUCTION AND SPA USE WITHIN THE LEGACY PLACE PLAN. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PCD, LOCATED SOUTHWEST OF THE INTERSECTION OF PGA BOULEVARD AND FAIRCHILD GARDENS AVENUE, IS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. [02:45:02] I'M SORRY. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTY. WE'RE GOING AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. WE'VE ALREADY DONE EX PARTE FOR RESOLUTION 63 WITH OUR PREVIOUS ORDINANCE 27. AND WE AGAIN HAVE OUR PETITIONER, NICOLE PLUNKETT, AS WELL AS OUR PLANNER. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS COMPANION RESOLUTION? NO. ALL RIGHT. LET'S GO AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I PLEASE GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE? I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 63 2023. I'LL SECOND. ALL RIGHT. WONDERFUL. SO, ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE LOOK FORWARD TO THIS NEW ADDITION TO OUR CITY. ALL RIGHT. MOVING ALONG TO ORDINANCE 29, 2023. IF THE CLERK COULD PLEASE READ THE TITLE ORDINANCE 29 2023 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 42 OFFENSES AT [VIII.l. ORDINANCE 29, 2023 – (2ND READING AND ADOPTION) PROHIBITION OF VIDEO AND SOUND RECORDING IN PUBLIC, NONPUBLIC, AND LIMITED PUBLIC FORUMS. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 42 - OFFENSES AT ARTICLE I. - GENERAL OFFENSES BY ADOPTING NEW SECTION 42-4. ENTITLED “CONTROL OF ACCESS TO CITY-OWNED, CONTROLLED, AND LEASED PROPERTY” IN ORDER TO IMPLEMENT REGULATIONS RELATED TO PUBLIC ACCESS TO SUCH PROPERTIES, PERMIT AND PROHIBIT CONDUCT WITHIN SAME, AND AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER TO MANAGE SUCH PROPERTIES; PROVIDING THAT EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 42 - OFFENSES SHALL REMAIN IN FULL FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] ARTICLE ONE GENERAL OFFENSES BY ADOPTING NEW SECTION 40 2-4 ENTITLED CONTROL OF ACCESS TO CITY OWNED, CONTROLLED AND LEASED PROPERTY IN ORDER TO IMPLEMENT REGULATIONS RELATED TO PUBLIC ACCESS TO SUCH PROPERTIES. PERMIT AND PROHIBIT CONDUCT WITHIN SAME, AND AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER TO MANAGE SUCH PROPERTIES, PROVIDING THAT EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 42 OFFENSES SHALL REMAIN IN FULL FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED, PROVIDING A CONFLICT CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTI. I'M GOING TO OPEN THE HEARING. HAS ANYTHING CHANGED SINCE FIRST READING, MAX? NO, MA'AM. NOTHING HAS CHANGED. OKAY, GREAT. WE DON'T HAVE ANYONE WISHING TO SPEAK ON IT. WE DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS. IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE WE HAVE ANYTHING ELSE GOING ON, SO I'LL CLOSE THE HEARING. MAY I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 29 2023? I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE ORDINANCE 29 2023. SECOND READING AND ADOPTION. SECOND, SECOND. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. MARCY, I DON'T SEE ANY DISCUSSION. SO LET'S GO AHEAD AND BRING IT TO VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES FIVE ZERO. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MAX. WE'VE GOT RESOLUTION 60 FIVE, 2023, WHICH IS THE CLERK IS GOING TO READ THE TITLE RESOLUTION 60 FIVE, 2023. [VIII.m. *RESOLUTION 65, 2023 – REQUEST FOR A SITE PLAN AND MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL OF THE AVENIR PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT (PCD). A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING A SITE PLAN AND MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE FOR A 29- BED NEIGHBORHOOD HOSPITAL AND TWO (2) MEDICAL OFFICE BUILDINGS TOTALING 72,750 SQUARE FEET ON A 13.09-ACRE PARCEL WITHIN THE WORKPLACE DISTRICT (PARCEL D) OF THE AVENIR PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT (PCD), LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD, APPROXIMATELY 0.35 MILES WEST OF COCONUT BOULEVARD, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN; PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL; PROVIDING WAIVERS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING A SITE PLAN AND MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE FOR A 29 BED NEIGHBORHOOD HOSPITAL AND TWO MEDICAL OFFICE BUILDINGS TOTALING 72,750FT² ON A 13.09 ACRE PARCEL WITHIN THE WORKPLACE DISTRICT. PARCEL D OF THE AVENIR PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PCD, LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD, APPROXIMATELY 0.35 MILES WEST OF COCONUT BOULEVARD, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, PROVIDING WAIVERS, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. THANK YOU SO MUCH, PATTY. LET'S OPEN THIS HEARING. WE'RE GOING TO GO THROUGH AND DECLARE EX PARTE MARCIE. YES, I'D LIKE TO. EX PARTE ROSA SCHECTER. OKAY. AND, BURT. NONE FOR ME. NONE FOR ME. CARL. I HAVE NONE EITHER. SO LET'S GO AHEAD AND HAVE A GREAT PRESENTATION. WE HAVE GEORGE MISSIMER FROM CUTLER AND HEARING. YES. GOOD EVENING FOR THE RECORD, GEORGE MISSIMER WITH CUTLER AND HEARING HERE TONIGHT ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT AND I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. WE'RE FINALLY HERE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE, BY THE WAY. AND IT HAS BEEN THIS HAS BEEN A LONG PROCESS, SO THANK YOU. ABSOLUTELY. AND IT'S ALWAYS A PLEASURE TO SEE THIS COUNCIL REPRESENT THE CITY SO WELL. SO THANK YOU. SO. WE'RE HERE TONIGHT AGAIN TO TALK ABOUT OUR MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE AND SITE PLAN FOR THE HEALTH PARK AT AVENIR. SO IT'S OUR FIRST MAJOR EMPLOYER OUT AT AVENIR IN THE ECONOMIC AND WORKPLACE DISTRICT. SO WE'RE VERY EXCITED ABOUT IT. WE'VE HAD A WONDERFUL TEAM ON THE PROJECT. WORKING CLOSELY WITH STAFF AND STAFF HAS BEEN AMAZING THROUGH THE PROCESS, VERY COLLABORATIVE, WORKING TOGETHER TO FIND THE BEST SOLUTIONS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT. BRIEFLY GOING OVER OUR TEAM AGAIN, THE OWNER, AVENIR DEVELOPMENT LLC, ROSA, DANNY AND MANNY HAVE BEEN A JOY TO WORK WITH. AS ALWAYS, OUR APPLICANT SEEING ACCOMPANIES AND THE DEVELOPER NATIONAL DEVELOPER, WORKING VERY CLOSELY WITH ADVANCED MEDICAL FACILITIES. KOTLIN HEARING HAS BEEN THE AGENT, LAND PLANNER AND LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT. OUR PROJECT ARCHITECT, DAVID STOKES COLLABORATIVE LED BY GREG PRUITT, OUR CIVIL ENGINEER MARTHA CARTER, AND OUR TRAFFIC CONSULTANT SUSAN O'ROURKE. TONIGHT, RESOLUTION 65, AGAIN APPROVING OUR SITE PLAN AND MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE FOR THE HOSPITAL. EVERYONE'S VERY FAMILIAR WITH THE LOCATION AT AVENIR. WE ARE WITHIN THE WORKPLACE DISTRICT PARCEL D, AND WE ARE DIRECTLY FRONTING NORTH LAKE BOULEVARD. SO AGAIN, A CLOSE UP VIEW OF THE AVENIR MASTER PLAN, AGAIN BEING THE FIRST REALLY MAJOR PROFESSIONAL EMPLOYER WITHIN AVENIR. LOOKING AT ACCESS AGAIN, JUST IN GENERAL. OVERVIEW OF THE SITE LOCATION. WE ARE LOCATED FRONTING NORTH LAKE BOULEVARD. OUR PRIMARY ACCESS POINTS ARE VIA DRIVEWAY THREE, WHICH CONNECT INTERNALLY TO AVANIR TO SEVERAL LOCATIONS, PROVIDING FOR EFFICIENT AND [02:50:09] CONVENIENT ACCESS BOTH FOR RESIDENTS OUTSIDE OF AVANIR AS WELL AS INTERIOR TO THE SITE. QUICKLY GOING OVER THE MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE THE HOSPITAL. WE ARE SORRY. WE ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE CRITERIA AS OUTLINED WITHIN THE CODE. THE HOSPITAL WILL HAVE A 24 HOUR EMERGENCY ROOM, 20 INPATIENT BEDS, TWO OPERATING ROOMS, DIAGNOSIS, DIAGNOSTIC LABORATORY AND IMAGING SERVICES. SO WHILE IT IS DEFINITELY MORE THAN A STANDARD ED, IT IS NOT QUITE AS LARGE AS A STANDARD HOSPITAL, SO THAT'S WHY WE'VE BEEN CALLING IT A NEIGHBORHOOD HOSPITAL. AGAIN TALKING ABOUT THE CONVENIENCE OF MEDICAL SERVICES AS BEING ESSENTIAL FOR A LOT OF THESE WESTERN COMMUNITIES. WHEN YOU START LOOKING AT THE LOCATIONS FOR EMERGENCY ROOMS AND HOSPITALS, THEY'RE PRIMARILY LOCATED OUT ALONG I 95. SO ACCESS TO THOSE. IF YOU'RE IN AN EMERGENT SITUATION, YOU'VE GOT TO DRIVE A PRETTY FAR DISTANCE DOWN NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD TO ACCESS THAT OR SOUTH TOWARDS ROYAL PALM BEACH. AND SO THIS BEING A REALLY CRITICAL LOCATION THAT WE FEEL IS A POSITIVE FOR THE ENTIRE AREA. LOOKING AT ACCESS AGAIN, WORKING WITH STAFF AND THE FIRE DEPARTMENT, POLICE DEPARTMENT, MAKING SURE THAT OUR ACCESS FOR OUR EMERGENCY VEHICLES IS CONVENIENT WITH AS FEW CONFLICT POINTS AS POSSIBLE. SO THE PRIMARY ACCESS POINT FOR AN EMERGENCY VEHICLE APPROACHING THE SITE WOULD BE THROUGH THE NORTHERNMOST ENTRANCE, AND THEY HAVE A STRAIGHT SHOT TOWARDS THE NORTH OF THE BUILDING, WHICH IS WHERE THE AMBULANCE ENTRY WOULD BE. LOOKING AT OUR TURNING MOVEMENTS FOR THE SITE, OUR FULL ACCESS ENTRANCE IS THAT NORTHERN MOST ENTRANCE, THE CENTER DRIVE AISLE IS A RIGHT IN AND A RIGHT OUT FOR PROXIMITY REASONS TOWARDS NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD. LOOKING AT THE BLOCK STYLE OF DEVELOPMENT IS OUTLINED WITHIN THE AVENIR DESIGN GUIDELINES. THE CIRCULATION AROUND THE SITE IS VERY CLEAR. IT'S CONVENIENT. IT'S EFFICIENT TO PROVIDE THE BEST ACCESS FOR PEOPLE APPROACHING THE SITE. IF IT IS AN EMERGENCY. IF IT'S NOT, WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE CAN NAVIGATE IT WITHOUT GETTING INTO TROUBLE OR HAVING AN INCIDENT. WE'VE DESIGNED AGAIN, THAT BLOCK STYLE OF DEVELOPMENT WITH A CENTER CORRIDOR LINED WITH LANDSCAPING FOR THAT TERMINATED VISTA AT THE HOSPITAL. LOOKING AT SOME OF THE PARKING, THE WAY WE'VE INTENTIONALLY DESIGNED IT. AGAIN, THE NORTHERN ENTRANCE TO THE BUILDING BEING THE EMERGENCY ENTRANCE FOR AMBULANCES. WE HAVE DEDICATED EMERGENCY RESPONDER PARKING. OFTENTIMES FROM LEAVING A SCENE OF A CAR ACCIDENT, AN AMBULANCE WOULD TRAVEL WITH A POLICE CAR AS WELL. SO CONVENIENT ACCESS THERE. WE ENVISION THE EMPLOYEE PARKING BEING AROUND THE REAR OF THE FACILITY, CONVENIENT FOR THEM TO ACCESS THE BUILDING AS WELL, KEEPING THEM A LITTLE BIT SEPARATE FROM THE PUBLIC PARKING. AND WE HAVE INCORPORATED SEVERAL COVERED PARKING AREAS CONSISTENT WITH CITY CODE. THOSE COVERED PARKING AREAS. THIS IS A DETAIL OF WHAT THAT STRUCTURE LOOKS LIKE, VERY CONSISTENT WITH THE ARCHITECTURE BEING PROPOSED, WHICH YOU'LL SEE LATER IN THE PRESENTATION. THE PEDESTRIAN CIRCULATION. SO CONNECTIVITIES IS ALWAYS A FOCUS. AND AGAIN, THAT STANDARD BLOCK STYLE DEVELOPMENT, LOTS OF CONNECTIVITY WITHIN THE PARKING LOT. DEDICATED PEDESTRIAN PATHS TO KEEP THEM OUT OF THE CIRCULATION AND VEHICLES AND CONNECTIONS OUT TO NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD, AS WELL AS FURTHER INTERIOR ALONG DRIVEWAY THREE. SOMETHING ELSE THAT WE'VE INCORPORATED AS PART OF THAT PEDESTRIAN CIRCULATION IS WE'VE AMENITIZED THAT STORMWATER LAKE, SOMETHING THAT WE'VE SEEN A LOT MORE COMMON WITH MEDICAL FACILITIES AND PROVIDING THAT ADDITIONAL AMENITY, A WALKING TRAIL AROUND THAT LAKE. SO IF WE'RE GOING TO HAVE IT, WE MIGHT AS WELL MAKE IT PRETTY, MAKE IT ACCESSIBLE FOR ALL THOSE THAT COME TO THE SITE. FURTHER INTO PEDESTRIAN AMENITIES, WE HAVE INCORPORATED SEVERAL PEDESTRIAN PLAZAS OUT ALONG NORTH LAKE BOULEVARD WITHIN THE 90 FOOT PARKWAY BUFFER, WITH APPROPRIATE LANDSCAPING AND CANOPY TREES TO PROVIDE SHADE COVER AS A POINT OF REFUGE. WE HAVE INCORPORATED SMALLER PLAZAS INTERIOR TO THE DEVELOPMENT, AS WELL AS THE TRAIL AROUND THE LAKE, AND THEN AS WELL ALONG THAT MAIN DRIVE, SEVERAL COVERED BENCHES AND TRELLISES, AGAIN PROVIDING ADDITIONAL SHADE WITHIN THAT PARKING LOT. AND HERE ARE JUST A FEW DETAILS SHOWING THOSE COVERED BENCHES AND THAT TRELLIS STRUCTURE. [02:55:01] BRIEF. LOOKING AT THE SITE DATA. THE TOTAL PROPERTY IS ABOUT 13 ACRES. THE INITIAL PHASE ONE PROJECT AREA IS RIGHT AROUND TEN ACRES. THE BALANCE WOULD BE A FUTURE DEVELOPMENT THAT WOULD HAVE TO COME BACK FOR ANOTHER SITE PLAN APPROVAL, AND THAT WOULD BE MORE MEDICAL OFFICE. AND THEN THE BUILDING DATA AGAIN, ABOUT 70,000FT² OF MEDICAL OFFICE WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD HOSPITAL. THE BUILDING HEIGHT WE ARE UNDER THE MAXIMUM, SO OUR MAXIMUM HEIGHT IS 65FT OR 55FT, WHICH IS THE MEDICAL OFFICE BUILDING. OUR THREE STORY LOOKING AT THE ARCHITECTURE. WE'VE LOVED WORKING WITH DAVID STOKES, THEIR VISION FOR THIS CAMPUS, VERY, VERY MODERN IN SOME OF THE ELEMENTS, REALLY BRINGING THAT STATE OF THE ART MEDICAL FACILITY TO THE OUTSIDE OF THE BUILDING. AND AGAIN, THIS THIS RENDERING DOES ACCURATELY DEPICT THE LANDSCAPING. AND SO INCORPORATING THAT LANDSCAPE DESIGN TO WHERE IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE ARCHITECTURE DOESN'T HIDE IT, IT ENHANCES IT. AND THEY WORK TOGETHER. HERE'S JUST A QUICK ELEVATION. I WOULD LIKE TO NOTE THE SIGNAGE ON THE BUILDING WE HAVE. WE ARE ASKING SEVERAL WAIVERS, WHICH I'LL GO OVER AT THE END, BUT SIGNAGE FOR THESE MEDICAL FACILITIES IS KEY. WE WANT TO MAKE SURE PEOPLE CAN NAVIGATE TO THE SITE, AND ONCE THEY'RE IN, THEY CAN SEE THE BUILDINGS AND UNDERSTAND WHERE THEY NEED TO GO. THIS IS OUR THREE STORY MEDICAL OFFICE BUILDING. THIS IS AT THE CORNER OF NORTH LAKE AND DRIVEWAY THREE. AND SO YOU CAN SEE AGAIN THE FRONT ENTRANCE CANOPY CONSISTENT WITH THAT COVERED PARKING AREA AS WELL, THE LANDSCAPING, WORKING WITH THE ARCHITECTURE OF THE BUILDING. WHILE THE MEDICAL OFFICE DOES FUNCTION A LITTLE DIFFERENTLY THAN THE HOSPITALS, SO THERE ARE SLIGHT DIFFERENCES IN THE DESIGN, THE COLOR, THE MATERIAL PALLET WORKS TOGETHER TO CREATE THAT UNITY AND DESIGN. AND THEN OUR TWO STORY OFFICE BUILDING AGAIN, CONSISTENT COLORS AND MATERIALS TO REALLY FIT IN WITH THE OVERALL DEVELOPMENT. NOW. LANDSCAPING IS ALWAYS SOMETHING THAT WE'D LOVE TO TALK ABOUT. AGAIN, BEING VERY INTENTIONAL WITH THE PLACEMENT THE SPECIES SELECTED, PRIMARILY NATIVES CAPITALIZING ON THEIR REDUCED NEEDS FOR IRRIGATION, EVEN LOOKING INTO THE PARKING ISLANDS, MAKING SURE THAT THE HEDGES AND SHRUBS THAT ARE WITHIN THOSE PARKING ISLANDS ARE NOT HARD. THEY'RE THEY'RE STURDY TO WHERE IF THEY GET DAMAGED, YOU KNOW, THEY BOUNCE BACK. BUT WE'VE SELECTED HORIZONTAL COCOPLUM, WHICH IS A NATIVE VARIETY OF COCOPLUM THAT WAS DEVELOPED IN HOBE SOUND, OFTEN REFERRED TO AS HOBE SOUND COCOPLUM. IT'S A SOFTER VARIETY THAT SPREADS OUT, DOESN'T GROW UP, SO IT'S EASY TO MAINTAIN AT A LOWER LEVEL. AND IT'S FULL. AND IT'S A REALLY WONDERFUL SELECTION FOR THOSE ISLANDS, AS WELL AS A NUMBER OF OTHER NATIVE SPECIES. AGAIN, JUST TOUCHING ON THOSE PLAZA AREAS THAT WE INCORPORATED INTO THE NORTH LAKE BUFFER. INCORPORATING ADDITIONAL CANOPY TREES AROUND THOSE TO PROVIDE SHADE. WE WORK CLOSELY WITH URBAN DESIGN STUDIOS FOR THE DESIGN OF THAT BUFFER, SO IT WAS A WONDERFUL COLLABORATION THERE. AGAIN, GOING INTO THE WAIVER REQUEST. SO WE HAVE SEVEN WAIVER REQUESTS TONIGHT. FOUR OF THOSE ARE TO DO WITH SIGNAGE. AND WE'LL GO INTO EACH ONE OF THOSE. AND THEN ONE TO DO WITH PARKING AS WELL AS THE BUILDING PLACEMENT, THE SETBACK. SO WE'LL START WITH THE SIGNAGE. THIS IS OUR MASTER SIGNAGE PLAN. THE LOCATIONS OF ALL OUR PROPOSED SIGNS. WE HAVE BUILDING ID SIGNS, THE EMERGENCY SIGNS, OUR GROUND MONUMENT SIGNS, AND THEN OUR BUILDING DIRECTIONAL SIGNS AROUND THE SITE TO LET TO NAVIGATE FOR PEOPLE COMING IN. SO THE WAIVERS ARE FOR OUR BUILDING ID SIGNS AND THE SIZE OF OUR DIRECTIONAL SIGNS. SO STARTING WITH THE BUILDING ID SIGNS WERE PERMITTED ONE SIGN PER BUILDING. AND SO WHEN YOU'RE APPROACHING THE SITE, IT'S REALLY CRITICAL THAT WE HAVE SIGNAGE ON THE EXTERIOR OF THE BUILDINGS FOR PEOPLE ARRIVING TO THE SITE. THEY CAN SEE THE BUILDING, THEY KNOW WHAT IT IS, BUT ALSO ONCE THEY ENTER THE SITE AGAIN HAVING SIGNAGE FACING INTERIOR TO WHERE THEY CAN AGAIN NAVIGATE TO WHERE THEY NEED TO GO. THE DIRECTIONAL SIGN. THE PRIMARY REASON FOR THE WAIVER IS WE'RE CREATING A LARGER DIRECTIONAL SIGN WHERE THE MAXIMUM ALLOWED BY CODE IS FOUR SQUARE FEET. WE'RE PROPOSING 6.85FT², AND THE REASON BEING THE SIZE OF THE LETTERS OF THE EMERGENCY. SO WE WERE TRYING TO MAINTAIN A MINIMUM SIX INCH LETTER HEIGHT FOR PEOPLE ARRIVING THROUGH VEHICLE THAT CAN SEE THAT THEY CAN IDENTIFY IT QUICKLY, ANYTHING SMALLER. AND WE START TO WORRY WITH THE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND FIRE DEPARTMENT, CAN PEOPLE REALLY NAVIGATE THAT? SO THAT WAS A REQUEST BY THE CITY AND WE REALLY HAD TO MAKE IT A LARGER SIGN. SOME OF THE ADDITIONAL WAIVERS REGARDING BUILDING PLACEMENT. SO THE HOSPITAL BUILDING, WE ARE OUTSIDE OF OUR BUILD TWO ZONE. [03:00:03] SO WE'RE REQUIRED A 0 TO 30 FOOT FRONT BUILD TO ZONE. AND SO THAT BUILDING IS PLACED FURTHER BACK FROM THE EDGE OF THE PROPERTY LINE THAN WE'RE PERMITTED. AND THE PRIMARY REASON FOR THAT IS 360 DEGREE ACCESS INTO THAT HOSPITAL BUILDING. IT'S REALLY CRITICAL THAT WE HAVE THAT CIRCULATION. AND SO WITH THAT, THERE'S NO WAY THAT WE CAN PUT THAT BUILDING UP AGAINST NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD. ADDITIONALLY, WITH THAT, THERE'S AN ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT WITH THAT FRONT BUILD TO ZONE THAT AT LEAST 50% OF THE BUILDING MUST BE WITHIN THAT FRONT BUILDING ZONE. SO BECAUSE OF THAT, WE'RE REQUIRED A WAIVER FOR THAT AS WELL. AND THEN FINALLY WE'RE REQUESTING A WAIVER FOR THE EMPLOYEE PARKING AREA, WHERE WE HAVE SEVERAL ROWS OF PARKING OF TEN SPACES IN A ROW BEFORE A LANDSCAPE ISLAND WHERE THE CODE MAXIMUM IS NINE. SO WE WORKED WITH STAFF TO IDENTIFY A SOLUTION FOR THAT PARKING AREA TO WHERE WE WERE MAXIMIZING THE SPACE. BEING AN EMPLOYEE AREA, BUT STILL PROVIDING THE NECESSARY LANDSCAPE THAT'S REQUIRED. AND SO WE HAVE EXCEEDED THAT LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENT AS PART OF THAT WAIVER REQUEST. SO THAT CONCLUDES OUR PRESENTATION. I'M SURE THERE'S A LOT OF OTHER INFORMATION THAT WE CAN INCLUDE, BUT IF ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE WE'D LOVE TO ANSWER THEM. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH, GEORGE BRETT. DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO ADD, MADAM MAYOR? NO. NO ADDITIONAL COMMENTS FROM STAFF GEORGE COVERED EVERYTHING. WOULD JUST LIKE TO TO REITERATE WHAT HE SAID FROM OUR BEHALF, WORKING WITH GEORGE KOLLER AND HEARING THE ENTIRE TEAM TO GETTING THE SITE PLAN WHERE IT IS. I THINK IT'S A IT'S A GREAT SITE PLAN, VERY EFFICIENT AND GREAT ADDITION TO AVENIR. GREAT. WE LOVE TO HEAR IT. THANK YOU. I WILL ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. GREAT. WONDERFUL. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS SO LET'S GO AHEAD. CAN I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 65 2023? I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 65 2023. THANK YOU. MARCIE CARL. ALL RIGHT. GREAT. LET'S HAVE A LITTLE DISCUSSION. DO WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? I THINK, MARCY, YOU MADE THE MOTION. DO YOU WANT TO GO FIRST? SURE. I JUST HAVE A FEW MINOR QUESTIONS. HOW MANY EMPLOYEES WILL THERE BE? APPROXIMATELY. THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION. WE HAVE WAYNE AND MALCOLM HERE TONIGHT THAT MIGHT BE ABLE TO PROVIDE A LITTLE BIT MORE COVER ON THAT. WE DID HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE HERE TONIGHT FROM GMC WHO I DON'T BLAME THEM FOR WANTING TO GO HOME EARLY. THEY HAD TO LEAVE EARLY. SO SIR MALCOLM SIGNED WITH SIGNING COMPANIES. YEAH. THE REPRESENTATIVE FROM GMC HAS BACK PROBLEMS SO SHE COULDN'T SIT THROUGH THE ENTIRE SESSION TONIGHT. SO SHE APOLOGIZES AT FULL CAPACITY. THE NEIGHBORHOOD HOSPITAL IS ESTIMATED TO HAVE ABOUT 50 EMPLOYEES. SORRY, 50 OR 15. 5050, THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT. OKAY. AND IS THERE GOING TO BE SECURITY THAT THE HOSPITAL HIRES? JUST I'M CONSIDERING, LIKE THE EMPLOYEES PARKING IN THE BACK. I KNOW HOSPITALS ARE 24 OVER SEVEN AND EMPLOYEES ARE ALSO NURSES. DOCTORS LEAVE AND COME AND GO AT ALL THE EMPLOYEES. EVERYTHING WILL BE KEYCARD ACCESS, CARD ACCESS OKAY. AND NO ON SITE SECURITY FOR THE PARKING LOT OR ANYTHING. NOT THAT WE'RE AWARE OF. OKAY. THANK YOU. THOSE ARE MY QUESTIONS, BURT. QUESTION FOR STAFF. THE MEDICAL BUILDINGS YOU HAVE ONE TWO STORY, ONE THREE STORY. IS IT POTENTIAL? THE HOSPITAL COULD GO HIGHER THAN THE TWO STORY WHERE IT IS NOW? IS THERE ROOM FOR EXPANSION WITH MORE BEDS? THERE IS. OKAY. THERE IS A PROPOSED 3000 SQUARE FOOT EXPANSION THAT IS INCLUDED. THAT WOULD BE TO THE SOUTH OF THE EXISTING BUILDING. AND ALL OF THAT SQUARE FOOTAGE IS INCLUDED IN THE PARKING DATA AND ALL THE SITE DATA AND TRAFFIC ANALYSIS. SO WE'VE LOOKED AT THAT. AND IN ADDITION, IT'S BEING BUILT OUT WITH 20 BEDS INITIALLY WITH THE POTENTIAL TO GO TO 29. AND THAT'S ALSO COUNTED IN, IN ALL OF THE THE PARKING AND TRAFFIC ANALYSIS AS WELL. OKAY. SO THE PARKING IT COULD HOLD IF THEY DO AN EXPANSION, THERE'S ENOUGH PARKING TO COVER ALL THAT. YES. AND IN THE FUTURE, FUTURE. THE DESIGN GUIDELINES ALLOW UP TO FOUR STORIES. AND SO IF THERE EVER IS A NEED FROM THE MARKET OR THERE'S A WILLINGNESS TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL METHODS FOR PARKING, THERE IS OPPORTUNITY IN THE SITE FOR INFILL AND FURTHER EXPANSION. OF COURSE, THAT HAS TO BE CALCULATED AND ACCEPTED AND PROPOSED BY THE APPLICANT. BUT THE TOOLS, THE ZONING TOOLS ARE THERE TO ALLOW FOR THAT. YEAH, THEY'RE NOT RESTRICTED. SO THEY WANT TO EXPAND. THERE'S A POTENTIAL TO DO SO. YEAH. AND FOR CLARIFICATION THE ADDITIONAL NINE BEDS WOULD BE ON THE SECOND LEVEL OKAY. SO NOT NOT ABOVE OKAY. I WOULD ASSUME THE HOSPITAL IS PROBABLY GOING TO HAVE AN HOUR OPEN FROM 8 A.M. TO 10 P.M. AND THEY SHUT DOWN AND THEN IT'S KEYCARD ACCESS. SO FROM A SECURITY STANDPOINT I THINK I THINK THAT'S SOMETHING LIKE THAT MIGHT BE IN PLACE. YEAH. IT'S NOT GOING TO BE CLOSED 24 OVER SEVEN TO VISITORS. OBVIOUSLY YOU WANT VISITORS TO COME IN AND SEE INDIVIDUALS, BUT IT'S GOING TO BE SOME LOCKDOWN TIME, I WOULD IMAGINE AT NIGHT WITH SECURITY TO GET IN. [03:05:07] THAT'S WHAT WE'RE ASSUMING FROM GMC. OKAY. THE ONLY QUESTION I HAVE I'M SORRY. GO AHEAD. I'M SORRY. THE GROUND FLOOR WILL INCLUDE EVERYTHING OTHER THAN THE BEDS WHICH WILL BE ON THE SECOND FLOOR. GOTCHA. AND IN TERMS OF LIGHTING, I GUESS THE SIGNS ARE LIT. THE EMERGENCY, THEY'RE GOING TO BE LIT ALL AROUND THE PROPERTY. OKAY. THAT'S ALL I HAD. I JUST TO ADD COMMENTS, I KNOW WE'RE GOING TO VOTE ON THIS QUICKLY, BUT IT'S IT'S A PERFECT LOCATION. I KNOW WE HAD PEOPLE FROM BAY HILL COME IN HERE MONTHS AGO, AND WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE PROJECT TO THE EAST OF THEM THAT ENDED UP BEING MULTIFAMILY THAT WE APPROVED. THERE WAS CONVERSATIONS ABOUT PUTTING MEDICAL ON THAT SITE, AND WE KNOW THIS SITE BEING ALL INCLUSIVE WILL TAKE A LOT LESS TRAFFIC THAN THE OTHER SITE IF WE PUT IT ON THE NORTH LAKE. SO THIS IS A WIN WIN. IT'S A IT'S A GREAT FACILITY. SO I'M IN FAVOR OF IT. SO GOOD LUCK. THANK YOU. GREAT. THANK YOU DANA I LOVE SEEING THIS COME TOGETHER. IT LOOKS LIKE A GREAT PROJECT. CONGRATULATIONS. IT LOOKS REALLY NICE. JUST A SILLY QUESTION ABOUT COVERED PARKING. SO WHY ONLY THAT MANY COVERED PARKING SPOTS AND WHY NOT? MORE OR LESS. HOW DO YOU HOW DID YOU COME UP WITH THAT STAFF COULD COULD ADD TO THIS, BUT WE'RE ALLOWED A MAXIMUM 5% OF OUR PARKING SPACES AS COVERED. AND SO WE'VE KIND OF HIT THAT MAXIMUM NUMBER. AND THAT'S THAT'S THE REASON THEY ARE HOW MANY THERE ARE. OKAY. YEAH THAT'S ALL. THANK YOU DANA CARL. I LIKE IT. GEORGE DID A GREAT JOB AND I LIKE THE WAY YOU'RE CONFIDENT IN YOUR PRESENTATION. THE SETBACKS ARE REASONABLE AND MAKE PERFECT SENSE, AND THE REQUEST FOR THE EXTRA SIGNAGE AND THE SIZE OF THE SIGNS, OBVIOUSLY, ARE COMMON SENSE. I DO LIKE THE SETBACK OFF OF NORTH LAKE BOULEVARD BECAUSE I'M. MR. FERRIS HAS BEEN DOING SETBACKS FOR 20 SOMETHING YEARS, AND THAT'S THE WHY WE DON'T SEE STUFF, BECAUSE THEY'RE SETBACKS. I DO LIKE IT A LOT. YOU DID A GREAT JOB AND I'M GOING TO APPROVE IT. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. MARCI. I JUST WANTED TO ADD, I GUESS I'M TIRED, SO I FORGOT THE TWO OTHER POINTS. I DO WANT TO SAY THAT I DO APPRECIATE MORE WAYFINDING THAN NOT. AND SO I'M 100% SUPPORTIVE OF THAT AND ALWAYS WILL BE. AND ALSO, I, I VERY MUCH APPRECIATE AND THINK YOU DID A WONDERFUL JOB ADDING A PEDESTRIAN TRAIL AROUND THE LAKE. I THINK THAT'S A VERY THOUGHTFUL APPROACH FOR THE GUESTS THAT ARE THERE, BUT ALSO FOR THE EMPLOYEES THAT MIGHT NEED A BREAK FROM THEIR VERY STRESSFUL, TOUGH JOB. SO I APPRECIATE YOU ADDING THAT. ALL RIGHT. GREAT POINTS ALL AROUND. SO WE HAVE NO FURTHER DISCUSSION. LET'S GO AHEAD AND TAKE A VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR. AYE. ANY OPPOSED. MOTION PASSES FIVE ZERO UNANIMOUSLY. CONGRATULATIONS ON BEING THE FIRST MAJOR EMPLOYER IN AVENIR. THAT'S GREAT. THANK YOU. YOU GOT IT. ALL RIGHT. GOOD. OH, THERE IT IS. LET'S GO TO RESOLUTION 60 EIGHT, 2023. RESOLUTION 60 EIGHT, 2023 RESOLUTION. [VIII.n. *RESOLUTION 68, 2023 – AVENIR PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT (PCD) POD 20 - REQUESTING APPROVAL FOR MODEL HOMES. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING A SITE PLAN AMENDMENT FOR SINGLE-FAMILY HOME FLOOR PLANS, ARCHITECTURAL ELEVATIONS, TYPICAL LOT LANDSCAPING, RESIDENTIAL ENTRY FEATURES, AND A SALES CENTER WITH MODEL HOMES FOR POD 20 WITHIN THE RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT (PARCEL A) OF THE AVENIR PLANNED COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT (PCD), LOCATED SOUTHEAST OF THE INTERSECTION OF AVENIR DRIVE AND PANTHER NATIONAL BOULEVARD, THE AVENIR PCD BEING GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF NORTHLAKE BOULEVARD, EAST OF GRAPEVIEW BOULEVARD, WEST OF BAY HILL DRIVE, AND SOUTH OF BEELINE HIGHWAY, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN; PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.] THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING A SITE PLAN AMENDMENT FOR SINGLE FAMILY HOME FLOOR PLANS, ARCHITECTURAL ELEVATIONS, TYPICAL LOT LANDSCAPING, RESIDENTIAL ENTRY FEATURES, AND A SALES CENTER WITH MODEL HOMES FOR POD 20 WITHIN THE RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT. PARCEL A OF THE AVENIR PLAN. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PCD LOCATED SOUTHEAST OF THE INTERSECTION OF AVENIR DRIVE AND PANTHER NATIONAL BOULEVARD. THE AVENIR PCD BEING GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF NORTH LAKE BOULEVARD, EAST OF GRAPEVIEW BOULEVARD, WEST OF BAYHILL DRIVE, AND SOUTH OF BEELINE HIGHWAY AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN, PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. GREAT, PATTY, THANK YOU SO MUCH. LET'S OPEN THE HEARING. WE'RE GOING TO START WITH EX PARTE. YOU LIKE TO START ON MY RIGHT MARCY. I'M GOING TO SAY ROSA SCHECTER OKAY GREAT. SO BERT EX PARTE FOR RESOLUTION 68. NONE FOR ME. DANA. NONE. BERT I MEAN CARL. PLEASE. HE JUST GOT BETTER LOOKING OVERNIGHT. COME ON. CARL. EX PARTE NEGATIVE. THANK YOU, SIR, AND I HAVE NONE I APOLOGIZE. ALL RIGHT. WE DO HAVE A PRESENTATION THIS EVENING. GOOD EVENING AND HAPPY HOLIDAYS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. FOR THE RECORD, MY NAME IS MARTY MINER. I'M WITH THE URBAN DESIGN STUDIO. I HAVE A VERY BRIEF PRESENTATION REGARDING AVENIR POD 20. I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AVENUE AVENIR POD 20. ABOUT A YEAR AGO, YOU APPROVED THEIR SITE PLAN FOR 144 SINGLE FAMILY HOMES ON 51 ACRES. THE PLAT WAS APPROVED IN MARCH OF THIS YEAR, AND A MONTH LATER IT WAS TRANSFERRED TO KE AVENIR LLC, WHO IS THE APPLICANT FOR THIS APPLICATION? THEY ARE A SUBSIDIARY OF KOLTER HOMES. [03:10:02] OKAY. JUST BRIEFLY, YOU LOOK AT THERE'S TWO TYPES OF LOTS ON THESE HOMES, 65 FOOT LOTS YOU SEE IN THE TAN ON YOUR SCREEN. AND THE YELLOWS ARE THE 55 FOOT WIDE LOTS. AND THIS IS AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF PANTHÉON NATIONAL AND AVENIR DRIVE. AND THOSE TWO ROADS ARE UNDER CONSTRUCTION RIGHT NOW. OUR REQUEST TODAY ARE FOR THE ELEVATIONS FOR TEN ARCHITECTURAL MODELS, INCLUDING THE TYPICAL LOT LANDSCAPING PLANS, THE RESIDENTIAL ENTRY FEATURE, AND THE MODEL ROAD AND SALES CENTER. ARCHITECTURAL MODELS. LIKE I SAID, THERE'S TEN MODELS TO REVIEW FROM, BUT THERE'S EVEN ANOTHER OPTION FOR THAT FOR A SECOND STORY. BONUS ROOM IN THE 55 FOOT LOTS, YOU HAVE SIX MODELS ON THE 55 SIX MODELS, 65 FOOT LOTS FOR MODELS, AND THERE'S THREE ARCHITECTURAL THEMES THAT I'LL GO THROUGH QUICKLY THE SIZES. THE SMALLEST IS THE EMILY MODEL, WHICH IS A TWO BEDROOM, TWO BATH AT 6000 HUNDRED AND 68FT². THE LARGEST IS THE SYDNEY IS THREE BEDROOM, THREE AND A HALF BATH JUST UNDER 2800FT². ON THE 55 FOOT LOTS. HERE ARE SOME OF THE RENDERINGS. YOU SEE THE DIFFERENT ARCHITECTURAL STYLES AND THE LOT LANDSCAPING YOU'RE GOING TO. FOR SOME OF THE TREES YOU'LL HAVE WAX MYRTLES, GREEN BUTTONWOODS, A JAPANESE FERN, SOUTHERN MAGNOLIAS. YOU'RE ALSO GOING TO SEE MULTI-TRUNK ROW, CHRISTMAS PALMS AND ALEXANDER PALMS, ALONG WITH SOME SABLES AND OTHERS. BUT WE DO MEET AND EXCEED ALL THE CITY'S REQUIREMENTS FOR LOT LANDSCAPING. THIS IS A TYPICAL STREET SCENE. YOU WOULD SEE THE DIFFERENT MODELS, THE DIFFERENT STYLES FOR EACH OF THE HOMES, FOR THE 55 FOOT LOTS, ON THE 65 FOOT LOTS WE HAVE THE FOUR MODELS. THEY ARE A LITTLE BIT LARGER, BUT THEY ALSO MEET AND EXCEED THE LANDSCAPING REQUIREMENTS. ANOTHER QUICK LANDSCAPE STREETSCAPE OF WHAT 65 FOOT LOTS? ALL THE VARIOUS OPTIONS HERE. IN ADDITION TO THE TEN MODELS, THE THREE ARCHITECTURAL STYLES, YOU ALSO HAVE ANTI MONOTONY STANDARDS THAT WILL HAVE THREE MODELS IN A ROW. YOU CAN'T HAVE THE SAME ELEVATION THEME ACROSS THE STREET, SO A LOT OF VARIETY IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. ARCHITECTURAL THEMES ARE TROPICAL MODERN MEDITERRANEAN FLORA VERNACULAR SORT OF INCORPORATE THOSE ASPECTS OF THOSE TYPES OF ARCHITECTURES INTO THE MODELS, EVEN THE COLOR STYLES. EACH THEME HAS FIVE COLORS. THE SCHEMES. THE FLORIDA VERNACULAR IS MORE OF A COASTAL COOL SCHEME. MEDITERRANEAN IS A WARM COLOR AND AND TROPICAL MODERN IS MORE OF A NEUTRALS. AS YOU GO INTO THE SYDNEY MODEL, THE LARGEST MODEL. THIS IS THE VARIOUS FRONT ELEVATIONS THAT SHOW THE DIFFERENT STYLES. JUST HOW THE SAME FLOOR PLAN CAN LOOK VERY DIFFERENT. AS I MENTIONED THE ARCHITECTURAL THEMES AND COLORS. IT GOES FROM THE STORES, THE TILES, THE PAVERS, EVERYTHING HAS BEEN CALLED OUT AND WE'VE WORKED VERY CLOSELY WITH STAFF TO MAKE THIS ALL RIGHT. ENTRY SIGN VERY QUICKLY. THERE'S TWO MAIN ENTRANCES, ONE OFF OF AVENIR DRIVE, ONE OFF THE PANTHER NATIONAL BOULEVARD. THERE IS A SECONDARY EXIT EMERGENCY ACCESS ALSO ON PANTHER NATIONAL BOULEVARD. BUT AT THESE TWO MAIN ENTRANCES, YOU'LL HAVE A SIGN FOR COLOMBIANS IN AVENIR. I PROBABLY DID NOT PRONOUNCE THAT RIGHT, BUT IT MEETS ALL THE CITY STANDARDS. IT MEETS THE AVENIR SIGN CODE BY INCLUDING THE LIGHT STONE THAT YOU SEE ON ALL THE OTHER SIGNS IN THE PROJECT, AND ALSO IT REFLECTS SOME OF THE INTERESTING. THERE'S A PORCELAIN METALLIC BANDING ON THERE. IT GIVES IT A LITTLE OOMPH. WE THOUGHT. MODEL ROW. ONE MORE THING. THERE'S FIVE LOTS IS DESIGNATED AS MODEL ROW ONE IS A TEMPORARY PARKING LOT THAT WILL, AFTER USE, BE REPLACED WITH A HOME. AND THE FOUR UNITS THERE. AND WE'VE PROVIDED SIGNAGE. VERY UNDERSTATED, BUT TO HELP DIRECT PEOPLE ONCE THEY GET TO THE MODEL ROW AREA. STAFF IS RECOMMENDING APPROVAL THROUGH PLANNING BOARD RECOMMENDED APPROVAL. AND I HAVE NO WAIVERS. OKAY. WOW. NO WAIVERS. ALL RIGHT. BRETT, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO ADD? THERE ARE NO ADDITIONAL COMMENTS. AGAIN, I WANT TO THANK THE APPLICANT FOR WORKING WITH US. [03:15:02] AND STAFF RECOMMENDS APPROVAL. ALL RIGHT. LIKE WE SAID, WE'D LOVE TO HEAR THAT. I DO NOT HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS. SO LET'S GO AHEAD. CAN I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 68 2023? I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 68 2023 A SECOND. GREAT. LET'S HAVE A CHAT. SEE, MARCY, YOU MADE THE MOTION TO GO FIRST. OKAY, I REALLY DON'T HAVE MANY QUESTIONS. JUST ONE QUESTION IN REGARDS TO THE GATE, I KNOW. SHOCKER. CAN YOU JUST CLARIFY THE THE GATE ITSELF? IS IT KEY FOB OR IS IT A STICKER? HOW DOES IT OPERATE? WAS THAT? GOOD EVENING COUNCIL. FOR THE RECORD, SCOTT MORTON WITH KOLTER HOMES. ANSWER YOUR QUESTION. WE EMPLOY A EMBARRASS SYSTEM FOR CALL BOX FOR FOR VISITORS TO COME. SO THEY PULL UP, THEY'RE ACTUALLY TALKING TO A REMOTE GUARD. AND THEN THE RESIDENTS GOING THROUGH THE RESIDENTS LANE. THEY HAVE CLICKERS TO COME THROUGH. AND OF COURSE, THEN WE'LL HAVE KNOCKS ENTRANCES FOR THE KNOW FOR FIRE AND EMERGENCY ACCESS. AND IS THE STACKING THE CODE REQUIRED? I KNOW IT'S CODE REQUIRED, BUT DOES IT EXCEED CODE? IT DOES IT SLIGHTLY. IT DOES EXCEED CODE THAT WAS APPROVED WITH THE SITE PLAN. AND THERE'S NO CHANGE. I JUST DIDN'T ASK THE LAST TIME, SO I FIGURED I'D GET AN OPPORTUNITY AGAIN. THANK YOU. OKAY, PERFECT. AND I DO HAVE ONE MORE QUESTION. WHO ARE THESE MODELS? MODEL HOMES NAMED AFTER RILEY. SIDNEY. WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE? ANYBODY KNOW HOW MANY DAUGHTERS? THAT'S ALL I WANT TO KNOW IN THE FAMILY. HOW MANY DAUGHTERS IN THE FAMILY? OUR MARKETING DEPARTMENT COMES UP WITH THE NAMES, YOU KNOW. SO. SO NOBODY IN PARTICULAR? NO. JUST CURIOUS. WE WANT TO FIND OUT THE STORY, I DON'T KNOW. AND THEN I ALSO, ON A SERIOUS NOTE, I DO WANT TO SAY I APPRECIATE THE HAVING BEEN A VOLUNTEER ON MY ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD FOR MY HOA. I DO REALLY APPRECIATE THE COMPREHENSIVE EXHIBIT ON THE COLORS AND THE ROOFS AND EVERYTHING. I KNOW IT'S A LOT OF WORK AND IT'S A LOT OF EFFORT AND IT'S HARD TO PUT TOGETHER. BUT THIS COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH DOES REALLY HELP GOING FORWARD WITH THOSE THAT TAKE OVER THE COMMUNITY AFTER THE DEVELOPER LEAVES. SO I APPRECIATE THAT. ALL RIGHT. THANKS, MARCIE. NO NOTHING. JUST BEAUTIFUL PROJECT. SO GOOD LUCK WITH EVERYTHING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU DANA CARL. NOPE. EXCITED TO SEE IT COME TOGETHER. ALL RIGHT. I HAD ALL THE EXACT SAME QUESTIONS AS MARCIE, SO I'M GOOD TO GO. NO, I LIKE IT. IT'S NICE. ALL RIGHT. I LOVE SEEING THE ANTI MONOTONY. I LIVE IN A NEIGHBORHOOD THAT HAS MONOTONY. AND THERE ARE FUNNY STORIES ABOUT PEOPLE COMING INTO TOWN THAT ARE VISITORS AND THEN TRYING TO GO BACK INTO THE HOUSE THAT THEY THOUGHT THEY LEFT TO GO RETRIEVE SOMETHING OR VISIT THE LADIES ROOM. AND, YOU KNOW, LO AND BEHOLD, THEY'RE DOING THEIR BUSINESS AND THEY FIND OUT THEY'RE IN THE WRONG HOUSE. SO THIS MATTERS. I KNOW IT SOUNDS SILLY, AND IT'S SOMETHING THAT I THINK YOU GUYS HAVE ACTUALLY DONE A REALLY GREAT JOB PRESENTING IN A WAY THAT HOPEFULLY WILL KEEP SEEING MORE AND MORE OF THAT. SO THAT'S IT. LET'S TAKE IT TO VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. CONGRATULATIONS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU SO MUCH. MOVING ALONG TO RESOLUTION 70 2023, RESOLUTION 70 2023, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL, THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE [IX.a. RESOLUTION 70, 2023 – CONVEYANCE OF ENVIRONMENTAL PRESERVE AT AVENIR. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE CONVEYANCE OF THE AVENIR CONSERVATION AREA TO THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS; APPROVING TWO (2) GRANTS OF EASEMENT FOR THE AVENIR CONSERVATION AREA; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. ] CONVEYANCE OF THE AVENIR CONSERVATION AREA TO THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS. APPROVING TWO GRANTS OF EASEMENT FOR THE AVENIR CONSERVATION AREA, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE FOR THE PURPOSES. I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING. MAX. ABOUT ME. YOU CAN GO FIRST, RON. THE NON-LEGAL PART. WE'RE HAPPY TO INTRODUCE TO YOU THE CONVEYANCE OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PRESERVE AT AVANIR. THE PICTURE YOU SEE HERE BEFORE YOU IS A LOT EASIER TO UNDERSTAND THAN THE MULTIPLE PICTURES AND PIECES OF THE PICTURES THAT ARE A PART OF YOUR PACKET. HERE YOU SEE THE PROPERTY OUTLINED IN RED IS WHAT IS BEING CONVEYED TO US AT THIS TIME. THE PART IN BLUE WILL BE HELD BACK UNTIL AFTER THE ROAD IS DESIGNED AND BUILT, AND THE CROSS OVER THE CSX ONTO B LINE IS COMPLETED, AND THAT PORTION OF THE PROPERTY WILL BE DEEDED TO THE CITY. ALSO, THERE'S A COUPLE OF EASEMENTS HERE THEY NEED TO FINISH. 100% OF THE RESTORATION EFFORTS IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL PRESERVE. AND OTHER THAN THAT, I THINK IT'S A GREAT ADDITION TO THE CITY FOR THE CITY TO OWN THE ENVIRONMENTAL PRESERVE. WE'RE WORKING ON SOME PROGRAM IDEAS AND TRAIL IDEAS ALREADY. [03:20:05] STAFF IS ALREADY WORKING ON AN ALMOST FINISHED WITH GRANT PROPOSALS TO TO UTILIZE THE PROPERTY FOR SOME GOOD EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES, AND WE'LL BE BRINGING THAT TO YOU IN THE FUTURE. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, MAX WOULD BE HAPPY TO ANSWER THEM FOR YOU. DON'T MISS ANYTHING, MAX. NO, DON'T. OKAY, SO YEAH, IT'S PRETTY SIMPLE. ALL THIS IS DOING IS THERE'S A DEED WHERE THEY'LL BE DEEDING THIS PROPERTY TO US, AND THEN WE'RE GOING TO GRANT THEM BACK TO EASEMENTS SO THAT THEY CAN, AS RON SAID, COMPLETE THEIR ENVIRONMENTAL MITIGATION. AND THEN ALSO IT ALLOWS THEM TO RETAIN THE MITIGATION CREDIT BANK BECAUSE THEY'VE GOT UNUSED CREDITS FOR THE THEY'LL BE ABLE TO UTILIZE. I GOT IT. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU GUYS SO MUCH. WE DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT CARDS. MAKE IT A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE, PLEASE. I'LL MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 70 2023. SECOND. ALL RIGHT, SO, MARCY, I SEE YOU'VE GOT YOUR LIGHT STILL ON. DO YOU HAVE DO YOU HAVE QUESTIONS? JUST TO CLARIFY, AND I SHOULD HAVE ASKED THIS BEFORE, BUT THE DEVELOPMENT ORDER THAT PUTS THE CONSERVATION EASEMENT IN PERPETUITY, IN CONSERVATION IN PERPETUITY STAYS EXACTLY AS THAT, IN PERPETUITY, EVEN THOUGH IT DOESN'T CHANGE. NO, MA'AM. YEAH. OKAY. I JUST WANTED TO CLARIFY, AND I JUST WANT TO ALSO SAY THANK YOU GUYS. THANK YOU, AVENIR, AND THANK YOU TO STAFF FOR MAKING THIS COME TO FRUITION, BECAUSE HAVING THOUSANDS MORE ACRES OF CONSERVATION IN OUR CITY IS JUST A WONDERFUL OPPORTUNITY FOR ALL OF US, FOR OUR FUTURE, FOR OUR CHILDREN'S FUTURE RESIDENTS FUTURE. AND I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE WHAT COMES TO FRUITION ON THIS PROPERTY. I'M REALLY LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. SO I APPRECIATE ALL OF YOUR EFFORTS. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE? THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR COMING TONIGHT AND HANGING IN THERE JUST SO YOU COULD BE HERE FOR THE CHERRY ON TOP OF THE EVENING. WE APPRECIATE IT. OKAY. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE, AYE. ANY OPPOSED? MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THAT'S PRETTY EXCITING STUFF. WOW. ALL RIGHT. NEXT WE HAVE ITEMS FOR COUNCIL ACTION DISCUSSION. CARL. IT'S GOING TO BE OKAY. [X. ITEMS FOR COUNCIL ACTION/DISCUSSION AND ITEMS OF INTEREST] WE'LL GO REAL FAST IF THERE IS ANYTHING. DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING? DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING FOR. COME ON MARCY DOES I DO I DO OH GO AHEAD. NO I JUST WANT TO THANK STAFF FOR THE TREE LIGHTING ON SATURDAY. THAT WAS A WONDERFUL EVENT. AND I'M GOING TO BEAT MARCY TO THE HAPPY HOLIDAYS FOR EVERYBODY AND A HAPPY NEW YEAR TO EVERYBODY. SO THANK YOU. OH THANK YOU. SORRY OKAY GREAT. THANK YOU. AND I WANTED TO SAY HAPPY HOLIDAYS I WISH EVERYONE A VERY HAPPY HEALTHY BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY A SAFE HOLIDAY SEASON. AND I WANTED TO EXTEND AN INVITATION ON SUNDAY. WE ARE GOING TO HAVE WELL NOT WE, BUT THERE ARE A FEW PEOPLE THAT PUT TOGETHER A HANUKKAH EVENT FROM 5 TO 6. OUR FORMER MAYOR AND I JUST WANTED HE ASKED ME TO EXTEND THE INVITATION TO EVERYONE HERE. SO I WANTED TO. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED INFORMATION, I'M HAPPY TO SHARE IT WITH YOU. THANKS, MARCY. ANYBODY ELSE? ALL RIGHT, 1 OR 2 QUICK THINGS I WANT TO THANK LAURIE FOR PUTTING TOGETHER PAY IT FORWARD. IT WAS GREAT TO SUPPORT A WONDERFUL NONPROFIT THAT EVERY PIE THAT ANYONE IN OUR CITY PURCHASED, OR TO UTILIZE THE CITY AREA FOR PICKUP, PROVIDED A WEEK'S WORTH OF HOT MEALS FOR A HOMEBOUND SENIOR. SO THANK YOU FOR MAKING THAT HAPPEN AND VOLUNTEERING ON THE SUNDAY AND THE GREEN MARKET AS WELL. WE REALLY APPRECIATE THAT. ALSO, EVERYBODY, PLEASE BE PART OF THE HOLIDAY JOY DRIVE WE'RE COLLECTING HERE IN THE CITY THROUGH DECEMBER 22ND. THE FOUNDATION IS ACCEPTING IT AT OUR FIRE STATION, POLICE DEPARTMENT, HEADQUARTERS, CITY HALL AND MORE CAN BE FOUND ONLINE. NOT THAT ANYONE'S LISTENING OR WATCHING. AND THEN LASTLY, I HAD THE HONOR OF SPEAKING ABOUT OUR TOD AND SUSTAINABILITY EFFORTS AT NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES, AND IT WAS JUST SUCH A PRIVILEGE TO TALK ABOUT ALL THE GREAT THINGS THAT OUR STAFF AND OUR COUNCILS HAVE BEEN DOING OVER THE YEARS. SO THANK YOU ALL FOR ALL OF YOUR HARD WORK AND HAPPY EVERYTHING. MAX, DO WE HAVE A CITY ATTORNEY APPOINT REPORT TONIGHT? NO. JUST WISH EVERYBODY A MERRY CHRISTMAS AND A HAPPY HANUKKAH, A HAPPY HOLIDAYS AND SEE YOU GUYS IN JANUARY. SEE YOU NEXT YEAR. ALL RIGHT, LET'S CLOSE. THIS MEETING IS ADJOURNED. THANK YOU. * This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.